We finally discuss the characterization of dualizable categories by the axiom (AB6), due to Clausen and Scholze. It expresses the fact that infinite products commute with filtered colimits, in the strongest possible sense.
Definition 4.18. Let \(C\) be a category with small products and filtered colimits. We say that \(C\) satisfies (AB6) if for every set \(S\) and every family of functors \(F_s\colon J_s \to C\), \(s \in S\), with each \(J_s\) filtered, the canonical map \[ \colim _{(j_s)_s \in \prod _s J_s} \prod _{s \in S} F_s(j_s) \to \prod _{s \in S} \colim _{j \in J_s} F_s(j) \] is an equivalence. Note that \(\prod _s J_s\) is again filtered.
Example 4.19. The category of sets and the category \(\An \) of animae satisfy (AB6) [Efimov (2024), Section 2.7].
Proof.
For sets, surjectivity follows by choosing, for each \(s\), a stage \(j_s\) representing the given element of \(\colim _{J_s}F_s\). For injectivity, two representatives which agree in each colimit agree at a later stage in each coordinate. Choosing these stages gives equality in the colimit over \(\prod _s J_s\). Here we use the axiom of choice.
For animae, we may replace each \(J_s\) by a cofinal directed poset, by Theorem A.8. The product of these cofinal functors is cofinal. Indeed, if \(u\colon P\to J\) is such a functor and \(j\in J\), the comma category \(P\times _J J_{j/}\) is filtered: any finite diagram in it has an underlying cone in \(P\), and the finitely many compatibility data in the animae \(\Map _J(j,u(p))\) can be extended at a later stage, since their filtered colimit is contractible by cofinality. Here we use that filtered colimits of animae commute with finite limits. Thus the comma categories for the product functor are products of nonempty filtered categories, which are again nonempty and filtered (using choice), and hence contractible. The set calculation proves that the comparison map induces a bijection on \(\pi _0\), since \(\pi _0\) commutes with products and filtered colimits of animae.
Fix a point in the source, represented by points \(x_s \in F_s(j_s)\). Restrict to the cofinal product of the tails \(J_{s,\geq j_s}\), so that all diagrams are pointed by the images of \(x_s\). For \(n \geq 1\), homotopy groups commute with products and filtered colimits of pointed animae. Applying the set calculation to these homotopy groups therefore gives \[ \colim _{(k_s)_s \geq (j_s)_s}\prod _s \pi _n(F_s(k_s),x_s) \cong \prod _s \colim _{k_s \geq j_s}\pi _n(F_s(k_s),x_s). \] Thus the comparison map induces isomorphisms on all homotopy groups at every basepoint, and is an isomorphism of animae. □
(AB6) in \(C\) is equivalent to the statement that the colimit functor \(\colim \colon \Ind (C) \to C\) preserves products. This rests on the following description of products in \(\Ind (C)\).
Lemma 4.20 ([Efimov (2024), Proposition 2.50]). Let \(C\) be a locally small category with small products. Then \(\Ind (C)\) has small products, and for filtered diagrams \((x_j)_{j \in J_s}\) in \(C\), \(s \in S\), we have \[ \prod _{s \in S} \quotcolim _{j \in J_s} x_j \simeq \quotcolim _{(j_s)_s \in \prod _s J_s} \prod _{s \in S} x_{j_s}. \]
Proof.
We show that the right-hand side has the universal property of the product. Since every object of \(\Ind (C)\) is a filtered colimit of representables, it suffices to test against \(y(c)\), \(c \in C\). As \(y(c)\) is compact, and using (AB6) in \(\An \), we get natural equivalences \begin {align*} \Map \Big (y(c),\quotcolim _{(j_s)_s} \prod _s x_{j_s}\Big ) &\simeq \colim _{(j_s)_s} \prod _s \Map _C(c,x_{j_s}) \\ &\simeq \prod _s \colim _{j \in J_s} \Map _C(c,x_j) \\ &\simeq \prod _s \Map \Big (y(c),\quotcolim _{j \in J_s} x_j\Big ). \end {align*} □
Proposition 4.21 (Clausen–Scholze, see [Efimov (2024), Proposition 2.51]). Let \(C \in \PrL _{\st }\). Then \(C\) is dualizable if and only if \(C\) satisfies (AB6).
Proof.
By Lemma 4.20, and since \(\colim \) sends \(\quotcolim _{(j_s)_s}\prod _s x_{j_s}\) to \(\colim _{(j_s)_s}\prod _s x_{j_s}\), the axiom (AB6) for \(C\) says exactly that \(\colim \colon \Ind (C) \to C\) preserves products of families of ind-objects. Every family of objects of \(\Ind (C)\) is of this form. So (AB6) holds if and only if \(\colim \) preserves small products, which is equivalent to dualizability of \(C\) by Proposition 3.17. □
Remark 4.22. In the talk, the implication “(AB6) \(\implies \) dualizable” was argued directly with \(\colim \colon \Ind (C^{\kappa }) \to C\). Note that products in \(\Ind (C^{\kappa })\) are not computed by the formula of Lemma 4.20, since a product of \(\kappa \)-compact objects need not be \(\kappa \)-compact. This is why the argument passes through the large category \(\Ind (C)\), as in the proof of (2) \(\implies \) (3) in Proposition 3.17.
Remark 4.23. Since \(\Sp \) is compactly generated, hence dualizable, it satisfies (AB6). More generally, by [Efimov (2024), Remark 2.52] a presentable, not necessarily stable, category is compactly assembled if and only if it satisfies (AB6) and filtered colimits in it commute with finite limits.