Proposition 11.1.4. Consider objects \(X\) and \(Y\) of \(C\) and consider a morphism \(\ev \colon Y \otimes X \to \unit \) in \(C\). The following conditions are equivalent:

(1)

The morphism \(\ev \colon Y \otimes X \to \unit \) exhibits \(Y\) as a dual to \(X\).

(2)

For all objects \(Z\) and \(W\) of \(C\), the composite \[ \Hom _{C}(W,Z \otimes Y) \xrightarrow {- \otimes X} \Hom _{C}(W \otimes X, Z \otimes Y \otimes X) \xrightarrow {\ev \circ -} \Hom _{C}(W \otimes X, Z) \] is an equivalence.

(3)

The map in (2) is an equivalence for \((W,Z) = (\unit ,X)\) and for \((W,Z) = (Y,\unit )\).

Proof. We first show that (1) implies (2). Let \(\coev \colon \unit \to X \otimes Y\) be the corresponding coevaluation map. It then follows directly from the triangle identities that an inverse to the map in (2) is given by the composite \[ \Hom _{C}(W \otimes X, Z) \xrightarrow {- \otimes Y} \Hom _{C}(W \otimes X \otimes Y, Z \otimes Y) \xrightarrow {- \circ \coev } \Hom _{C}(W,Z \otimes Y). \] The implication (2)\(\Rightarrow \)(3) is immediate. For (3)\(\Rightarrow \)(1), the first test produces the coevaluation and one triangle identity; the second detects the other triangle identity. Indeed, the test \((W,Z)=(\unit ,X)\) gives a map \(\coev \colon \unit \to X\otimes Y\) whose image is \(\id _X\), so the composite \[ X \xrightarrow {\coev \otimes \id } X \otimes Y \otimes X \xrightarrow {\id \otimes \ev } X \] is identified with \(\id _X\). The test \((W,Z)=(Y,\unit )\) gives an equivalence \[ \Hom _C(Y,Y) \xrightarrow {- \otimes X} \Hom _C(Y \otimes X, Y \otimes X) \xrightarrow {\ev \circ -} \Hom _C(Y \otimes X, \unit ). \] Both \(\id _Y\) and \((\ev \otimes \id )\circ (\id \otimes \coev )\) map to \(\ev \): for the latter, this follows from the first triangle identity and the commutative diagram

Commutative diagram involving Y tensor X, Y tensor X tensor Y tensor X, Ytensor X, unit, with arrows labeled identity tensor coev tensor identity, identity tensor identity tensor ev, ev tensor identity tensor identity, ev.

The two maps are therefore identified, proving the second triangle identity. β–‘