Observation 8.1.8 (Graded homotopy rings). The homotopy groups of an associative ring spectrum \(R\) form a graded ring. For \(x\in \pi _p(R)\) and \(y\in \pi _q(R)\), the product \(xy\in \pi _{p+q}(R)\) is represented by \[ \S [p+q]\simeq \S [p]\otimes \S [q] \xrightarrow {x\otimes y}R\otimes R\xrightarrow {m}R. \] The same construction using the action map \(R\otimes M\to M\) makes \(\pi _*(M)\) a graded left \(\pi _*(R)\)-module for every left \(R\)-module \(M\), and similarly for right modules.
If \(R\) is commutative, then \(\pi _*(R)\) is graded-commutative: \[ xy=(-1)^{pq}yx. \] Indeed, interchanging \(\S [p]\) and \(\S [q]\) acts by \((-1)^{pq}\) on \(\S [p+q]\). For nonnegative \(p,q\), this is the degree of the permutation interchanging the two blocks of suspension coordinates; the general case follows by invertibility of suspension. See also Warning 4.2.11, Observation 16.6.7.