Let \(A \to B\) be a map of \(\bbE _1\)-rings, and consider the base change functor \(B \otimes _A -\colon \D (A) \to \D (B)\) between the categories of left modules, with right adjoint the restriction functor \(\res \colon \D (B) \to \D (A)\). Recall from Definition 2.16 that \(A \to B\) (or rather \(\Perf (A) \to \Perf (B)\)) is a homological epimorphism if \(B \otimes _A -\) is a localization, i.e. if \(\res \) is fully faithful. Since \(\res \) preserves colimits, this is equivalent to the counit \(B \otimes _A \res (N) \to N\) being an equivalence for all \(N \in \D (B)\), and since both sides preserve colimits in \(N\) and \(\D (B)\) is generated by \(B\), this is in turn equivalent to the multiplication map \[ B \otimes _A B \to B \] being an equivalence. In the language of Clausen, \(A \to B\) is then called idempotent.

Proposition 5.1. Let \(A \to B\) be a homological epimorphism of \(\bbE _1\)-rings, and put \[ \D (A \to B) := \ker \big (B \otimes _A -\colon \D (A) \to \D (B)\big ). \] Then \(\D (A \to B)\) is dualizable, and the sequence \(\D (A \to B) \hookrightarrow \D (A) \to \D (B)\) is a strongly continuous localization sequence. In particular, \[ K^{\cont }(\D (A \to B)) \simeq \fib \big (K(A) \to K(B)\big ). \]

Proof.

The functor \(B \otimes _A -\) is a localization by assumption, and it is strongly continuous since its right adjoint \(\res \) preserves colimits. Hence \(\D (A \to B) \hookrightarrow \D (A) \to \D (B)\) is a strongly continuous localization sequence (Lemma 2.13), and \(\D (A \to B)\) is dualizable by Proposition 3.19. The final statement follows from the definition of \(K^{\cont }\), see Section 1.4. □

Proposition 5.2. Every dualizable category is of the form \(\D (E \to E')\) for some homological epimorphism \(E \to E'\) of \(\bbE _1\)-rings.

Proof.

Let \(C\) be dualizable. Choose a set \(S\) of representatives of the isomorphism classes of \(C^{\omega _1}\), a regular cardinal \(\kappa > |S|\), and put \(G := \bigoplus _{x \in S} x\). As a \(\kappa \)-small sum of \(\kappa \)-compact objects, \(G\) is \(\kappa \)-compact. Let \(A \subseteq C^{\kappa }\) be the thick subcategory generated by \(G\); it contains \(C^{\omega _1}\), since every object of \(C^{\omega _1}\) is a retract of \(G\). The functor \(\hat {y}\colon C \to \Ind (C^{\kappa })\) takes values in \(\Ind (C^{\omega _1}) \subseteq \Ind (A)\) (Theorem 3.20, see also [Efimov (2024), Corollary 2.14]), and hence is a fully faithful left adjoint of \(\colim \colon \Ind (A) \to C\). Its essential image \(\hat {y}(C)\) is closed under colimits, with right orthogonal \(\ker (\colim \colon \Ind (A) \to C)\). Since the latter is closed under colimits in \(\Ind (A)\), the localization \[ Q\colon \Ind (A) \to \Ind (A)/\hat {y}(C) \simeq \ker (\colim ) \] has a colimit-preserving right adjoint and thus preserves compact objects. As \(Q\) is essentially surjective and \(\Ind (A)\) is compactly generated by \(G\), the category \(\ker (\colim )\) is compactly generated by the single object \(Q(G)\). Hence \(\ker (\colim ) \simeq \Ind (B)\) for \(B\) the thick subcategory generated by \(Q(G)\), and \(Q\) is \(\Ind \) of a homological epimorphism \(A \to B\) with kernel \(\hat {y}(C) \simeq C\); this is the Calkin sequence of Theorem 3.16 with \(C^{\kappa }\) replaced by \(A\). Finally, by Morita theory [Lurie (2017), Theorem 7.1.2.1] we have \(\Ind (A) \simeq \D (E)\) for \(E := \End (G)\catop \) and \(\Ind (B) \simeq \D (E')\) for \(E' := \End (Q(G))\catop \), under which \(Q\) corresponds to \(E' \otimes _E -\), where the ring map \(E \to E'\) is induced by \(Q\) on endomorphisms. Indeed, \(Q(G)\) has the resulting \(E\)-action, so the two colimit-preserving functors agree on the generator together with its endomorphism action, as required by Morita theory. So \(C \simeq \D (E \to E')\). □

There is a convenient criterion for a map \(A \to B\) with fiber \(I\) to be a homological epimorphism. Recall that a non-unital ring spectrum \(I\) is called h-unital if the multiplication \(I \otimes _{\S \oplus I} I \to I\) is an isomorphism, where \(\S \oplus I\) denotes the unitalization. Equivalently, the nonunital relative tensor product, defined by the semisimplicial bar construction with terms \(I^{\otimes (n+2)}\), maps isomorphically to \(I\); see [Krause et al. (2024), Section 2.10 and Lemma 3.5.5].

Theorem 5.3 ([Krause et al. (2024), Section 2.10, especially Corollary 2.10.6]). For a non-unital ring spectrum \(I\), the following are equivalent:

(1)

\(I\) is h-unital;

(2)

the map \(\S \oplus I \to \S \) is a homological epimorphism;

(3)

for every fiber sequence \(I \to A \to B\) in which \(A \to B\) is a map of unital ring spectra, the map \(A \to B\) is a homological epimorphism.

Conversely, if \(A \to B\) is a homological epimorphism of connective ring spectra and \(\pi _0(A) \to \pi _0(B)\) is surjective, then \(\fib (A \to B)\) is h-unital [Krause et al. (2024), Proposition 2.10.7]. The surjectivity hypothesis cannot be omitted: the fiber of \(k[t]\to k[t,t^{-1}]\) is not h-unital [Krause et al. (2024), Example 2.10.8].

Example 5.4. The following maps are homological epimorphisms, and hence give rise to dualizable categories \(\D (A \to B)\):

(1)

A localization \(A \to A[S^{-1}]\) of a commutative ring at a multiplicative subset. More generally, if \(A\) is a commutative Noetherian ring, the kernel of every homological epimorphism out of \(A\) is compactly generated: the associated localization of \(\D (A)\) is smashing, so this follows from [Neeman (1992), Theorem 3.3 and Corollary 3.4].

(2)

A surjection \(A \twoheadrightarrow B\) of perfect \(\F _p\)-algebras: the higher \(\mathrm {Tor}^A\)-groups between perfect \(A\)-algebras vanish by [Bhatt and Scholze (2017), Lemma 3.16], so \(B \otimes ^{\bL }_A B \simeq B\). Similarly, if \(A\) is an integral perfectoid ring and \(B\) is a perfect \(\F _p\)-algebra, any surjection \(A \twoheadrightarrow B\) is a homological epimorphism. Indeed, the derived \(p\)-completed tensor product of perfectoid rings is discrete by the proof of [Bhatt and Scholze (2022), Lemma 10.3]. Here \(B \otimes ^{\bL }_A B\) is already derived \(p\)-complete, since it is a \(B\)-module, and its degree-zero homology is \(B\).

(3)

(Wodzicki) If \(A\) is a unital C\(^*\)-algebra and \(I \subseteq A\) a closed two-sided \(*\)-ideal, then \(A \to A/I\) is a homological epimorphism. For \(A = B(\Hh )\) and \(I = \Kk (\Hh )\), this gives the category \(\D (\Kk )\) from Example 1.14.

(4)

(Almost ring theory) If \(A\) is a ring and \(I \subseteq A\) is a two-sided ideal with \(I^2 = I\) which is flat as a left or right \(A\)-module, then \(A \to A/I\) is a homological epimorphism. We discuss this in detail in Section 5.2.