Theorem 2.41 (Tamme, before Efimov, [Tamme (2018), Theorem 18]). Consider a square \(Q\) in \(\Cat _{\st }\) of the form Commutative square with A mapping to B by f, C mapping to D by g, and vertical maps from A to C and B to D. Assume that \(\Ind (Q)\) is cartesian, and that \(\Ind (f)\) and \(\Ind (g)\) are localizations. Then every localizing invariant \(F\) sends \(Q\) to a cartesian square.

Proof.

Write \(h\colon B \to D\) for the right vertical functor and form the lax pullback \(P = B \times _D^{\to } C\). Its objects are triples \((b,c,\varphi )\) with \(\varphi \colon h(b) \to g(c)\). There is a split exact sequence \(C \to P \to B\), and hence \(F(P) \simeq F(C) \oplus F(B)\), by [Tamme (2018), Proposition 10]. The hypotheses make \(Q\) an excisive square in the sense of [Tamme (2018), Definition 14]; in fact only \(\Ind (g)\) needs to be a localization. By [Tamme (2018), Theorem 15], the functor \((b,c,\varphi ) \mapsto \cofib (\varphi )\) fits into an exact sequence \[ A \to P \to D. \] Here and in the split sequence, we may pass to idempotent completions before applying \(F\). Under the splitting, the map \(F(P) \to F(D)\) is \((-F(h),F(g))\): on \((b,0,h(b)\to 0)\) it is suspension followed by \(h\), and on \((0,c,0\to g(c))\) it is \(g\). Thus \(F(A)\) is the fiber of \(F(B)\oplus F(C) \xrightarrow {-F(h)+F(g)} F(D)\), compatibly with the maps of \(Q\). This is precisely the assertion that \(F(Q)\) is cartesian. □