Let \(X\) be a topological space. We write \(\Vect ^{\disc }(X)\) for the 1-category whose objects are the finite-rank complex vector bundles over \(X\) and whose morphisms are the morphisms of vector bundles over \(X\). The superscript \(\disc \) indicates that we are not yet recording the topology on spaces of bundle maps. Since vector bundles are stable under base change along continuous maps, this gives a contravariant functor \[ \Vect ^{\disc }\colon \Top \catop \to \Cat . \] We show that \(\Vect ^{\disc }(X)\) can be equipped with a symmetric monoidal structure via tensor product of complex vector bundles. We construct this structure explicitly using Lurie’s equivalent model of symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-categories over \(\Fin _*\).
Construction 9.5.1. For a finite pointed set \(S_+\), we write \(S\) for the complement of the basepoint. Define a 1-category \[ \Vect ^{\otimes ,\disc }(X) \] equipped with a functor \(p_X\colon \Vect ^{\otimes ,\disc }(X) \to \Fin _*\) as follows. An object over \(S_+\) is an \(S\)-indexed family \((V_s)_{s \in S}\) of vector bundles over \(X\). A morphism over a pointed map \(\alpha \colon S_+ \to T_+\) from \((V_s)_{s \in S}\) to \((W_t)_{t \in T}\) consists of, for every \(t \in T\), a map over \(X\) \[ \phi _t\colon \prod _{s \in \alpha ^{-1}(t)} V_s \longrightarrow W_t \] which is continuous and complex multilinear on each fiber. Here the product is the fiber product over \(X\), and if \(\alpha ^{-1}(t)=\emptyset \) we interpret the source as \(X\), so that \(\phi _t\) is the same as a section of \(W_t\).
Composition is substitution of multilinear maps. Thus, if \(\beta \colon T_+ \to U_+\) is another pointed map and \(\psi _u\colon \prod _{t \in \beta ^{-1}(u)}W_t \to Z_u\) is the corresponding family of multilinear maps, the composite over \(\beta \alpha \) is given by \[ (v_s)_{s \in (\beta \alpha )^{-1}(u)} \longmapsto \psi _u\left ( \left (\phi _t((v_s)_{s \in \alpha ^{-1}(t)})\right )_{t \in \beta ^{-1}(u)} \right ). \] This is again multilinear in all variables. The identity morphism over \(\id _{S_+}\) is given by the identity maps \(V_s \to V_s\).
Proposition 9.5.2. The functor \[ p_X\colon \Vect ^{\otimes ,\disc }(X) \to \Fin _* \] is a cocartesian fibration of 1-categories. It therefore defines a symmetric monoidal 1-category whose underlying category is \(\Vect ^{\disc }(X)\) and whose tensor product is the tensor product of vector bundles.
Proof. Let \(\alpha \colon S_+ \to T_+\) be a pointed map and let \((V_s)_{s \in S}\) be an object over \(S_+\). For each \(t \in T\), choose the tensor product \[ W_t := \bigotimes _{s \in \alpha ^{-1}(t)} V_s, \] with the convention that the tensor product over the empty set is the trivial line bundle \(\ul {\C }\). Let \[ \mu _t\colon \prod _{s \in \alpha ^{-1}(t)} V_s \to W_t \] be the universal multilinear map. Local trivializations show that \(W_t\) is again a vector bundle and that \(\mu _t\) is continuous. These maps define a morphism \[ (V_s)_{s \in S} \longrightarrow (W_t)_{t \in T} \] over \(\alpha \).
We claim that this morphism is \(p_X\)-cocartesian. Let \(\beta \colon T_+ \to U_+\) be another pointed map, and let \((Z_u)_{u \in U}\) be an object over \(U_+\). By definition, a morphism from \((W_t)_{t \in T}\) to \((Z_u)_{u \in U}\) over \(\beta \) is a family of multilinear maps \[ \prod _{t \in \beta ^{-1}(u)} W_t \to Z_u. \] Precomposition with the maps \(\mu _t\) identifies this set with the set of multilinear maps \[ \prod _{s \in (\beta \alpha )^{-1}(u)} V_s \to Z_u, \] for all \(u \in U\), by the universal property of the tensor products \(W_t\). This is the required universal property of a cocartesian morphism.
The fiber over \(S_+\) is visibly \(\Vect ^{\disc }(X)^S\), so the Segal maps are isomorphisms. Thus \(p_X\) is a symmetric monoidal category in Lurie’s model. Taking nerves gives the corresponding cocartesian fibration of \(\infty \)-categories, and the equivalence of \(\infty \)-operad models from Proposition 19.4.8 carries it to the desired symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category over \(\Span (\Fin )\). Its tensor product is obtained by pushing forward along the active map \(\{1,2\}_+ \to \{1\}_+\), hence is the usual tensor product of vector bundles. □
Tensor product of vector bundles preserves finite direct sums in each variable, so the preceding semiring construction applies.
Corollary 9.5.3. For every topological space \(X\), the groupoid \[ \Vect ^{\disc }(X)^{\simeq } \] of finite-rank complex vector bundles and bundle isomorphisms is naturally an object of \(\CRig (\An )\). This structure is contravariantly functorial in \(X\) by pullback.
Proof. Direct sum gives finite coproducts in the small 1-category \(\Vect ^{\disc }(X)\), with initial object the rank-zero bundle \(\ul {0}\). Tensor product distributes over direct sums in each variable, so Corollary 20.3.4 applies to the symmetric monoidal structure of Proposition 9.5.2. This construction is natural in symmetric monoidal functors which preserve finite coproducts. Since pullback preserves direct sums, tensor products, and trivial bundles, it gives the asserted functoriality in \(X\). □
The 1-category \(\Vect ^{\disc }(X)\) discards the natural compact-open topologies on its hom sets. Let us first explain how the familiar topological enrichment motivates the construction below. Suppose that \(X\) is compact Hausdorff. The spaces \(\Iso _X(E,E')\) of bundle isomorphisms, with their compact-open topologies, form the hom spaces of a topologically enriched groupoid. Its homotopy coherent nerve, in the sense of Construction 25.3.2, remembers the underlying anima of each of these spaces of isomorphisms by Proposition 25.3.4.
The simplicial resolution used to construct this nerve has the same vector bundles as objects in every degree, while its morphisms in degree \(n\) are the continuous maps \[ \Hom _{\Top }(\abs {\Delta ^n},\Iso _X(E,E')). \] The total spaces of vector bundles over a compact Hausdorff space are locally compact Hausdorff, so the compact-open exponential law identifies this set with \[ \Iso _{X\times \abs {\Delta ^n}} \bigl (\pr _X^*E,\pr _X^*E'\bigr ). \] Thus the groupoid in simplicial degree \(n\) is equivalent to the full subgroupoid of \(\Vect ^{\disc }(X\times \abs {\Delta ^n})^{\simeq }\) spanned by the bundles pulled back from \(X\). Every vector bundle over \(X\times \abs {\Delta ^n}\) is isomorphic to one of this form by Theorem 9.1.4. Consequently the inclusion of this full subgroupoid is an equivalence. For compact Hausdorff \(X\), the colimit below is therefore the standard simplicial model for the homotopy coherent nerve of the topologically enriched groupoid of vector bundles and bundle isomorphisms. We use the same formula as our definition for an arbitrary topological space.
The coherent direct sums and tensor products therefore refine the simplicial diagram in Definition 9.4.1 to a diagram in \(\CRig (\An )\).
In this realization, a bundle over \(X\times [0,1]\) gives an identification between its endpoint restrictions; bundles over \(X\times \abs {\Delta ^n}\) supply the higher identifications. Direct sums and tensor products are defined degreewise.
Proof. Functoriality follows from pullback. The \(\infty \)-category \(\simp \catop \) is sifted by Proposition 22.6.9, and the forgetful functors \[ \CRig (\An )\longrightarrow \CMon (\An )\longrightarrow \An \] create sifted colimits. For the second functor, this follows by regarding \(\CMon (\An )\) as the full subcategory of \(\Fun (\Span (\Fin ),\An )\) spanned by the finite-product-preserving functors: pointwise sifted colimits preserve this condition by Lemma 22.6.11. For the first functor, use \(\CRig (\An )=\CAlg (\CMon (\An ))\), the fact that \(\CMon (\An )\) is presentably symmetric monoidal by Theorem 18.2.5, and [Lurie (2017), Corollary 3.2.3.2]. This proves the assertion about the underlying anima.
Applying \(\pi _0\) to the geometric realization gives the coequalizer of the two endpoint maps from simplicial degree \(1\) to degree \(0\). If \(X\) is paracompact Hausdorff, the endpoint restrictions of every vector bundle over \(X\times [0,1]\) are isomorphic by Theorem 9.1.4. Thus the two maps agree, and the coequalizer is \(\pi _0\Vect ^{\disc }(X)^{\simeq }\). □
Proof. The constructions and proofs of Proposition 9.5.2, Corollary 9.5.3, Proposition 9.4.2 apply verbatim with \(\C \) replaced by \(\R \). □
We now specialize to \(X=\pt \). Recall from Subsection 9.4.2 that the group completion of \(\Vect (\pt )^{\simeq }\) is the infinite loop anima underlying connective complex K-theory. The semiring structure above supplies its multiplication and all its coherences.
Proof. By Proposition 9.4.2, we have \[ \Vect (\pt )^{\simeq } \in \CAlg (\CMon (\An )). \] By Proposition 16.6.4, the composite \[ \CMon (\An ) \xrightarrow {(-)^{\grp }} \CGrp (\An ) \xhookrightarrow {\bB ^{\infty }} \Sp \] is symmetric monoidal. Applying it to the commutative algebra object \(\Vect (\pt )^{\simeq }\) gives a commutative algebra object of \(\Sp \), i.e. a commutative ring spectrum. Under Theorem 5.4.6, the functor \(\bB ^{\infty }\colon \CGrp (\An )\to \Sp _{\geq 0}\) is the inverse of the recognition equivalence, and \((-)^{\grp }\) is the same group-completion left adjoint used in Subsection 9.4.2. Its underlying spectrum is therefore \(\ku \). □
Exercises
Exercise 9.1 (Direct sums, tensor products, and K-theory). Let \(E_1\) and \(E_2\) be complex vector bundles over a topological space \(X\).
- (1)
-
Show that the fiber product \(E_1\times _XE_2\), with its fiberwise direct-sum structure, is again a vector bundle. Verify that direct sum makes \(\pi _0\Vect (X)\) into an abelian monoid.
- (2)
-
Construct the tensor-product bundle \(E_1\otimes E_2\), whose fiber over \(x\in X\) is \((E_1)_x\otimes _{\C }(E_2)_x\). Show that tensor product is unital, commutative, associative, and distributive over direct sum on isomorphism classes, making \(\pi _0\Vect (X)\) into a commutative semiring. Verify that direct sum and tensor product commute with pullback.
- (3)
-
Assume now that \(X\) is compact Hausdorff. Deduce that multiplication extends uniquely across group completion to a commutative ring structure on \(K^0(X)\), and that pullback makes \(K^0\) a contravariant functor from compact Hausdorff spaces to commutative rings.
Exercise 9.2 (Stable equivalence and reduced K-theory). Let \(X\) be a compact Hausdorff space and consider the morphism of abelian monoids \[ \pi _0\Vect (X)\to K^0(X)\to \widetilde K^0(X). \]
- (1)
-
Show that two vector bundles \(E\) and \(E'\) have the same image in \(\widetilde K^0(X)\) if and only if there are \(n,m\geq 0\) and an isomorphism \[ E\oplus \ul {\C }^n\cong E'\oplus \ul {\C }^m. \]
- (2)
-
For the discrete space \(X=\{1,\dots ,r\}\), where \(r\geq 1\), compute \(K^0(X)\) and \(\widetilde K^0(X)\). Identify the map \(\Z \to K^0(X)\) and the isomorphism from \(\widetilde K^0(X)\) to the kernel of restriction to the basepoint \(1\). Show that if \(X\) is disconnected, \(\widetilde K^0(X)\) can contain classes whose virtual rank is nonzero on some component.
Exercise 9.3 (Pointwise operations on classifying maps). Let \(X\) be a cell complex. Using the commutative semiring structure on \[ \Vect (\pt )^{\simeq }\simeq \bigsqcup _{k\geq 0}\bB U(k), \] show that \(\Hom _{\An }(\Pi _\infty X,\Vect (\pt )^{\simeq })\) admits a canonical commutative semiring structure. Under the classification of Corollary 9.2.15, identify addition and multiplication on its set of components with direct sum and tensor product of vector bundles.
Exercise 9.4 (Connective and periodic K-theory of spheres). For every \(k\in \Z \) and \(n\geq 0\), compute the groups and the natural map \[ \widetilde {\ku }^{\,k}(S^n)\longrightarrow \widetilde {\KU }^{\,k}(S^n). \] When these groups are nonzero, identify generators as powers of the Bott class under the suspension isomorphisms. Explain which negative powers occur in periodic K-theory and why they have no connective counterpart.
Exercise 9.5 (The rational Chern character of projective space). Let \(m\geq 0\), let \(H\to \CP ^m\) be the tautological line bundle, and put \(x=c_1(H)\) and \(u=[H]-[\ul {\C }]\in \KU ^0(\CP ^m)\). Show that \[ \mathrm {ch}(u)=e^x-1\in H^*(\CP ^m;\Q )\cong \Q [x]/(x^{m+1}). \] Deduce that the map \[ \Q [t]/(t^{m+1})\longrightarrow \KU ^0(\CP ^m)\otimes \Q , \qquad t\longmapsto u\otimes 1, \] is a well-defined isomorphism of commutative \(\Q \)-algebras. Compute \(\KU ^k(\CP ^m)\otimes \Q \) for every \(k\in \Z \).