Proposition 19.1.5. Let \(S\) be a collection of morphisms in an \(\infty \)-category \(C\).
- (1)
-
The classes \(S^\perp \) and \({}^\perp S\) are closed under composition and contain all isomorphisms. In particular, they are encoded by wide subcategories of \(C\).
- (2)
-
The classes \(S^\perp \) and \({}^\perp S\) are closed under retracts.
- (3)
-
The class \(S^\perp \) is closed under base change (pullbacks), and \({}^\perp S\) is closed under cobase change (pushouts).
- (4)
-
The class \(S^\perp \) has the left cancellation property: if \(g \circ f,g \in S^\perp \), then \(f \in S^\perp \). Dually, \({}^\perp S\) has the right cancellation property: if \(g \circ f,f \in {}^\perp S\), then \(g \in {}^\perp S\).
- (5)
-
If \(C\) admits small limits, \(S^\perp \) is closed under small limits in \(\Ar (C)\). Dually, if \(C\) admits small colimits, \({}^\perp S\) is closed under small colimits in \(\Ar (C)\).
Proof. These properties all follow from the definition of orthogonality in terms of hom animae. The proofs of (1) and (2) are left to the reader. For (3), consider a pullback square in \(C\) where \(r \in S^\perp \):
For any \(l \colon A \to B\) in \(S\), we must show \(l \perp r'\). This means showing that the left square in the diagram below is a pullback square of animae:
The right square is a pullback because \(\Hom _C(A,-)\) preserves pullbacks, so by the pasting lemma for pullback squares it remains to show that the outer rectangle is a pullback. But this holds as we may rewrite it as the pasting of the square obtained from the original pullback square by applying \(\Hom _C(B,-)\) and the pullback square exhibiting the orthogonality relation \(l \perp r\). The assertion about pushouts is dual.
For (4), consider morphisms \(f\colon X \to Y\) and \(g\colon Y \to Z\) in \(C\), and assume that \(g \circ f\) and \(g\) lie in \(S^{\perp }\). To show that \(f \in S^{\perp }\), let \(l\colon A \to B\) be a morphism in \(S\), and consider the following commutative diagram:
By assumption, the right and outer squares are pullback squares, hence by the pasting law so is the left square. Right cancellation for \({}^\perp S\) follows dually.
For (5), let \(r\) be the limit in \(\Ar (C)\) of a diagram of morphisms \(r_i \in S^\perp \). For any \(l\colon A\to B\) in \(S\), the square defining \(l\perp r\) is the limit of the squares defining \(l\perp r_i\), since \(\Hom _C(A,-)\) and \(\Hom _C(B,-)\) preserve limits. Limits of pullback squares are pullback squares, so \(r\in S^\perp \). The assertion about colimits is dual. □