Lemma 8.4.14 ([Lurie (2017), Lemma 7.2.3.11]). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(S \subseteq \pi _*(R)\) be a multiplicative subset of homogeneous elements. The following conditions are equivalent:
- (1)
-
The set \(S\) satisfies the left Ore condition.
- (2)
-
For every element \(s \in S\), the left \(R\)-module \(R/Rs\) is \(S\)-nilpotent.
Proof. For each homogeneous \(s\in S\), the long exact sequence of \(R[d]\xrightarrow {\cdot s}R\to R/Rs\) expresses \(\pi _*(R/Rs)\) as an extension of the cokernel of right multiplication by \(s\) by a shift of its kernel. Condition (a) says precisely that every element of this cokernel is annihilated on the left by an element of \(S\): the class of \(x\) is killed by \(t\) exactly when \(tx=ys\) for some \(y\). Condition (b) says the same for the kernel.
Elementwise \(S\)-nilpotence is preserved by submodules, quotients, and extensions. For the last assertion, first annihilate the image of an element in the quotient, then annihilate its lift in the submodule; the product of the two annihilators lies in \(S\). Consequently, \(\pi _*(R/Rs)\) is \(S\)-nilpotent if and only if both the kernel and cokernel are. This proves the equivalence. □