Example 6.21 (Solid modules and nuclear modules over formal schemes). Ambient category. Let \(\D (\mathrm {Solid}_{\Z })\) be the derived category of light solid abelian groups, as in Efimov’s convention in [Efimov (2025), Section 7.2]. This is a compactly generated symmetric monoidal category, with compact projective generator \(\prod _{\N }\Z \) and compact unit \(\Z \). It is far from rigid: the compact object \(\prod _{\N }\Z \) is not dualizable (its predual is \(\bigoplus _{\N }\Z \)). In fact, there is a symmetric monoidal equivalence \[ \D (\mathrm {Solid}_{\Z }) \simeq \Ind \big (\D ^b(\mathrm {Proj}^{\omega _1}\text {-}\Z )\catop \big ), \] where \(\D ^b(\mathrm {Proj}^{\omega _1}\text {-}\Z ) \subseteq \D (\Z )\) is the stable subcategory generated by \(\bigoplus _{\N }\Z \), under which \(\prod _{\N }\Z \) corresponds to \((\bigoplus _{\N }\Z )\catop \) [Efimov (2025), Section 7.2].
Completion and nuclear objects. More generally, let \(R\) be a commutative ring and \(I = (a_1,\dots ,a_m) \subseteq R\) a finitely generated ideal, and let \(R^{\wedge }_I\) denote its derived \(I\)-adic completion. We use the induced solid analytic structure, with the notation of [Efimov (2025), Section 7.2]. All completions and tensor products in this example are derived; for Noetherian \(R\), the derived completion of \(R\) agrees with its ordinary completion. Its category of modules \(\D (\mathrm {Solid}_{(R^{\wedge }_I,\Z )}) = \Mod _{R^{\wedge }_I}(\D (\mathrm {Solid}_{\Z }))\) is compactly generated by \(R^{\wedge }_I \otimes ^{\square } \prod _{\N }\Z \), with compact unit. The category of nuclear solid modules is \[ \Nuc ^{CS}(R^{\wedge }_I) := \Nuc \big (\D (\mathrm {Solid}_{(R^{\wedge }_I,\Z )})\big ), \] with respect to this specified solid structure. (For \(R = \Z \) and \(I = 0\) one recovers \(\D (\Z )\): an object of \(\D (\mathrm {Solid}_{\Z })\) is nuclear if and only if it is discrete [Clausen and Scholze (2026), Lecture VIII, Exercise 1].) One has \(\Nuc ^{CS}(R^{\wedge }_I) \simeq \D (\mathrm {Solid}_{(R^{\wedge }_I,\Z )})^{\rig }\).
Rigidity and invariants. The key technical input is that the preduals of compact objects are nuclear, which goes back to Andreychev [Andreychev (2023), Lemma 3.8 and Korollar 3.14]; see [Efimov (2025), Propositions 7.4 and 7.5] (Efimov deduces the rigidity from this via [Efimov (2025), Propositions 1.33 and 1.34] rather than via Proposition 6.19). The tensor products here are those of the complete solid module category; the cited propositions supply the nuclearity and rigidity statements. Hence:
- \(\Nuc ^{CS}(R^{\wedge }_I)\) is rigid, hence dualizable, but in general not compactly generated.
- Its compact objects are the perfect complexes over \(R^{\wedge }_I\).
- Its continuous K-theory is \(K^{\cont }(\Nuc ^{CS}(R^{\wedge }_I)) \simeq \lim _n K(R \quot (a_1^n,\dots ,a_m^n))\), which is \(\lim _n K(R/I^n)\) if \(R\) is Noetherian (Efimov [Efimov (2025), Corollary 7.10], as conjectured by Clausen–Scholze), cf. Theorem 1.15.
Failure of compact generation. To see that compact generation fails already for \(\Nuc ^{CS}(\Z _p)\), suppose otherwise. Its compact objects are \(\Perf (\Z _p)\), so the canonical \(\Z \)-linear functor \(\D (\Z _p) \to \Nuc ^{CS}(\Z _p)\) would be an equivalence. But Efimov computes \[ \mathrm {HH}^{\cont }(\Nuc ^{CS}(\Z _p)/\Z ) \simeq \Z _p \] [Efimov (2025), Corollary 7.20(i)], whereas \[ \mathrm {HH}_1(\Z _p/\Z ) \cong \Omega ^1_{\Z _p/\Z } \cong \Omega ^1_{\Q _p/\Q } \neq 0. \] Here \(\mathrm {HH}^{\cont }\) denotes the continuous extension of relative Hochschild homology, which agrees with ordinary Hochschild homology on compactly generated categories. This gives the required contradiction; see also the discussion after [Efimov (2025), Remark 7.21].
Operator-algebra presentation. There is also an operator-algebra presentation, analogous to the compact-operator example of Example 1.14. Let \(R\) be a commutative ring, \(I = (f_1,\dots ,f_m) \subseteq R\) a finitely generated ideal. In this paragraph all completions and tensor products are derived, following [Efimov (2025), Section 7.2]. Let \(P := (\bigoplus _{\N } R)^{\wedge }_I\) be the \(I\)-completed countable direct sum, which plays the role of a separable Hilbert space. In place of \(B(\Hh )\) we take the endomorphism ring \(\End _R(P)\), and in place of the Calkin algebra \(B(\Hh )/\Kk \) the \(I\)-adically completed endomorphism ring \[ \Calk ^{\mathrm {top}}_R(P) := \End _{\Calk (R)}(P)^{\wedge }_I \] of \(P\) in the Calkin category of \(\Perf (R)\). The fiber of \(\End _R(P) \to \Calk ^{\mathrm {top}}_R(P)\) is \(\big (\prod _{\N }R \otimes _R \bigoplus _{\N }R\big )^{\wedge }_I\), which one may think of as the \(I\)-adic completion of the endomorphisms of finite rank, just as \(\Kk \) is the norm closure of the operators of finite rank. Efimov shows that \(\End _R(P) \to \Calk ^{\mathrm {top}}_R(P)\) is a homological epimorphism, whose kernel is the category of nuclear modules over \(R^{\wedge }_I\) in the sense of Clausen–Scholze [Efimov (2025), Corollary 7.7]: \[ \Nuc ^{CS}(R^{\wedge }_I) \simeq \D \big (\End _R(P) \to \Calk ^{\mathrm {top}}_R(P)\big ). \]
Efimov’s variant. Efimov also introduced a variant \(\Nuc (R^{\wedge }_I)\) [Efimov (2025), Definition 3.28], which can be described as \(\lim ^{\dual }_n \D (R \quot (a_1^n,\dots ,a_m^n))\), the limit computed in \(\Pr ^{\dual }\) [Efimov (2025), Proposition 5.23]. It receives a fully faithful strongly continuous functor from \(\Nuc ^{CS}(R^{\wedge }_I)\) [Efimov (2025), Corollary 7.6], which induces an equivalence on compact objects, both sides having compact objects \(\Perf (R^{\wedge }_I)\) [Efimov (2025), Proposition 3.29]. It can equivalently be described as the rigidification \(\D _{I\text {-}\mathrm {compl}}(R)^{\rig }\) [Efimov (2025), Proposition 4.3] of the category of derived \(I\)-complete \(R\)-modules; the latter need not itself be rigid. For example, for \(R = \Z \) and \(I = (p)\) its unit \(\Z _p\) is not compact.