Lemma 6.5. Let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal category whose homotopy category is idempotent complete; for instance, \(C\) stable and idempotent complete [Lurie (2017), Lemma 1.2.4.6]. Then an object \(x \in C\) is dualizable if and only if \(\id _x\) is trace-class.

Proof.

If \(x\) is dualizable with dual \(x^{\vee }\), then the coevaluation and evaluation are a witness for \(\id _x\). Conversely, let \((z,\alpha ,\beta )\) be a witness for \(\id _x\), so that \(\alpha \colon \unit \to x \otimes z\) and \(\beta \colon z \otimes x \to \unit \) satisfy the first triangle identity \((x \otimes \beta )(\alpha \otimes x) \simeq \id _x\), but not necessarily the second one. Consider \[ e := (\beta \otimes z)(z \otimes \alpha )\colon z \to z \otimes x \otimes z \to z. \] Inserting the first triangle identity in the middle of \(e \circ e\) shows that \(e \circ e \simeq e\), and similarly \(\beta (e \otimes x) \simeq \beta \) and \((x \otimes e)\alpha \simeq \alpha \). As the homotopy category is idempotent complete, \(e\) splits: \(e \simeq sr\) with \(r\colon z \to z'\), \(s\colon z' \to z\) and \(rs \simeq \id _{z'}\). Put \(\alpha ' := (x \otimes r)\alpha \) and \(\beta ' := \beta (s \otimes x)\). Then \[ (x \otimes \beta ')(\alpha ' \otimes x) \simeq (x \otimes \beta )(x \otimes e \otimes x)(\alpha \otimes x) \simeq (x \otimes \beta )(\alpha \otimes x) \simeq \id _x \] and \((\beta ' \otimes z')(z' \otimes \alpha ') \simeq r e s \simeq rsrs \simeq \id _{z'}\). So \((\alpha ',\beta ')\) exhibits \(z'\) as a dual of \(x\); since dualizability can be checked in the homotopy category, \(x\) is dualizable. ā–”