Lemma 7.10 ([Efimov (2024), Proposition 2.65]). Let \(I\) be a directed poset, let \(I \to \PrL _{\st }\), \(i \mapsto C_i\), be a diagram with transition functors \(F_{ij}\colon C_i \to C_j\), let \(C := \colim _i C_i\) in \(\PrL _{\st }\), and let \(F_i\colon C_i \to C\) be the structure functors.
- (1)
-
The counits induce an equivalence \(\colim _i F_iF_i^R \simeq \id _C\).
- (2)
-
If the functors \(F_{ij}\) are strongly continuous, then for all \(i,j \in I\) there is a natural equivalence \[ \colim _{k \geq i,j} F_{jk}^RF_{ik} \simeq F_j^RF_i. \]
Proof.
We identify \(C\) with \(\lim _i C_i\), taken along the functors \(F_{ij}^R\), so that \(F_i^R\) becomes the projection. Mapping spectra in this limit are the limits of the mapping spectra.
(1) For \(i \leq j\), the counit of \(F_{ij} \dashv F_{ij}^R\) induces a map \(F_iF_i^R \simeq F_jF_{ij}F_{ij}^RF_j^R \to F_jF_j^R\), so the functors \(F_iF_i^R\) form an \(I\)-indexed diagram with a cocone to \(\id _C\), given by the counits. For \(x,y \in C\) we get natural equivalences \[ \hom _C\big (\colim _i F_iF_i^Rx,y\big ) \simeq \lim _i \hom _C(F_iF_i^Rx,y) \simeq \lim _i \hom _{C_i}(F_i^Rx,F_i^Ry) \simeq \hom _C(x,y), \] whose composite is induced by the cocone. By the Yoneda lemma, the cocone exhibits \(\id _C\) as the colimit.
(2) By Proposition 7.1(1), the functors \(F_i\) are strongly continuous, so the projections \(F_j^R\) preserve colimits, and the transition functors \(F_{jj'}^R\) of the limit preserve colimits by assumption. Fix \(i\), and for \(x \in C_i\) consider the family of objects \[ F_i'(x)_j := \colim _{k \geq i,j} F_{jk}^RF_{ik}(x) \in C_j, \qquad j \in I. \] For \(k \leq \ell \), the transition map in this colimit is \[ F_{jk}^RF_{ik} \longrightarrow F_{jk}^RF_{k\ell }^RF_{k\ell }F_{ik} \simeq F_{j\ell }^RF_{i\ell }, \] induced by the unit of \(F_{k\ell } \dashv F_{k\ell }^R\). The units for composites give these diagrams coherently. For \(j \leq j'\), we have \(F_{jj'}^R F_i'(x)_{j'} \simeq \colim _{k \geq i,j'} F_{jk}^RF_{ik}(x) \simeq F_i'(x)_j\), using that \(F_{jj'}^R\) preserves colimits and that \(\{k \geq i,j'\} \subseteq \{k \geq i,j\}\) is cofinal. These identifications are induced by restriction to common cofinal tails and the composition isomorphisms for right adjoints. Their compatibility for chains of indices follows from that of the units above and the universal property of colimits. Thus they define a functor \(F_i'\colon C_i \to \lim _j C_j \simeq C\), and the claim is equivalent to \(F_i' \simeq F_i\). We show that \(F_i'\) is left adjoint to \(F_i^R\). For \(x \in C_i\) and \(y = (y_j)_j \in C\), we have \begin {align*} \hom _C(F_i'x,y) &\simeq \lim _j \hom _{C_j}\Big (\colim _{k \geq i,j} F_{jk}^RF_{ik}x,\, y_j\Big ) \\ &\simeq \lim _{(j,k) \in P\catop } \hom _{C_j}(F_{jk}^RF_{ik}x,y_j) \\ &\simeq \lim _{j \geq i} \hom _{C_j}(F_{ij}x,y_j) \simeq \lim _{j \geq i} \hom _{C_i}(x,F_{ij}^Ry_j) \\ &\simeq \hom _{C_i}(x,y_i) = \hom _{C_i}(x,F_i^Ry). \end {align*}
Here \(P = \{(j,k) \mid i \leq j \leq k\}\), with the product order. In the second step we first restrict the limit over \(j\) to the cofinal subset \(I_{\geq i}\). The functor \((j,k) \mapsto \hom _{C_j}(F_{jk}^RF_{ik}x,y_j)\) is contravariant in \((j,k)\). In the third step we restrict along the diagonal \(I_{\geq i} \to P\), \(j \mapsto (j,j)\), which is cofinal: for \((j,k) \in P\), the poset of \(m \geq i\) with \((j,k) \leq (m,m)\) is \(I_{\geq k}\), which is directed and hence weakly contractible. Thus the opposite of the diagonal is initial, as required for this limit over \(P\catop \). On the diagonal, \(F_{jj}^R = \id \). The fourth step is the adjunction \(F_{ij} \dashv F_{ij}^R\), and the remaining diagram is constant with value \(\hom _{C_i}(x,y_i)\), as \(F_{ij}^Ry_j \simeq y_i\). The unit of the resulting adjunction \(F_i' \dashv F_i^R\) is the map \(x \to F_i'(x)_i\) from the summand \(k=i\). To identify the resulting isomorphism with the canonical map, use the cocones \[ F_{jk}^RF_{ik} \longrightarrow F_{jk}^RF_k^RF_kF_{ik} \simeq F_j^RF_i, \] induced by the unit of \(F_k \dashv F_k^R\). They define \(F_i' \to F_i\), and at \(j=k=i\) carry the unit just described to the unit of \(F_i \dashv F_i^R\). By the adjunction, this map is the isomorphism between the two left adjoints. Evaluating at the \(j\)-th component proves the claim with its canonical cocone. ā”