For a connective ring spectrum \(R\), the Postnikov truncations of an \(R\)-module inherit \(R\)-module structures. We will show that these define a t-structure on \(\LMod _R\), whose heart is the ordinary category of \(\pi _0(R)\)-modules. We first explain how such t-structures arise in a general symmetric monoidal setting.
Definition 8.3.1 (Connectivity-preserving symmetric monoidal structure). Let \(C\) be a stably symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category, meaning that \(C\) is stable and its tensor product is exact separately in both variables, and equip \(C\) with a t-structure. We say that the symmetric monoidal structure on \(C\) is connectivity-preserving if the following two conditions are satisfied:
- (1)
-
The monoidal unit \(\unit \) of \(C\) is connective;
- (2)
-
For two connective objects \(X,Y \in C_{\geq 0}\), the tensor product \(X \otimes Y\) is again connective.
This condition is often expressed by saying that the t-structure is compatible with the symmetric monoidal structure. If the symmetric monoidal structure is connectivity-preserving, then \(C_{\geq 0}\) inherits a symmetric monoidal structure making the inclusion \(C_{\geq 0} \hookrightarrow C\) into a symmetric monoidal functor; this is proved in Part II in Lemma 14.7.1. As a consequence, the truncation functor \(\tau _{\geq 0}\colon C \to C_{\geq 0}\) is canonically lax symmetric monoidal (see Proposition 14.5.6).
Definition 8.3.2. Let \(C\) be a stably symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category equipped with a t-structure for which the symmetric monoidal structure is connectivity-preserving. Let \(R \in \Alg (C_{\geq 0})\) be a connective associative algebra in \(C\). We say that a left \(R\)-module \(M\) is connective if its underlying object in \(C\) is connective, and similarly for coconnective modules. This defines full subcategories \[ \LMod _R(C)_{\geq 0}, \quad \LMod _R(C)_{\leq 0} \quad \subseteq \quad \LMod _R(C). \]
Lemma 8.3.3. In the situation of the preceding definition, the pair \[ \bigl (\LMod _R(C)_{\geq 0},\LMod _R(C)_{\leq 0}\bigr ) \] defines a t-structure on \(\LMod _R(C)\). Its truncation functors are computed on underlying objects.
Proof. The adjunction between the symmetric monoidal inclusion \(C_{\geq 0}\hookrightarrow C\) and its lax symmetric monoidal right adjoint \(\tau _{\geq 0}\) induces, after passing to algebras and modules and taking the fiber over \(R\), an adjunction \[ \LMod _R(C_{\geq 0})\rightleftarrows \LMod _R(C). \] Its right adjoint is computed on underlying objects by \(\tau _{\geq 0}\). Finite limits and colimits of modules are computed on underlying objects by Proposition 17.1.16. Since the forgetful functor detects isomorphisms, \(\LMod _R(C)\) is stable. Closure under the required shifts follows from the corresponding property in \(C\), so it remains to check orthogonality and decomposition. If \(X\) is connective and \(Y\) is coconnective, adjunction gives \[ \Hom _{\LMod _R(C)}(X,Y[-1]) \simeq \Hom _{\LMod _R(C_{\geq 0})}(X,\tau _{\geq 0}(Y[-1])) \simeq *. \] Finally, for an arbitrary \(R\)-module \(X\), the counit \(\tau _{\geq 0}X\to X\) in modules has connective source, and its cofiber belongs to \(\LMod _R(C)_{\leq -1}\) because this is true after forgetting to \(C\). This gives the required decomposition. □
By Lemma 8.2.1, the symmetric monoidal structure on \(\Sp \) is connectivity-preserving. We can therefore apply the preceding lemma to its Postnikov t-structure.
Corollary 8.3.4. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. Then \(\LMod _R\) admits a t-structure given by the connective and coconnective \(R\)-modules. This t-structure is both left and right complete, and every left \(R\)-module \(M\) satisfies \[ M \quad \simeq \quad \colim (\tau _{\geq 0}M \to \tau _{\geq -1}M \to \dots ) \qquadtext {and} M \quad \simeq \quad \lim (\dots \to \tau _{\leq 1}M \to \tau _{\leq 0}M). \] The same statements hold for \(\RMod _R\).
Proof. The t-structure exists by Lemma 8.3.3, Lemma 8.2.1. Truncations are computed on underlying spectra, and the forgetful functor preserves limits and colimits and detects isomorphisms. Thus the two displayed formulas follow from the corresponding Postnikov formulas for spectra (Proposition 6.3.4, Lemma 6.3.31), proving left and right completeness. □
Observation 8.3.5. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. Taking \(\pi _0\) induces a colimit-preserving functor \[ \pi _0\colon \LMod _{R,\geq 0}\longrightarrow \LMod _{\pi _0(R)}(\Ab ). \] Moreover, if \(M\) is a connective right \(R\)-module and \(N\) a connective left \(R\)-module, then \(M\otimes _R N\) is connective, and the canonical map \[ \pi _0(M)\otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)}\pi _0(N) \longrightarrow \pi _0(M\otimes _R N), \qquad [x]\otimes [y]\longmapsto [x\otimes y], \] is an isomorphism.
Indeed, the symmetric monoidal functors \[ \Sp \longleftarrow \Sp _{\geq 0}\xrightarrow {\pi _0}\Ab \] preserve colimits. They therefore induce functors on algebras and modules and preserve relative tensor products by Proposition 17.2.12. The fully faithful inclusion on the left identifies modules in \(\Sp _{\geq 0}\) with connective module spectra. Finally, colimits of modules are computed on underlying objects, so the induced \(\pi _0\)-functor preserves colimits as well. The analogous statement holds for right modules.
The following cellular description of connective modules will also identify the heart of the module t-structure.
Proposition 8.3.6 ([Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.1.1.13(1)]). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. Then the \(\infty \)-category \(\LMod _{R,\geq 0}\) is the smallest subcategory of \(\LMod _R\) which contains \(R\) and which is closed under colimits. The analogous statement holds for connective right \(R\)-modules.
Proof. The connective modules contain \(R\) and are closed under colimits. Conversely, for a connective module \(M\), we construct a sequence \(M(0)\to M(1)\to \cdots \) over \(M\) by successively killing the homotopy groups of the fibers; we enforce this by requiring the fiber \(K(i) := \fib (M(i)\to M)\) to be \(i\)-connective for each \(i \geq 0\).
Choose \(M(0)\to M\) from a coproduct of copies of \(R\) so that it is surjective on \(\pi _0\); then \(K(0)\) is connective. Given \(M(i)\to M\), choose a map \(g\colon F[i]\to K(i)\) which is surjective on \(\pi _i\), where \(F\) is a coproduct of copies of \(R\). Write \(\widetilde g\) for its composite with \(K(i)\to M(i)\), and form the pushout
The nullhomotopy from the fiber sequence gives a map \(M(i+1)\to M\). The resulting fiber sequence \[ F[i]\longrightarrow K(i)\longrightarrow K(i+1) \] and surjectivity on \(\pi _i\) imply that \(K(i+1)\) is \((i+1)\)-connective.
Every \(M(i)\) belongs to the subcategory generated by \(R\) under colimits, since nonnegative shifts and cofibers are colimits. The fiber of \(\colim _i M(i)\to M\) is \(\colim _iK(i)\), since filtered colimits are exact. For each \(j\), the groups \(\pi _jK(i)\) vanish for \(i>j\), so Lemma 4.4.28 implies that this fiber is zero. Thus \(M\simeq \colim _iM(i)\), as required. The same construction works for right modules. □
Lemma 8.3.7. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. Then the functor \(\pi _0\) from Observation 8.3.5 restricts to equivalences \[ \LMod _R^{\heartsuit } \iso \LMod _{\pi _0(R)}(\Ab ), \qquad \RMod _R^{\heartsuit } \iso \RMod _{\pi _0(R)}(\Ab ) \] between the hearts of the module categories and the abelian categories of discrete modules over \(\pi _0(R)\).
Proof. We prove the statement for left modules; the proof for right modules is identical. For essential surjectivity, write a discrete \(\pi _0(R)\)-module \(M\) as a coequalizer of free modules. The two maps between the free modules lift to maps between coproducts of copies of \(R\), since homotopy classes of maps out of \(R\) are classified by elements of \(\pi _0\). Form their coequalizer \(\widetilde M\) in \(\LMod _{R,\geq 0}\) and then apply \(\tau _{\leq 0}\). Since \(\pi _0\) preserves colimits of connective modules, we have \(\pi _0(\widetilde M)\cong M\), and hence \(\tau _{\leq 0}\widetilde M\) is a discrete \(R\)-module whose image under \(\pi _0\) is \(M\).
We will now show that the functor is fully faithful. Let \(N \in \LMod _R^{\heartsuit }\), and consider the subcategory \(C \subseteq \LMod _{R,\geq 0}\) spanned by those left \(R\)-modules \(M\) such that the map \[ \pi _0 \Hom _{\LMod _R}(M,N) \to \Hom _{\LMod _{\pi _0(R)}(\Ab )}(\pi _0(M),\pi _0(N)) \] is an isomorphism. The subcategory \(C\) contains \(R\). For connective \(M\) and discrete \(N\), the hom anima \(\Hom _{\LMod _R}(M,N)\) is discrete by t-structure orthogonality. Hence its \(\pi _0\) carries colimits in \(M\) to limits of sets. The right-hand side does so as well, since \(\pi _0\) preserves colimits of connective modules. Thus \(C\) is closed under colimits. It follows from Proposition 8.3.6 that \(C = \LMod _{R,\geq 0}\), as desired. □
Notation 8.3.8. Let \(R\) be a discrete associative ring. We will from now on denote the categories \(\LMod _R(\Ab )\) and \(\RMod _R(\Ab )\) of discrete left and right \(R\)-modules by \(\LMod _R^{\heartsuit }\) and \(\RMod _R^{\heartsuit }\), respectively. This notation is justified by Lemma 8.3.7: these categories agree with the hearts of \(\LMod _R\) and \(\RMod _R\), regarding \(R\) as an Eilenberg–MacLane ring spectrum.
Tensor products in \(\Ab \) will from now on always be denoted by \(\otimes ^{\heartsuit }\); we reserve \(\otimes \) for the tensor product in \(\Sp \).
Remark 8.3.9. For an arbitrary associative ring spectrum \(R\), [Lurie (2017), Proposition 1.4.4.11] gives a t-structure on \(\LMod _R\) whose connective part is the smallest full subcategory containing \(R\) and closed under colimits and extensions. Its coconnective objects are precisely the modules whose underlying spectra are coconnective: orthogonality to \(R[n]\) for \(n>0\) is equivalent to vanishing of the positive homotopy groups. If \(R\) is not connective, the connective objects of this t-structure need not have connective underlying spectra; \(R\) itself is an example.