The basic construction of this chapter is the quotient of a small stable category \(B\) by a stable subcategory \(A\), obtained by forcing the objects of \(A\) to become zero. In the setting of stable categories this is simply a localization in the sense of Dwyer–Kan, and the following theorem shows that it behaves just like Verdier’s classical quotient of triangulated categories: it is again stable, it has the expected universal property, and its mapping spectra are computed by a colimit over \(A\). We then introduce the corresponding notion of exact sequence, the Verdier sequences.
Theorem 2.1 ([Nikolaus and Scholze (2018), Theorem I.3.3]). Let \(B\) be a small stable category and \(A \subseteq B\) a full stable subcategory. Let \(W_A\) be the class of morphisms of \(B\) whose cofiber lies in \(A\), and let \(q\colon B \to B/A := B[W_A^{-1}]\) be the localization. Then:
- (1)
-
The category \(B/A\) is stable and \(q\) is exact.
- (2)
-
For every stable category \(E\), restriction along \(q\) induces an equivalence between \(\Fun ^{\ex }(B/A,E)\) and the full subcategory of \(\Fun ^{\ex }(B,E)\) spanned by the functors that vanish on \(A\).
- (3)
-
For \(x,y \in B\), the category \(A_{/y}\) is filtered and \[ \Map _{B/A}(qx,qy) \simeq \colim _{(a \to y) \in A_{/y}} \Map _B\big (x,\cofib (a \to y)\big ). \]
The category \(B/A\) is called the Verdier quotient of \(B\) by \(A\).
Note that \(q\) is essentially surjective, being a localization. Moreover, part (2) says that \(B \to B/A\) is the cofiber of \(A \hookrightarrow B\) in \(\Cat _{\st }\). Indeed, for a stable category \(E\), exact functors out of the pushout \(0 \sqcup _A B\) in \(\Cat _{\st }\) are given by \[ \Fun ^{\ex }(B,E) \times _{\Fun ^{\ex }(A,E)} \{0\}, \] the category of exact functors \(F\colon B \to E\) together with an equivalence \(F|_A \simeq 0\). Since \(0\) is a zero object of \(\Fun ^{\ex }(A,E)\), the space of such equivalences is either empty or contractible, so this is the full subcategory of \(\Fun ^{\ex }(B,E)\) spanned by the functors vanishing on \(A\).
Lemma 2.2. In the situation of Theorem 2.1, the kernel of \(q\colon B \to B/A\) is the thick closure of \(A\) in \(B\), i.e. the full subcategory of retracts of objects of \(A\). In particular, \(B/A \simeq B/\bar {A}\), where \(\bar {A}\) is the thick closure of \(A\).
Proof.
Since \(q\) is exact, its kernel is a thick subcategory of \(B\), and it contains \(A\) since \(0 \to a\) lies in \(W_A\) for \(a \in A\). Conversely, let \(x \in B\) with \(q(x) \simeq 0\). Then \(\id _{qx}\) is nullhomotopic, so by Theorem 2.1(3) (applied with \(y = x\)) there exists \(a \to x\) with \(a \in A\) such that the canonical map \(x \to c := \cofib (a \to x)\) is nullhomotopic. Since \(a \simeq \fib (x \to c)\) and the fiber of a nullhomotopic map \(x \to c\) is \(x \oplus \Omega c\), it follows that \(x\) is a retract of \(a\). This shows that the kernel of \(q\) consists of retracts of objects of \(A\), and every retract of an object of \(A\) lies in the thick subcategory \(\ker (q)\). The last statement follows from the universal property Theorem 2.1(2), since an exact functor vanishes on \(A\) if and only if it vanishes on \(\bar {A}\). □
Remark 2.3. Let \(F\colon B \to C\) be a functor into a pointed category \(C\). Since the constant functor \(0\) with value a zero object is a terminal object of \(\Fun (B,C)\), the space of natural transformations \(F \to 0\) is contractible. Hence the space of equivalences \(F \simeq 0\) is either empty or contractible, and it is non-empty if and only if \(F\) sends every object to a zero object. So for a composable pair \(A \xrightarrow {i} B \xrightarrow {p} C\) of functors between pointed categories, a nullhomotopy \(pi \simeq 0\) is unique if it exists, and its existence is a property of the pair \((i,p)\). We will therefore write “\(pi \simeq 0\)” as a condition throughout, without specifying a nullhomotopy.
Definition 2.4. A sequence \(A \xrightarrow {i} B \xrightarrow {p} C\) in \(\Cat _{\st }\) with \(pi \simeq 0\) is called a Verdier sequence if it is both a fiber sequence and a cofiber sequence in \(\Cat _{\st }\). Explicitly, this means that \(i\) is fully faithful with essential image \(\ker (p)\), and that the induced functor \(B/A \to C\) is an equivalence. In this case \(p\) is called a Verdier projection.
By Lemma 2.2, for every full stable subcategory \(A \subseteq B\) the sequence \(\bar {A} \hookrightarrow B \to B/A\) is a Verdier sequence. See [Calmès et al. (2020), Lemma A.1.8 and Proposition A.1.9] for a detailed discussion of Verdier sequences.