Remark 5.5.3. The hypothesis on fundamental groups cannot be dropped. For the commutative monoid \(\bigsqcup _{n\geq 0}\bB \Sigma _n\), the telescope is \(\Z \times \bB \Sigma _{\infty }\), whereas the group completion is its plus construction \(\Z \times \bB \Sigma _{\infty }^+\); these differ already on \(\pi _1\). See Nikolaus (2017), Proposition 6 for necessary and sufficient criteria.