Proposition A.13. Let \(C\) be a small category and let \(X \in \Ind (C)\). Then \(X\) is \(\omega _1\)-compact if and only if \(X \simeq \colim _n y(c_n)\) for some sequence \(c_0 \to c_1 \to c_2 \to \dots \) in \(C\).
Proof.
If \(X\) is a sequential colimit of representables, then \(X\) is a countable colimit of compact objects, hence \(\omega _1\)-compact by Corollary A.4.
Conversely, let \(X\) be \(\omega _1\)-compact. By definition of \(\Ind (C)\) and Theorem A.8, we may write \(X = \colim _{p \in P} y(c_p)\) for a filtered partially ordered set \(P\). By Proposition A.9, we have \(X \simeq \colim _{Q \in \Sigma } X_Q\) with \(X_Q = \colim _{q \in Q} y(c_q)\) and \(\Sigma \) \(\omega _1\)-filtered. As \(X\) is \(\omega _1\)-compact, \(\Map (X,X) \simeq \colim _{Q} \Map (X,X_Q)\), so the identity of \(X\) factors as \(X \xrightarrow {s} X_Q \xrightarrow {r} X\) for some \(Q \in \Sigma \). By Lemma A.7(2), \(X_Q\) is a sequential colimit \(Y = \colim _n y(a_n)\) of representables. By Lemma A.11, \(X \simeq \colim (Y \xrightarrow {e} Y \xrightarrow {e} \dots )\) with \(e = sr\).
By Lemma A.12, there exist \(f\colon \N \to \N \) with \(f(n) \geq n\) and a natural transformation \(\eta \colon a_{\bullet } \to a_{f(\bullet )}\) inducing \(e\) on colimits. Define a functor \(\Phi \colon \N \times \N \to C\) by \(\Phi (k,n) = a_{f^k(n)}\), with horizontal maps the transition maps of \(a_{\bullet }\) and vertical maps \(\eta _{f^k(n)}\colon a_{f^k(n)} \to a_{f^{k+1}(n)}\); by Remark A.10 this is the functor \(\N \to \Fun (\N ,C)\) given by the sequence \(a_{\bullet } \to a_{f(\bullet )} \to a_{f^2(\bullet )} \to \dots \) of whiskerings of \(\eta \). Since each \(f^k\) is cofinal, \(\colim _n y\Phi (k,n) \simeq Y\), and under these identifications the induced map in the \(k\)-direction is \(\colim \eta \simeq e\). Hence \[ X \simeq \colim _k \colim _n y\Phi (k,n) \simeq \colim _{(k,n) \in \N \times \N } y\Phi (k,n) \simeq \colim _n y\Phi (n,n), \] where the last equivalence uses cofinality of the diagonal (Lemma A.7(3)). So \(X\) is a sequential colimit of representables. ā”