In topology, the morphisms in various categories under consideration often form a topological space, and composition is continuous. Such a topologically enriched category should give an \(\infty \)-category, called its homotopy coherent nerve, whose hom animae are obtained from the hom spaces by applying the functor \(\Pi _{\infty }\colon \Top \to \An \). One way to make this precise is via the theory of enriched \(\infty \)-categories: one may identify \(\infty \)-categories with \(\An \)-enriched \(\infty \)-categories [Heine (2023), Lemma 6.18] and then obtain a functor from topologically enriched categories by changing enrichments along \(\Pi _{\infty }\). Here we by-pass this technology and construct the \(\infty \)-category directly from the topological enrichment using colimits in \(\Cat _{\infty }\); its relation to the quasicategorical construction from Example 1.6.14 is explained in Remark 25.3.3.
Definition 25.3.1. A topologically enriched category is a classical 1-category \(D\) together with a chosen topology on each of the hom sets \(\Hom _D(X,Y)\) for \(X,Y \in D\), satisfying the property that the composition maps \(\Hom _D(Y,Z) \times \Hom _D(X,Y) \to \Hom _D(X,Z)\) are continuous with respect to these topologies. We denote by \(\Homtop _D(X,Y) \in \Top \) the hom set in \(C\) equipped with the chosen topology.
Construction 25.3.2 (Homotopy coherent nerve). Consider a topologically enriched category \(D\). We will define an \(\infty \)-category \(\Ntop (D)\), called the homotopy coherent nerve of \(D\).
For every \([n] \in \simp \catop \), consider the (classical) 1-category \(D_n\) defined as follows:
- The objects of \(D_n\) are the objects of \(D\);
- The morphisms \(X \to Y\) of \(D_n\) are the continuous maps \(\abs {\Delta ^n} \to \Homtop _D(X,Y)\);
- The identity in \(D_n\) is the constant map \(\abs {\Delta ^n} \to \Homtop _D(X,X)\) with value \(\id _X\);
- The composition in \(D_n\) of morphisms \(f\colon \abs {\Delta ^n} \to \Homtop _D(X,Y)\) and \(g\colon \abs {\Delta ^n} \to \Homtop _D(Y,Z)\) is the composite \[ \abs {\Delta ^n} \xrightarrow {\Delta } \abs {\Delta ^n} \times \abs {\Delta ^n} \xrightarrow {g \times f} \Homtop _D(Y,Z) \times \Homtop _D(X,Y) \xrightarrow {\circ } \Homtop _D(X,Z). \]
Since \(\abs {\Delta ^n}\) is functorial in \([n] \in \simp \) (see Example 1.6.8) we see that the assignment \([n] \mapsto D_n\) determines a functor \[ D_{\bullet }\colon \simp \catop \to \Cat _1 \hookrightarrow \Cat _{\infty }. \] We then define the \(\infty \)-category \(\Ntop (D)\) as the colimit of this functor: \[ \Ntop (D) \quad := \quad \colim (D_{\bullet }\colon \simp \catop \to \Cat _{\infty }). \]
Note that \(D_0\) is the underlying category of \(D\). Since it admits a canonical functor to \(\Ntop (D)\), we see that every object of \(D\) gives rise to an object of \(\Ntop (D)\), and in fact all objects are of this form.
Remark 25.3.3. The fact that we refer to \(\Ntop (D)\) as the ‘homotopy coherent nerve’ is somewhat abusive: this terminology is often used instead for the simplicial set \(N^{\Delta }(\bC )\) associated to a simplicially enriched category, cf. Example 1.6.14. The two constructions are closely related: given a topologically enriched category \(D\), we may obtain a simplicially enriched category \(\bC \) by taking \(\Hom ^{\Delta }_{\bC }(X,Y) := \Sing (\Homtop _{D}(X,Y))\), i.e. we apply the singular simplicial complex construction from Example 1.6.8 to each of the hom spaces of \(D\). Then the underlying \(\infty \)-category of the quasicategory \(N^{\Delta }(\bC )\) is equivalent to \(\Ntop (D)\). The proof of this fact is quite technical: it relies on the fact that there is a model structure (due to Bergner (2007)) on the category of (small) simplicially enriched categories whose localization at the weak equivalences is \(\Cat _{\infty }\). A reference for this claim in the literature may be found in Gepner and Meier (2023), Corollary B.4.
Proposition 25.3.4. For objects \(X\) and \(Y\) of \(D\), the hom anima between \(X\) and \(Y\) in \(\Ntop (D)\) is equivalent to the underlying anima of the topological space \(\Homtop _D(X,Y)\): \[ \Hom _{\Ntop (D)}(X,Y) \simeq \Pi _{\infty }(\Homtop _D(X,Y)). \]
Proof. Let \(B_n\) be the ordinary simplicial nerve of \(D_n\), regarded as a simplicial anima, and put \(B:=\colim _n B_n\). Since geometric realizations commute with finite products in animae, we have \[ B_k\simeq \coprod _{x_0,\ldots ,x_k\in \operatorname {Ob}(D)}\prod _{j=1}^k\Pi _{\infty }\Homtop _D(x_{j-1},x_j). \] Consequently, \(B\) is a Segal anima with object anima the discrete set \(\operatorname {Ob}(D)\) and the asserted hom animae. By Remark 1.8.13, the associated category of \(B_n\) is \(D_n\). Since the associated-category functor preserves colimits, its value on \(B\) is therefore \(\Ntop (D)\). The result follows from Proposition 25.1.9, since the completion map preserves hom animae. □
Exercises
Exercise 25.1 (Composition in a Segal anima). Let \(X\) be a Segal anima. Show that the degeneracy map \(s_0\colon X_0\to X_1\) defines identity morphisms and that the composition map \[ X_1\times _{X_0}X_1\simeq X_2\xrightarrow {d_1}X_1 \] is unital and associative.
Exercise 25.2 (Nerves and completeness).
- (1)
-
Let \(C\) be an \(\infty \)-category. Show that its \(\infty \)-categorical nerve \(N(C)_n=\Map ([n],C)\) is a complete Segal anima.
- (2)
-
Let \(C\) be a classical 1-category. Regard its nerve \(N(C)\in \sSet \) from Example 1.6.11 as a simplicial anima. Show that it is a Segal anima. Is it complete? Determine precisely when this holds.
Exercise 25.3 (Discrete topological enrichment). Let \(C\) be a classical 1-category and regard it as a topologically enriched category \(C^{\mathrm {disc}}\) by giving each hom set the discrete topology. Show that the canonical functor \[ C\longrightarrow \Ntop (C^{\mathrm {disc}}) \] is an equivalence of \(\infty \)-categories.