A final functor allows us to change the indexing \(\infty \)-category of a diagram without changing its colimit. Initial functors have the analogous property for limits. The following form of Quillen’s Theorem A characterizes these functors in terms of relative slices; we take it as a black box:
Theorem 22.5.1 (Joyal’s version of Quillen’s Theorem A, [Lurie (2009b), Theorem 4.1.3.1]). For a functor \(\alpha \colon I \to J\), the following two conditions are equivalent:
- (1)
-
For every \(\infty \)-category \(C\) and every functor \(F\colon J \to C\), the functor \(F\) has a colimit if and only if \(F \circ \alpha \colon I \to C\) has a colimit, and in this case the canonical map \[ \colim _I (F \circ \alpha ) \to \colim _J F \] is an isomorphism in \(C\);
- (2)
-
For every object \(j\) of \(J\), the relative slice category \(I_{j/} = I \times _J J_{j/}\) is weakly contractible, meaning that its geometric realization \(\geom {I_{j/}}\) is contractible.
The dual result is also true, where in (1) we use limits and in (2) we use the over categories \(I_{/j}\).
Definition 22.5.2. A functor \(\alpha \) satisfying the conditions of the theorem is called final. We say that \(\alpha \) is initial if \(\alpha \catop \colon I\catop \to J\catop \) is final (i.e. each relative slice \(I_{/j}\) is weakly contractible, or equivalently limits of functors \(F\colon J \to C\) may be computed as limits of \(F \circ \alpha \colon I \to C\)).
Lemma 22.5.3. Every localization functor \(q\colon C\to C[W^{-1}]\) is final.
Proof. Let \(F\colon C[W^{-1}]\to D\) be a functor. By the universal property of the localization, precomposition with \(q\) is fully faithful. Hence for every object \(X\in D\) it induces an equivalence \[ \Nat (F,\const _X)\iso \Nat (F\circ q,\const _X). \] Thus the cocone functors of \(F\) and \(F\circ q\) are naturally equivalent, so either is representable if and only if the other is, by the same object. Condition (1) of Theorem 22.5.1 now shows that \(q\) is final. □
Warning 22.5.4. The terminology regarding final functors is extremely inconsistent in the literature. Because of historic reasons, final functors are also called cofinal functors, where the ‘co’ roughly means ‘jointly final’ and has nothing to do with the usual meaning of ‘co’ in category theory. Nevertheless, some authors use the words ‘final’ and ‘cofinal’ for the two notions from Definition 22.5.2, and there is no consensus as to which of the two words should refer to which of the two notions.
We hope that the convention in Definition 22.5.2 is easy to remember in light of the following lemma:
Lemma 22.5.5. Consider an object \(j\) of an \(\infty \)-category \(J\). Then \(j\colon * \to J\) is an initial functor if and only if \(j\) is an initial object, and it is a final functor if and only if \(j\) is a terminal object of \(J\).
Proof. For an object \(x\) of \(J\), the relative slice \(*_{/x}=*\times _J J_{/x}\) for the functor \(j\colon *\to J\) is the hom anima \(\Hom _J(j,x)\). Since an anima agrees with its geometric realization, this slice is weakly contractible precisely when \(\Hom _J(j,x)\) is contractible. Thus \(j\) is an initial functor if and only if it is an initial object. The assertion about final functors is dual. □
A common way of showing that the relative slice categories \(I_{j/}\) or \(I_{/j}\) are weakly contractible is by showing they admit an initial or terminal object:
Lemma 22.5.6. Let \(C\) be an \(\infty \)-category that admits an initial (resp. terminal) object \(x\colon * \to C\). Then \(C\) is weakly contractible: \(\geom {C} \simeq *\).
Proof. If \(x\) is initial, Remark 22.2.3 gives an adjunction \(x\colon * \rightleftarrows C \noloc p_C\), which by Lemma 22.1.7 induces an equivalence \(* \simeq \geom {*} \simeq \geom {C}\). The terminal case is dual. □
Corollary 22.5.7. If a functor \(\alpha \colon I \to J\) admits a left adjoint, then \(\alpha \) is a final functor. Dually, if it admits a right adjoint it is an initial functor.
Proof. Let \(\beta \colon J\to I\) be a left adjoint to \(\alpha \), with unit \(\eta \colon \id _J\to \alpha \beta \). For every \(j\in J\), the object \((\beta (j),\eta _j)\) is initial in the relative slice \(I_{j/}\). Indeed, by Lemma 22.3.2, Chapterexercise 1.4, its hom anima to \((i,u\colon j\to \alpha (i))\) is the fiber over \(u\) of \[ \Hom _I(\beta (j),i)\longrightarrow \Hom _J(j,\alpha (i)),\qquad f\longmapsto \alpha (f)\circ \eta _j, \] which is an isomorphism by the adjunction. Thus \(I_{j/}\) is weakly contractible by Lemma 22.5.6, proving finality. The assertion about initial functors is dual. □