Proposition 6.17 (Clausen–Scholze; see [Clausen and Scholze (2026), Theorem 8.6] and [Efimov (2025), Propositions 1.27 and 1.28]).
- (1)
-
For \(M \in C\), the following are equivalent:
- (a)
-
\(M\) is nuclear;
- (b)
-
for every compact \(P\), the map \(\hom _C(\unit _C,P^{\vee } \otimes M) \to \hom _C(P,M)\) is an equivalence of spectra (equivalently, since we may replace \(P\) by its shifts, the corresponding map of mapping spaces is an equivalence for every compact \(P\));
- (d)
-
\(M \simeq \colim _{i \in I} M_i\) for a directed poset \(I\) and compact objects \(M_i\), such that for every \(i\) there is \(j \geq i\) with \(M_i \to M_j\) trace-class.
Moreover, these conditions are implied by
- (c)
-
for every compact \(P\), the map \(P^{\vee } \otimes M \to \iHom (P,M)\) is an equivalence,
and if the tensor product of any two compact objects of \(C\) is compact, then (c) is equivalent to (a), (b) and (d).
- (2)
-
The subcategory \(\Nuc (C) \subseteq C\) is closed under colimits. It is \(\omega _1\)-presentable, and its \(\omega _1\)-compact objects are precisely the basic nuclear objects.
Proof.
We first prove (1). (b) \(\Rightarrow \) (a): Taking \(\pi _0\) of the mapping spaces, every morphism \(P \to M\) lies in the image of \(\pi _0\lambda _M\) (with \(Q = \unit _C\)), i.e. is trace-class.
(a) \(\Rightarrow \) (d): Since \(C\) is compactly generated, \(M\) is a filtered colimit of compact objects, and by Theorem A.8 we may write \(M \simeq \colim _{i \in I} M_i\) with \(I\) a directed poset and \(M_i\) compact; denote by \(t_{ij}\) the transition maps and by \(\iota _i\colon M_i \to M\) the canonical maps. Fix \(i\). Since \(\iota _i\) is trace-class, it is \(\lambda _M(w)\) for some \(w \in \pi _0\Map _C(\unit _C, M \otimes M_i^{\vee })\). As \(\unit _C\) is compact and \(M \otimes M_i^{\vee } \simeq \colim _j M_j \otimes M_i^{\vee }\), the class \(w\) is the image of some \(w' \in \pi _0\Map _C(\unit _C, M_j \otimes M_i^{\vee })\) with \(j \geq i\). Then \(g := \lambda _{M_j}(w')\colon M_i \to M_j\) is trace-class, and \(\iota _j g \simeq \lambda _M(w) \simeq \iota _i\) by naturality of \(\lambda \). As \(M_i\) is compact, \(\pi _0\Map _C(M_i,M) \simeq \colim _k \pi _0\Map _C(M_i,M_k)\), so there is \(k \geq j\) with \(t_{jk}g \simeq t_{ik}\). Since trace-class morphisms form an ideal (Remark 6.6(2)), \(t_{ik}\) is trace-class.
(d) \(\Rightarrow \) (b): This is Lemma 6.16 with \(Q = \unit _C\).
(c) \(\Rightarrow \) (b): Apply \(\hom _C(\unit _C,-)\) and use \(\hom _C(\unit _C,\iHom (P,M)) \simeq \hom _C(P,M)\).
(d) \(\Rightarrow \) (c), if compact objects are closed under tensor products: For compact \(Q\), the map \(\hom _C(Q,P^{\vee } \otimes M) \to \hom _C(Q,\iHom (P,M)) \simeq \hom _C(Q \otimes P,M)\) is an equivalence by Lemma 6.16. Since \(C\) is compactly generated, the compact objects detect equivalences, so \(P^{\vee } \otimes M \to \iHom (P,M)\) is an equivalence.
We now prove (2). By (1), \(M\) is nuclear if and only if the maps in (b) are equivalences. Since \(\unit _C\) and \(P\) are compact, the functors \(\hom _C(\unit _C,P^{\vee } \otimes -)\) and \(\hom _C(P,-)\) preserve filtered colimits, and being exact they preserve all small colimits. Hence \(\Nuc (C)\) is closed under colimits in \(C\); in particular, colimits in \(\Nuc (C)\) are computed in \(C\).
Basic nuclear objects are nuclear by (d) (with \(I = \N \)). They are countable colimits of compact objects, hence \(\omega _1\)-compact in \(C\) (Corollary A.4), and hence also in \(\Nuc (C)\).
Next, every nuclear \(M\) is an \(\omega _1\)-filtered colimit of basic nuclear objects. Write \(M \simeq \colim _{i \in I} M_i\) as in (d), and choose for every \(i\) an element \(\sigma (i) \geq i\) such that \(M_i \to M_{\sigma (i)}\) is trace-class. Let \(\Sigma _{\sigma }\) be the set of countable directed subsets \(J \subseteq I\) with \(\sigma (J) \subseteq J\), ordered by inclusion. The proof of Proposition A.9 applies verbatim to \(\Sigma _{\sigma }\) instead of \(\Sigma \) (adding in the inductive construction also \(\sigma (u)\) for \(u \in U_k\)), and shows that \(\Sigma _{\sigma }\) is \(\omega _1\)-filtered and that \(M \simeq \colim _{J \in \Sigma _{\sigma }} M_J\) with \(M_J = \colim _{i \in J} M_i\). Each \(M_J\) is basic nuclear: enumerate \(J = \{q_0,q_1,\dots \}\), and choose inductively \(j_0 = q_0\) and \(j_{n+1} \in J\) with \(j_{n+1} \geq \sigma (j_n), q_{n+1}\). Then \(n \mapsto j_n\) is cofinal (Lemma A.7), so \(M_J \simeq \colim _n M_{j_n}\), and each \(M_{j_n} \to M_{j_{n+1}}\) factors through the trace-class map \(M_{j_n} \to M_{\sigma (j_n)}\), hence is trace-class.
The basic nuclear objects form an essentially small collection, since \(C^{\omega }\) is essentially small. Thus \(\Nuc (C)\) admits small colimits and is generated under \(\omega _1\)-filtered colimits by an essentially small collection of \(\omega _1\)-compact objects, so it is \(\omega _1\)-accessible by [Lurie (2009), Proposition 5.4.2.2], and hence \(\omega _1\)-presentable.
Finally, let \(X \in \Nuc (C)\) be \(\omega _1\)-compact. Writing \(X \simeq \colim _{J \in \Sigma _{\sigma }} X_J\) as above, the identity of \(X\) factors through some \(X_J\), so \(X\) is a retract of a basic nuclear object \(Y = \colim _n a_n\), where the \(a_n\) are compact and the transition maps \(a_n \to a_{n+1}\) are trace-class. Now we argue as in the proof of Proposition A.13, applied in \(C \simeq \Ind (C^{\omega })\): by Lemma A.11 and Lemma A.12, we find a strictly increasing \(f\colon \N \to \N \) with \(f(n) \geq n\) and a natural transformation \(\eta \colon a_{\bullet } \to a_{f(\bullet )}\) such that \(X \simeq \colim _n \Phi (n,n)\), where \(\Phi (k,n) = a_{f^k(n)}\). The transition map \(\Phi (n,n) \to \Phi (n+1,n+1)\) is the composite of the transition map \(a_{f^n(n)} \to a_{f^n(n+1)}\) of \(a_{\bullet }\), which is trace-class as \(f^n(n+1) > f^n(n)\), with \(\eta _{f^n(n+1)}\). So it is trace-class, and \(X\) is basic nuclear. □