In classical algebra, given a commutative ring \(R\) and a multiplicative subset \(S \subseteq R\), one can form the localization \(R[S^{-1}]\), a new ring in which every element of \(S\) becomes invertible. We now develop the analogous construction for commutative ring spectra. This is the form needed in Chapter 9, where periodic complex K-theory is obtained by inverting the Bott element in connective complex K-theory.

We have already met a special case in Section 7.2: inverting a set of primes \(P\) on the sphere spectrum gives a mapping telescope \(\S [P^{-1}]\), and tensoring with this telescope is the corresponding reflection. The same two features persist here. Localization is smashing, and localization at a single homogeneous element is computed by a telescope.

The online version also treats localization of associative ring spectra at multiplicative subsets satisfying an Ore condition.

8.4.1 The commutative case

Let \(R\) be a commutative ring spectrum. Its homotopy groups form a graded-commutative ring, and the homotopy groups of an \(R\)-module form a graded module over it.

Definition 8.4.1. Let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a subset of homogeneous elements. We say that \(S\) is multiplicative if it contains the unit \(1 \in \pi _0(R)\) and is closed under multiplication.

For a homogeneous element \(s \in \pi _d(R)\), multiplication by \(s\) is already defined at the level of \(R\)-modules:

Observation 8.4.2. Choose a representative \(s\colon R[d]\to R\) of an element of \(\pi _d(R)\). Multiplication by \(s\) is the natural transformation of functors \(\Mod _R\to \Mod _R\) given by \[ s\colon M[d] \simeq R[d]\otimes _R M \xrightarrow {\ s \otimes \id \ } R \otimes _R M \simeq M. \] On homotopy groups this is the map \(x \mapsto s\cdot x\).

Definition 8.4.3. Let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements. An \(R\)-module \(N\) is \(S\)-local if multiplication by every \(s \in S\) is an isomorphism \[ s\colon N[\abs {s}] \iso N. \] This condition is independent of the chosen representatives of the elements of \(S\). Equivalently, multiplication by every \(s \in S\) is an isomorphism on the graded group \(\pi _*(N)\). We write \(\Mod _R^{\Loc (S)} \subseteq \Mod _R\) for the full subcategory of \(S\)-local modules.

Proposition 8.4.4 (Commutative localization is smashing). Let \(R\) be a commutative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements.

(1)

The inclusion \(\Mod _R^{\Loc (S)} \hookrightarrow \Mod _R\) admits a left adjoint \[ S^{-1}(-)\colon \Mod _R \longrightarrow \Mod _R^{\Loc (S)}. \] The subcategory \(\Mod _R^{\Loc (S)}\) admits a symmetric monoidal structure with tensor product \(\otimes _R\) and unit \(S^{-1}R\). The localization functor is symmetric monoidal and the inclusion is lax symmetric monoidal.

(2)

The localization is smashing: for every \(M \in \Mod _R\), the map \[ M \simeq M \otimes _R R \xrightarrow {\ \id _M \otimes \,\eta _R\ } M \otimes _R S^{-1}R \] exhibits \(M \otimes _R S^{-1}R\) as the \(S\)-localization of \(M\). In particular, \[ S^{-1}M \simeq M \otimes _R S^{-1}R \] naturally in \(M\).

Proof. For every \(s \in S\) of degree \(d\) and every \(n \in \Z \), consider the shifted multiplication map \[ s[n]\colon R[d+n] \longrightarrow R[n]. \] An \(R\)-module is local with respect to this small collection of morphisms precisely when it is \(S\)-local: allowing all shifts means that locality tests multiplication by \(s\) on every homotopy group. Since \(\Mod _R\) is presentable by Proposition 17.1.17, Theorem 23.2.2(4) provides the asserted reflection \(S^{-1}(-)\).

The symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(\Mod _R\) is closed, as recalled after Corollary 17.2.19. If \(N\) is \(S\)-local and \(P\) is any \(R\)-module, then \(\iHom _R(P,N)\) is again \(S\)-local. Indeed, under the natural isomorphism \[ \iHom _R(P,N)[d] \iso \iHom _R(P,N[d]), \] multiplication by \(s\) is obtained by applying \(\iHom _R(P,-)\) to the isomorphism \(s\colon N[d] \iso N\). The internal-hom criterion Lemma 14.7.3 therefore gives the symmetric monoidal structure and the symmetric monoidality of the localization.

It remains to prove the smashing formula. The unit \(\eta _R\colon R \to S^{-1}R\) is an \(S\)-local equivalence, and the proof of the internal-hom criterion shows that \(S\)-local equivalences remain so after tensoring with any \(R\)-module. Consequently, \[ \id _M\otimes \eta _R\colon M\longrightarrow M\otimes _R S^{-1}R \] is an \(S\)-local equivalence. Its target is \(S\)-local: multiplication by \(s\) on \(M\otimes _R S^{-1}R\) is obtained by tensoring \(\id _M\) with the isomorphism \(s\colon (S^{-1}R)[\abs {s}]\iso S^{-1}R\). A local equivalence from \(M\) to a local object exhibits that object as the reflection of \(M\), which proves the claim. □

We can now localize in commutative ring spectra.

Corollary 8.4.5 (Localization of a commutative ring spectrum). In the situation of Proposition 8.4.4, the \(R\)-module \(S^{-1}R\) carries a canonical structure of a commutative ring spectrum \(R[S^{-1}]\), and the localization map refines to a morphism \[ \eta \colon R \longrightarrow R[S^{-1}] \] in \(\CAlg (\Sp )\). It has the following universal property: for every commutative ring spectrum \(A\), precomposition with \(\eta \) induces a monomorphism of animae \[ -\circ \eta \colon \Hom _{\CAlg (\Sp )}(R[S^{-1}],A) \hookrightarrow \Hom _{\CAlg (\Sp )}(R,A) \] whose image consists of those maps \(f\colon R \to A\) for which \(\pi _*(f)\) carries every element of \(S\) to a unit of \(\pi _*(A)\).

Proof. By Proposition 8.4.4, the reflection \[ S^{-1}(-)\colon \Mod _R \longrightarrow \Mod _R^{\Loc (S)} \] is a symmetric monoidal Bousfield localization. The Part II result Corollary 17.2.19 therefore equips \(S^{-1}R\) with a commutative \(R\)-algebra structure and characterizes it as initial among commutative \(R\)-algebras whose underlying modules are \(S\)-local. Under the equivalence \[ \CAlg (\Mod _R)\simeq \CAlg (\Sp )_{R/}, \] this gives the asserted morphism \(\eta \colon R\to R[S^{-1}]\) of commutative ring spectra.

Let \(f\colon R\to A\) be a morphism of commutative ring spectra. Its underlying \(R\)-module is \(S\)-local if and only if \(\pi _*(f)\) sends every \(s\in S\) to a unit. One direction is immediate. Conversely, suppose that \(A\) is \(S\)-local and let \(s'=\pi _*(f)(s)\) have degree \(d\). Since multiplication by \(s'\) is bijective, there is an element \(u\in \pi _{-d}(A)\) such that \(s'u=1\). Since \(s'(us'-1)=0\), injectivity of multiplication by \(s'\) gives \(us'=1\). Thus \(s'\) is a unit.

The initial property of \(S^{-1}R\) among commutative \(R\)-algebras with local underlying module now gives the claimed factorization property. Conversely, every morphism that factors through \(R[S^{-1}]\) inverts \(S\), since the image of \(S\) in \(\pi _*(R[S^{-1}])\) consists of units and ring morphisms preserve units. □

Finally, we record the computation used for Bott inversion.

Lemma 8.4.6 (Inverting a single element). Let \(R\) be a commutative ring spectrum, let \(s \in \pi _d(R)\) be a homogeneous element, and let \(S := \{1,s,s^2,\dots \}\) be the multiplicative subset it generates. Then for every \(M \in \Mod _R\) the canonical map exhibits the telescope \[ M[s^{-1}] := \colim \bigl (M \xrightarrow {\ s\ } M[-d] \xrightarrow {\ s\ } M[-2d] \xrightarrow {\ s\ } \cdots \bigr ) \] as the \(S\)-localization of \(M\). On homotopy groups it is given by graded localization: \[ \pi _*(M[s^{-1}]) \cong \pi _*(M)[s^{-1}]. \]

Proof. The transition maps are shifts of the module map of Observation 8.4.2, so the telescope is a colimit in \(\Mod _R\). Since homotopy groups preserve filtered colimits by Lemma 4.4.28, we have \[ \pi _k(M[s^{-1}]) \cong \colim \bigl (\pi _k(M)\xrightarrow {\ s\cdot \ }\pi _{k+d}(M) \xrightarrow {\ s\cdot \ }\pi _{k+2d}(M)\longrightarrow \cdots \bigr ), \] which is the degree-\(k\) part of \(\pi _*(M)[s^{-1}]\). In particular, multiplication by \(s\) on \(M[s^{-1}]\) is an isomorphism, so the telescope is \(S\)-local.

Let \(N\) be any \(S\)-local \(R\)-module. Mapping out of the telescope gives \[ \Hom _{\Mod _R}(M[s^{-1}],N) \simeq \lim _j\Hom _{\Mod _R}(M[-jd],N). \] Every transition map in this limit is an equivalence, because under the shift adjunction it is induced by the isomorphism \(s\colon N[d]\iso N\). Evaluation at the zeroth term therefore gives an equivalence \[ \Hom _{\Mod _R}(M[s^{-1}],N) \iso \Hom _{\Mod _R}(M,N), \] induced by precomposition with the canonical map \(M\to M[s^{-1}]\). This is the universal property of the \(S\)-localization. □

Corollary 8.4.7 (Homotopy groups of a localization). Let \(R\) be a commutative ring spectrum, let \(S\subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements, and let \(M\) be an \(R\)-module. There is a natural isomorphism of graded modules \[ \pi _*(S^{-1}M)\cong S^{-1}\pi _*(M). \] For \(M=R\), this identifies \(\pi _*(R[S^{-1}])\) with the graded ring \(S^{-1}\pi _*(R)\).

Proof. For a finite subset \(F\subseteq S\), successively applying Lemma 8.4.6 gives an \(F\)-localization \(M[F^{-1}]\) with homotopy groups \(\pi _*(M)[F^{-1}]\). Each step preserves locality for the elements already inverted, since their actions commute with the localization maps and filtered colimits preserve isomorphisms. The universal property makes these localizations functorial in \(F\).

The filtered colimit of \(M[F^{-1}]\) over the finite subsets of \(S\) is \(S\)-local: for each \(s\in S\), the subsets containing \(s\) are cofinal. Mapping into an \(S\)-local module identifies the hom anima out of each term with that out of \(M\), so this colimit is \(S^{-1}M\). Taking homotopy groups gives the asserted formula. For \(M=R\), the identification respects multiplication and hence is an isomorphism of graded rings. □

Remark 8.4.8. Combining Corollary 8.4.5 with Lemma 8.4.6 for \(M=R\), the telescope \[ R[s^{-1}] = \colim \bigl (R\xrightarrow {\ s\ }R[-d] \xrightarrow {\ s\ }R[-2d]\longrightarrow \cdots \bigr ) \] is formed in \(\Mod _R\) and acquires its commutative ring structure from its identification with the localization. The map \(R\to R[s^{-1}]\) is a morphism of commutative ring spectra, and \[ \pi _*(R[s^{-1}])\cong \pi _*(R)[s^{-1}]. \]

8.4.2 Ore localization (online only)

We now extend localization to associative ring spectra. Module localization exists for every multiplicative subset \(S\subseteq \pi _*(R)\). Under the left Ore condition introduced below, its kernel consists precisely of the \(S\)-nilpotent modules, and for ordinary rings it recovers the classical construction of fractions.

Definition 8.4.9 (Localization of a ring spectrum). Let \(R\) be a ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements. The localization of \(R\) at \(S\), denoted \(R[S^{-1}]\), is a ring spectrum equipped with a map of ring spectra \(\eta \colon R \to R[S^{-1}]\) that satisfies the following property: for every ring spectrum \(A\), precomposition with \(\eta \) induces a monomorphism of animae \[ - \circ \eta \colon \Hom _{\Alg }(R[S^{-1}],A) \hookrightarrow \Hom _{\Alg }(R,A) \] whose image consists of those algebra maps \(f\colon R \to A\) for which \(\pi _*(f)\) carries every element of \(S\) to a unit of the graded ring \(\pi _*(A)\).

In other words: an algebra map \(f\colon R \to A\) factors through \(\eta \) if and only if it inverts \(S\), and in that case the factorization is unique. Note that \(R[S^{-1}]\) is unique, if it exists. In an analogous way, we may define localization at the level of modules. Let us first introduce some terminology:

Definition 8.4.10. Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements.

(1)

A left \(R\)-module \(M\) is called \(S\)-nilpotent if for every element \(x \in \pi _n(M)\), there exists an element \(s \in S\) such that \(s \cdot x = 0\) in \(\pi _*(M)\).

(2)

A left \(R\)-module \(N\) is called \(S\)-local if, for every element \(s \in S\) of degree \(d\) and every \(k\in \Z \), left multiplication by \(s\) induces an isomorphism \[ s\cdot -\colon \pi _k(N)\iso \pi _{k+d}(N). \]

We denote by \(\LMod _R^{S\dnil }\) and \(\LMod _R^{\Loc (S)}\) the full subcategories of \(\LMod _R\) spanned by the \(S\)-nilpotent and \(S\)-local modules, respectively.

When \(R\) is commutative, the second condition agrees with the definition given in the previous subsection. For a general associative ring spectrum, however, left multiplication by \(s\) on \(N\) need not be a morphism of left \(R\)-modules, which explains the formulation in terms of homotopy groups. Equivalently, the underlying map of spectra \(s\colon N[\abs {s}]\to N\) is an isomorphism for every \(s\in S\). There is also an intrinsic reformulation in \(\LMod _R\): right multiplication by \(s\in \pi _d(R)\) defines a morphism \(\cdot s\colon R[d]\to R\) of left \(R\)-modules, and \(N\) is \(S\)-local precisely when it is local with respect to all shifts of these morphisms.

Both conditions are formulated purely in terms of the graded \(\pi _*(R)\)-module \(\pi _*(M)\), and this makes them stable under all the operations we will need:

Observation 8.4.11. The subcategories \(\LMod _R^{S\dnil }\) and \(\LMod _R^{\Loc (S)}\) are stable subcategories of \(\LMod _R\), closed under all small colimits.

Proof. Both subcategories contain zero and are closed under shifts. Consider an exact sequence \(M'\to M\to M''\). If \(M'\) and \(M\) are \(S\)-local, the five lemma applied to multiplication by each \(s\in S\) on the long exact sequence shows that \(M''\) is \(S\)-local.

If \(M'\) and \(M\) are \(S\)-nilpotent, take \(x\in \pi _n(M'')\) and choose \(s\in S\) annihilating its boundary in \(\pi _{n-1}(M')\). Then \(sx\) lifts to an element \(y\in \pi _{n+\abs {s}}(M)\). Choosing \(t\in S\) with \(ty=0\) gives \((ts)x=0\). Thus \(M''\) is \(S\)-nilpotent. These arguments use only vanishing, so the suspension signs in the boundary maps do not affect them.

Both subcategories are therefore stable and closed under finite colimits. They are closed under filtered colimits because homotopy groups preserve these colimits: invertibility of each action passes to the colimit, and every element in a filtered colimit comes from a stage where it is annihilated by an element in \(S\). Arbitrary coproducts are filtered colimits of finite coproducts. Closure under coproducts and finite colimits now implies closure under all small colimits. □

Definition 8.4.12. Let \(R\) be a ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements. Given a left \(R\)-module \(M\), its \(S\)-localization is an \(S\)-local left \(R\)-module \(S^{-1}M\) equipped with a morphism of left \(R\)-modules \(\eta \colon M \to S^{-1}M\) satisfying the property that for every other \(S\)-local left \(R\)-module \(N\), precomposition with \(\eta \) induces an equivalence of animae \[ - \circ \eta \colon \Hom _{\LMod _R}(S^{-1}M,N) \iso \Hom _{\LMod _R}(M,N). \]

The localization exists for every multiplicative subset \(S\): the local objects are those local with respect to the small collection of all shifts of \(\cdot s\colon R[\abs {s}]\to R\), so presentability gives a reflection by Theorem 23.2.2(4). The left Ore condition below will identify the kernel of this reflection with the \(S\)-nilpotent modules.

Definition 8.4.13 ([Lurie (2017), Definition 7.2.3.1, Remark 7.2.3.7]). Let \(A_*\) be a graded associative ring and let \(S \subseteq A_*\) be a set of homogeneous elements which contains the unit and is closed under multiplication. We say that \(S\) satisfies the left Ore condition if the following hold:

(a)

For every pair of elements \(x \in A_*\) and \(s \in S\), there exist elements \(y \in A_*\) and \(t \in S\) such that \(tx = ys\).

(b)

If \(xs = 0\) for some \(x \in A_*\) and \(s \in S\), then there exists some \(t \in S\) such that \(tx=0\).

It suffices to check these conditions for homogeneous \(x\), in which case \(y\) in part (a) may also be chosen homogeneous. An ordinary ring is regarded as concentrated in degree zero.

This seemingly purely algebraic condition can be conveniently rephrased in terms of \(S\)-nilpotent modules. For an element \(s \in S\) of degree \(d\), we denote by \(R/Rs\) the cofiber of the map of left \(R\)-modules \(\cdot s\colon R[d] \to R\) given by right multiplication by \(s\), i.e., the cofiber of the following composite \[ \cdot s\colon R[d] \simeq R \otimes \S ^d \xrightarrow {\id \otimes s} R \otimes R \xrightarrow {m} R. \]

Lemma 8.4.14 ([Lurie (2017), Lemma 7.2.3.11]). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements. The following conditions are equivalent:

(1)

The set \(S\) satisfies the left Ore condition.

(2)

For every element \(s \in S\), the left \(R\)-module \(R/Rs\) is \(S\)-nilpotent.

Proof. For each homogeneous \(s\in S\), the long exact sequence of \(R[d]\xrightarrow {\cdot s}R\to R/Rs\) expresses \(\pi _*(R/Rs)\) as an extension of the cokernel of right multiplication by \(s\) by a shift of its kernel. Condition (a) says precisely that every element of this cokernel is annihilated on the left by an element of \(S\): the class of \(x\) is killed by \(t\) exactly when \(tx=ys\) for some \(y\). Condition (b) says the same for the kernel.

Elementwise \(S\)-nilpotence is preserved by submodules, quotients, and extensions. For the last assertion, first annihilate the image of an element in the quotient, then annihilate its lift in the submodule; the product of the two annihilators lies in \(S\). Consequently, \(\pi _*(R/Rs)\) is \(S\)-nilpotent if and only if both the kernel and cokernel are. This proves the equivalence. □

The previous lemma says that under the Ore condition the modules \(R/Rs\) are \(S\)-nilpotent. In fact they generate all \(S\)-nilpotent modules, in the explicit sense of the following lemma. This lemma is the main technical input of this section, and we use it as a black box.

Lemma 8.4.15 ([Lurie (2017), Lemma 7.2.3.13]). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset satisfying the left Ore condition. Then every \(S\)-nilpotent left \(R\)-module \(M\) can be written as the colimit of a sequence of left \(R\)-modules \[ 0 = M_0 \to M_1 \to M_2 \to \cdots \] in which the fiber of each map \(M_i \to M_{i+1}\) is a coproduct of modules of the form \((R/Rs_{\alpha })[n_{\alpha }]\) with \(s_{\alpha } \in S\) and \(n_{\alpha } \in \Z \). In particular, \(\LMod _R^{S\dnil }\) is generated under colimits by the set of objects \[ \{\, (R/Rs)[n] \mid s \in S, \, n \in \Z \,\}. \]

Proposition 8.4.16 ([Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.2.3.14]). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset satisfying the left Ore condition. Let \(N\) be a left \(R\)-module. Then the following conditions are equivalent:

(1)

The module \(N\) is \(S\)-local.

(2)

For every element \(s \in S\) and every integer \(n\), the hom anima \(\Hom _{\LMod _R}((R/Rs)[n], N)\) is contractible.

(3)

For every \(S\)-nilpotent module \(M \in \LMod _R\), the hom anima \(\Hom _{\LMod _R}(M,N)\) is contractible.

Proof. Let \(s \in S\) be an element of degree \(d\). Applying the mapping spectrum functor \(\hom _{\LMod _R}(-,N)\) to the exact sequence \[ R[d] \xrightarrow {\cdot s} R \to R/Rs \] and using the identifications \(\hom _{\LMod _R}(R,N) \simeq N\) and \(\hom _{\LMod _R}(R[d],N)\simeq N[-d]\) gives an exact sequence of spectra \[ \hom _{\LMod _R}(R/Rs,N)\longrightarrow N \xrightarrow {\ s\cdot -\ }N[-d]. \] The second map is left multiplication by \(s\): precomposition with right multiplication \(\cdot s\colon R[d]\to R\) sends a map \(f\colon R \to N\) to the map determined by \(f(s) = s \cdot f(1)\).

Condition (1) says precisely that the second map is an isomorphism for every \(s\in S\), which by exactness is equivalent to the vanishing of \(\hom _{\LMod _R}(R/Rs,N)\). Since a spectrum vanishes if and only if all the animae \(\Omega ^{\infty }(-[-n])\) do, this is in turn equivalent to \(\Hom _{\LMod _R}((R/Rs)[n],N)\) being contractible for all \(n\). This proves \((1) \Leftrightarrow (2)\).

To prove the implication \((3) \Rightarrow (2)\), we observe that since \(S\) satisfies the left Ore condition, the module \(R/Rs\) is \(S\)-nilpotent for every \(s \in S\), as established in Lemma 8.4.14. As \(\LMod _R^{S\dnil }\) is closed under shifts (Observation 8.4.11), condition (3) applied to \(M = (R/Rs)[n]\) immediately yields condition (2).

For \((2)\Rightarrow (3)\), the modules \(M\) for which \(\Hom _{\LMod _R}(M,N)\) is contractible are closed under colimits. By Lemma 8.4.15, they therefore include every \(S\)-nilpotent module. □

Under the left Ore condition, every module decomposes into an \(S\)-nilpotent part and an \(S\)-local part:

Proposition 8.4.17 ([Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.2.3.17, Remark 7.2.3.18]). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset satisfying the left Ore condition. Then for every left \(R\)-module \(M\), there exists an exact sequence in \(\LMod _R\) \[ M' \to M \to M'', \] where \(M'\) is \(S\)-nilpotent and \(M''\) is \(S\)-local.

Proof. By Lemma 8.4.15, the \(\infty \)-category \(\LMod _R^{S\dnil }\) is the localizing subcategory generated by the set of objects \(\{ (R/Rs)[n] \mid s \in S, n \in \Z \}\). It is therefore presentable by Proposition 23.2.7(2). Its inclusion into \(\LMod _R\) preserves colimits by Observation 8.4.11, so Theorem 23.2.5 gives a right adjoint \(G\). For any module \(M\), the counit of this adjunction gives a map \(G(M) \to M\). We define \(M' := G(M)\) and we let \(M''\) be the cofiber of this map. It remains to show that \(M''\) is \(S\)-local, for which we use criterion (3) from Proposition 8.4.16. Let \(N\) be an \(S\)-nilpotent left \(R\)-module. Applying \(\hom _{\LMod _R}(N,-)\) provides an exact sequence of spectra \[ \hom _{\LMod _R}(N,M') \to \hom _{\LMod _R}(N,M) \to \hom _{\LMod _R}(N,M''). \] Both functors in the adjunction are exact, so the adjunction is enriched in spectra. The first map is therefore an isomorphism, and it follows that \(\hom _{\LMod _R}(N,M'') = 0\), as desired. □

Remark 8.4.18. The pair \((\LMod _R^{S\dnil },\LMod _R^{\Loc (S)})\) is a semiorthogonal decomposition: every module admits the functorial decomposition above, and the hom anima from an \(S\)-nilpotent module to an \(S\)-local module is contractible. Both subcategories are stable. Thus this pair also defines a t-structure in the sense of Definition 6.3.1, with zero heart.

Corollary 8.4.19. Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S\subseteq \pi _*(R)\) satisfy the left Ore condition. In the decomposition \(M'\to M\to M''\) of Proposition 8.4.17, the map \(M\to M''\) exhibits \(M''\) as \(S^{-1}M\). In particular, the fiber of the localization map is \(S\)-nilpotent.

Proof. By Proposition 8.4.17 there is an exact sequence \(M' \to M \to M''\) of left \(R\)-modules such that \(M'\) is \(S\)-nilpotent and \(M''\) is \(S\)-local. We claim that \(M''\) is an \(S\)-localization. Indeed, for any other \(S\)-local left \(R\)-module \(N\), mapping into \(N\) provides a fiber sequence of animae \[ \Hom _{\LMod _R}(M'',N) \to \Hom _{\LMod _R}(M,N) \to \Hom _{\LMod _R}(M',N). \] But since \(M'\) is \(S\)-nilpotent, the anima \(\Hom _{\LMod _R}(M',N)\) is contractible by part (3) of Proposition 8.4.16. It follows that the first map is an equivalence, as desired. □

The proof exhibits the fiber of the localization map \(\eta _M\colon M \to S^{-1}M\) as the \(S\)-nilpotent part \(M'\) of \(M\). This gives the following recognition criterion:

Observation 8.4.20. Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) satisfy the left Ore condition. Then:

(1)

For \(M \in \LMod _R\) we have \(S^{-1}M = 0\) if and only if \(M\) is \(S\)-nilpotent.

(2)

A map \(f\colon M \to N\) of left \(R\)-modules becomes an isomorphism after \(S\)-localization if and only if \(\cofib (f)\) is \(S\)-nilpotent.

(3)

If \(T\) is an \(S\)-local module and \(f\colon M \to T\) is a map with \(S\)-nilpotent cofiber, then \(f\) exhibits \(T\) as the \(S\)-localization of \(M\).

Proof. (1) Write \(M' \to M \to S^{-1}M\) for the decomposition of Proposition 8.4.17. If \(M\) is \(S\)-nilpotent, then the counit \(M' = G(M) \to M\) of the coreflection is an isomorphism, so its cofiber \(S^{-1}M\) vanishes. Conversely, if \(S^{-1}M = 0\) then \(M' \to M\) is an isomorphism, so \(M\) is \(S\)-nilpotent.

(2) The functor \(S^{-1}(-)\) is a left adjoint between stable \(\infty \)-categories, hence preserves cofibers. Thus \(S^{-1}(f)\) is an isomorphism if and only if \(S^{-1}\cofib (f) \simeq \cofib (S^{-1}f)\) vanishes, which by (1) happens if and only if \(\cofib (f)\) is \(S\)-nilpotent.

(3) By (2) the map \(S^{-1}(f)\colon S^{-1}M \to S^{-1}T\) is an isomorphism, and the unit \(\eta _T\colon T \to S^{-1}T\) is an isomorphism because \(T\) is already \(S\)-local. Naturality of the unit gives \(\eta _T\circ f=S^{-1}(f)\circ \eta _M\). It follows that the isomorphism \(\eta _T^{-1}\circ S^{-1}(f)\colon S^{-1}M\to T\) identifies \(f\) with the localization map \(\eta _M\colon M\to S^{-1}M\). □

The existence of \(S\)-localizations of \(R\)-modules can be used to deduce the existence of localizations of ring spectra. Regarding \(R\) as a module over itself, applying the \(S\)-localization functor gives an \(S\)-local \(R\)-module \(S^{-1}R \in \LMod _R\). This object can be endowed with the structure of an associative ring spectrum, which we denote by \(R[S^{-1}]\).

Proposition 8.4.21 ([Lurie (2017), Remark 7.2.3.26, Proposition 7.2.3.27]). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset satisfying the left Ore condition. The \(S\)-localization \(S^{-1}R\) admits the structure of an associative ring spectrum, which we denote by \(R[S^{-1}]\). Furthermore, the canonical map \(R \to S^{-1}R\) can be enhanced to a morphism of associative ring spectra \[ \phi \colon R \to R[S^{-1}]. \] This morphism exhibits \(R[S^{-1}]\) as an \(S\)-localization of \(R\), in the sense of Definition 8.4.9.

We use this result as a black box, taking it directly from the cited reference. Constructing the coherently associative multiplication on \(S^{-1}R\) is the one step of the theory for which the module-theoretic arguments above do not suffice.

Finally, this abstract homotopical construction recovers the classical construction of fractions when applied to an ordinary associative ring and module.

Proposition 8.4.22 ([Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.2.3.20 and the proof of Proposition 7.2.3.5]). Let \(R\) be an ordinary associative ring and let \(S\subseteq R\) be a multiplicative subset satisfying the left Ore condition. For every ordinary left \(R\)-module \(M\), its localization \(S^{-1}M\) in module spectra is discrete and identifies naturally with the classical module of left fractions.