Theorem 8.5.14 (Characterization of flat modules, [Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.2.2.13, Theorem 7.2.2.15]). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum and let \(N\) be a connective left \(R\)-module. The following conditions are equivalent:
- (1)
- (2)
-
For every right \(R\)-module \(M\) and \(n \in \Z \), the following map is an isomorphism: \[ \pi _n(M) \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \iso \pi _n(M \otimes _R N), \qquad \quad [x] \otimes [y] \mapsto [x \otimes y]. \]
- (3)
-
The discrete \(\pi _0(R)\)-module \(\pi _0(N)\) is flat, and for each integer \(n\) the map \[ \pi _n(R) \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to \pi _n(N), \qquad \qquad [r] \otimes [x] \mapsto [rx] \] is an isomorphism of abelian groups.
- (4)
-
For every discrete right \(R\)-module \(M\), the spectrum \(M \otimes _R N\) is discrete. Equivalently, \(\Tor ^R_i(M,N) = 0\) for all discrete \(M\) and all \(i > 0\).
- (5)
-
The left \(\pi _0(R)\)-module \(\pi _0(R) \otimes _R N\) is discrete and flat.
If \(R\) and \(N\) are both discrete, these conditions are further equivalent to:
Proof. We first show that the t-structural conditions are equivalent. Apply Proposition 6.5.9 to the relative tensor product \(\RMod _R \times \LMod _R \to \Sp \). The t-structure on \(\RMod _R\) is right complete by Corollary 8.3.4, relative tensor products preserve sequential colimits, and \(\Sp _{\leq 0}\) is closed under sequential colimits. Moreover, \(M \otimes _R N\) is connective when \(M\) and \(N\) are connective by Observation 8.5.10. Thus the heart criterion of Proposition 6.5.9 gives \(\text{(1)} \Leftrightarrow \text{(4)}\).
\(\text{(1)} \Rightarrow \text{(2)}\): A t-exact functor commutes with homotopy group objects by Lemma 6.3.26. On hearts, \((-)\otimes _R N\) is identified with \((-)\otimes _{\pi _0(R)}^{\heartsuit }\pi _0(N)\) by Observation 8.5.10, giving the required formula.
\(\text{(2)} \Rightarrow \text{(3)}\): Taking \(M = R\) gives the displayed isomorphisms in (3). To prove that \(\pi _0(N)\) is flat, consider a short exact sequence \(0 \to M' \to M \to M'' \to 0\) of ordinary right \(\pi _0(R)\)-modules, regarded as discrete right \(R\)-modules. Tensoring the associated exact sequence with \(N\) and applying (2) gives a short exact sequence \[ 0 \to M' \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to M \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to M'' \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to 0. \] Hence \(\pi _0(N)\) is flat over \(\pi _0(R)\).
\(\text{(3)} \Rightarrow \text{(2)}\): The right \(R\)-modules for which the formula holds in every degree form a localizing subcategory. Indeed, they are closed under shifts and coproducts, and closure under cofibers follows from the five lemma applied to the long exact sequences, using flatness of \(\pi _0(N)\). By assumption this subcategory contains \(R\), so it is all of \(\RMod _R\) by the right-module version of Lemma 8.1.11.
\(\text{(2)} \Rightarrow \text{(1)}\): The formula shows that \((-)\otimes _R N\) preserves both connective and coconnective modules.
\(\text{(4)} \iff \text{(5)}\): Let \(A := \pi _0(R)\) and let \(L := A \otimes _R N\). Every discrete right \(R\)-module is equivalently a discrete right \(A\)-module, and for such an \(M\), associativity of relative tensor products gives a natural isomorphism \[ M \otimes _A L \iso M \otimes _R N. \] If (4) holds, then taking \(M = A\) shows that \(L\) is discrete. Moreover, the displayed isomorphism shows that \(M \otimes _A L\) is discrete for every discrete right \(A\)-module \(M\). Thus \(L\) satisfies (4) as an \(A\)-module, and hence is flat by the equivalence between (1) and (4) already proved above.
Conversely, if \(L\) is discrete and flat as an \(A\)-module, then for every discrete right \(R\)-module \(M\), regarded as a discrete right \(A\)-module, the spectrum \(M \otimes _A L\) is discrete. By the displayed isomorphism, so is \(M \otimes _R N\), which is (4).
For discrete \(R\) and \(N\), Lemma 6.5.10 gives \(\text{(1)}\Leftrightarrow \text{(7)}\), since every discrete right module is a quotient of a free one. Vanishing of \(\Tor _1^R(-,N)\) implies (6) by the Tor long exact sequence. Conversely, given a free presentation \(0\to K\to F\to M\to 0\), that sequence identifies \(\Tor _1^R(M,N)\) with the kernel of \(K\otimes _R^{\heartsuit }N\to F\otimes _R^{\heartsuit }N\), which vanishes under (6). □