The construction of \(\Sp \) in Chapter 4 used prespectra. For the symmetric monoidal structure, a different model is more convenient. We will consider functors from finite pointed animae which send the zero object to a terminal object and pushout squares to pullback squares. We will show that these reduced excisive functors give a second model for spectra, and that their inclusion into the full functor category admits a left adjoint. This realizes \(\Sp \) as a Bousfield localization of a functor category on which Day convolution is available.

Definition 16.5.1. Let \(F\colon C \to D\) be a functor between \(\infty \)-categories.

(1)

If \(C\) admits pushouts, we say that \(F\) is excisive if it sends pushout squares in \(C\) to pullback squares in \(D\).

(2)

If \(C\) admits a terminal object, we say that \(F\) is reduced if it sends the terminal object of \(C\) to a terminal object of \(D\).

We write \(\Exc (C,D) \subseteq \Fun (C,D)\) for the full subcategory of excisive functors, \(\Fun _*(C,D) \subseteq \Fun (C,D)\) for the full subcategory of reduced functors, and \(\Exc _*(C,D)\) for their intersection.

Notation 16.5.2. We write \(\An _*^{\fin }\) for the small \(\infty \)-category of finite pointed animae. Its universal property is given in Lemma 4.3.12.

Definition 16.5.3. Let \(C\) be an \(\infty \)-category with finite limits. We denote by \(\Sp ^{\exc }(C)\) the full subcategory \[ \Sp ^{\exc }(C) := \Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin }, C) \subseteq \Fun (\An _*^{\fin }, C) \] spanned by the reduced, excisive functors from \(\An _*^{\fin }\) to \(C\). We denote by \(\Omega ^{\infty }\colon \Sp ^{\exc }(C) \to C\) the evaluation at \(S^0 \in \An _*^{\fin }\).

A reduced functor \(\An _*^{\fin }\to C\) has a canonical lift to \(C_*\), obtained from the maps \(F(*)\to F(X)\); cf.Β Lemma 4.1.13. We will therefore freely use the equivalence \[ \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C)\simeq \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C_*), \] and its restriction to reduced excisive functors.

The following criterion is the basic reason that reduced excisive functors behave like spectra.

Construction 16.5.4. Let \(C\) be a pointed \(\infty \)-category with finite colimits, let \(D\) be a pointed \(\infty \)-category with finite limits, and let \(F\colon C \to D\) be a reduced functor. Applying \(F\) to the pushout square defining \(\Sigma _CX\) gives a square

Commutative square with maps F(X) to 0, 0 to F(\Sigma CX), F(X) to 0, 0 to F(\Sigma CX).

and hence a canonical map \[ \eta _X\colon F(X) \to \Omega _DF(\Sigma _CX). \]

Proposition 16.5.5 (Excisiveness criterion). Let \(C\) be a pointed \(\infty \)-category with finite colimits and let \(D\) be a pointed \(\infty \)-category with finite limits. A reduced functor \(F\colon C \to D\) is excisive if and only if the map \(\eta _X\colon F(X) \to \Omega _DF(\Sigma _CX)\) is an isomorphism for every object \(X \in C\).

Proof. If \(F\) is excisive, it sends the pushout square defining \(\Sigma _CX\) to a pullback square, so the canonical map \[ \eta _X\colon F(X)\longrightarrow \Omega _DF(\Sigma _CX) \] is an isomorphism.

Conversely, suppose these maps are isomorphisms. Consider a pushout square

Commutative square with maps Z to X, Y to W, Z to Y, X to W.

We must show that its comparison map \[ \alpha \colon F(Z)\longrightarrow P:=F(X)\times _{F(W)}F(Y) \] is an isomorphism. Put \(A:=X\sqcup _Z 0\) and \(B:=0\sqcup _Z Y\), and extend the square by pushouts to the diagram

Commutative diagram involving Z, X, 0, Y, W, B, A, \Sigma C Z, \Sigma C Y, \Sigma C X, and further objects.

Applying \(F\), the map \(W\to \Sigma _C Z\) and its specified nullhomotopies on \(X\) and \(Y\) induce a map \[ \beta \colon P\longrightarrow \Omega _DF(\Sigma _C Z). \] The outer suspension square of \(Z\) identifies \(\beta \alpha \) with \(\eta _Z\).

The suspension rectangles of \(Z,X,Y,W\) form a coherent square of squares. After applying \(F\) and replacing \(F(Z)\) by its pullback cone \(P\), they give a square of arrows with vertices \(\beta ,\eta _X,\eta _Y,\eta _W\). Taking the pullback of the last three arrows therefore identifies the composite \[ P\xrightarrow {\beta }\Omega _DF(\Sigma _C Z) \longrightarrow \Omega _DF(\Sigma _C X)\times _{\Omega _DF(\Sigma _C W)}\Omega _DF(\Sigma _C Y) \] with the map induced by \(\eta _X,\eta _W,\eta _Y\). This composite is an isomorphism, since all three maps are isomorphisms. Since \(\beta \alpha =\eta _Z\) is also an isomorphism, two-out-of-six shows that \(\alpha \) is an isomorphism. Thus \(F\) is excisive. β–‘

Corollary 16.5.6. The following conditions are equivalent for a reduced functor \(F\colon C \to D\) between stable \(\infty \)-categories:

(1)

\(F\) is an exact functor;

(2)

\(F\) commutes with loop objects;

(3)

\(F\) commutes with suspensions.

Proof. Since \(C\) and \(D\) are stable, the functor \(F\) is exact if and only if it is excisive. By Proposition 16.5.5, this holds if and only if the canonical map \(F(X)\to \Omega _DF(\Sigma _CX)\) is an isomorphism for every \(X\in C\). By adjunction, this is equivalent to the canonical map \(\Sigma _DF(X)\to F(\Sigma _CX)\) being an isomorphism. Thus exactness is equivalent to preservation of suspensions, and preservation of loops is equivalent because suspension and loops are inverse equivalences in both \(\infty \)-categories. β–‘

Proposition 16.5.7. Let \(C\) be a pointed \(\infty \)-category with finite colimits and let \(D\) be an \(\infty \)-category with finite limits. Then \(\Exc _*(C,D)\) is stable.

Proof. By replacing \(D\) with \(D_*\), we may assume \(D\) is pointed. The \(\infty \)-category \(\Exc _*(C,D)\) has finite limits computed pointwise, and reduced excisive functors are closed under such limits. It is also pointed. By Theorem 4.2.2, it remains to show that its loop functor is an equivalence.

The loop functor is computed pointwise: \(\Omega (F)=\Omega _D\circ F\). Define a shift functor by \(\Shift (F):=F\circ \Sigma _C\). Since \(\Sigma _C\) preserves zero objects and pushout squares, \(\Shift (F)\) is again reduced excisive. Applying an excisive functor \(F\) to the pushout square defining suspension gives natural isomorphisms \[ F \simeq \Omega _DF\Sigma _C = \Omega (\Shift F) = \Shift (\Omega F), \] so \(\Omega \) and \(\Shift \) are inverse equivalences. β–‘

Lemma 16.5.8. If \(C\) is stable, the evaluation functor \(\Omega ^\infty \colon \Sp ^{\exc }(C) \to C\) is an equivalence.

Proof. When \(C\) is stable, a reduced functor \(\An _*^{\fin }\to C\) is excisive if and only if it preserves finite colimits. Hence \[ \Sp ^{\exc }(C) = \Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \simeq \Fun _*^{\mathrm {rex}}(\An _*^{\fin },C). \] Evaluation at \(S^0\) is an equivalence by the universal property of \(\An _*^{\fin }\) from Notation 16.5.2. β–‘

Corollary 16.5.9. The \(\infty \)-category \(\Sp ^{\exc }(C)\) is stable for every \(\infty \)-category \(C\) with finite limits.

Proof. Take the source \(\infty \)-category in Proposition 16.5.7 to be \(\An _*^{\fin }\). β–‘

Proposition 16.5.10. For every \(\infty \)-category \(C\) with finite limits, the evaluation functor \(\ev _{S^0}\colon \Sp ^{\exc }(C) \to C\) exhibits \(\Sp ^{\exc }(C)\) as a stabilization of \(C\).

Proof. The functor \(\ev _{S^0}\) is left exact, since limits in the functor category are computed pointwise and reduced excisive functors are closed under limits. Let \(D\) be stable. Since pushout squares and pullback squares agree in \(D\), a functor \(D \to C\) is left exact if and only if it is reduced and excisive. Thus it is enough to show that \[ \Exc _*(D,\Sp ^{\exc }(C)) \to \Exc _*(D,C) \] is an equivalence. Since reducedness and excisiveness are pointwise conditions, currying restricts to the relevant full subcategories and identifies the source with \[ \Exc _*(D,\Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },C)) \simeq \Sp ^{\exc }(\Exc _*(D,C)). \] The target \(\Exc _*(D,C)\) is stable by Proposition 16.5.7, so evaluation at \(S^0\) is an equivalence by Lemma 16.5.8. β–‘

Corollary 16.5.11. There is a unique equivalence \[ \Sp \simeq \Sp ^{\exc }(\An )=\Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },\An ) \] under which the two functors to \(\An \) given by \(\Omega ^\infty \) and evaluation at \(S^0\) agree.

Proof. By Proposition 4.3.16, Proposition 16.5.10, both sides, equipped with the displayed functors to \(\An \), are stabilizations of \(\An \). The result follows from the uniqueness of stabilization. β–‘

Proposition 16.5.12 (Excisive approximation). Let \(C\) be an \(\infty \)-category that admits finite limits, finite colimits, and sequential colimits, and assume that the loop functor \(\Omega \colon C_*\to C_*\) preserves sequential colimits. Then the two inclusions \[ \Sp ^{\exc }(C)=\Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \hookrightarrow \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \qquadtext { and } \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \hookrightarrow \Fun (\An _*^{\fin },C) \] admit left adjoints \[ P_1\colon \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \to \Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \qquadtext { and } (-)^{\mathrm {red}}\colon \Fun (\An _*^{\fin },C) \to \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C). \]

Proof. For the reduction functor, let \(F\colon \An _*^{\fin }\to C\) be arbitrary. Since \(*\) is initial in \(\An _*^{\fin }\), the unique natural transformation \(\const _*\to \id \) induces \(\const _{F(*)}\to F\). Define \[ F^{\mathrm {red}}(X):=*\sqcup _{F(*)}F(X). \] This is reduced. If \(G\) is reduced, every natural transformation \(F\to G\) vanishes on \(F(*)\), and hence factors uniquely through \(F\to F^{\mathrm {red}}\). Thus \((-)^{\mathrm {red}}\) is left adjoint to the inclusion of reduced functors.

For \(P_1\), we may replace \(C\) by \(C_*\), which inherits finite and sequential colimits from \(C\), so assume \(C\) is pointed. Write \[ T(F):=\Omega F\Sigma \] for the endofunctor of \(\Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C)\), equipped with the natural transformation \(\eta \colon \id \to T\) from Construction 16.5.4. Apply the final composite identity in the proof of Proposition 16.5.5 to the suspension square of \(X\). In the notation of that proof, \(P=T(F)(X)\) and \(\beta \) is the identity, so it gives a natural identification \[ T(\eta _F)\simeq \eta _{T(F)}. \]

Now let \(F\colon \An _*^{\fin }\to C\) be reduced. Iterate \(\eta \) to form \[ F \xrightarrow {\eta _F} T(F) \xrightarrow {\eta _{T(F)}} T^2(F) \longrightarrow \cdots \] and define \[ P_1(F):=\colim _{n\geq 0}T^n(F). \] Thus \(T^n(F)\simeq \Omega ^nF\Sigma ^n\), with the transition maps given by \(\eta _{T^n(F)}\).

The functor \(T\) preserves sequential colimits by assumption. Consequently, \[ T(P_1(F))\simeq \colim _{n\geq 0}T^{n+1}(F), \] and under this isomorphism \(\eta _{P_1(F)}\) is the map from the defining telescope to its tail. The shift \(n\mapsto n+1\) is cofinal, so this map is an isomorphism. The excisiveness criterion now shows that \(P_1(F)\) is excisive.

It remains to verify the universal property. The coherence \(T(\eta _G)\simeq \eta _{T(G)}\) identifies the sequential diagram defining \(P_1(T(G))\) with the tail of the diagram defining \(P_1(G)\), compatibly with \[ P_1(\eta _G)\colon P_1(G)\longrightarrow P_1(T(G)). \] Thus \(P_1(\eta _G)\) corresponds to the cofinal tail map and is an isomorphism. Moreover, \(P_1\) preserves sequential colimits, since \(T\) does.

Let \(u_F\colon F\to P_1(F)\) be the map into the telescope. Since \(P_1\) preserves sequential colimits, the map \[ P_1(u_F)\colon P_1(F)\longrightarrow P_1(P_1(F)) \] is the sequential colimit of the maps \(P_1(F)\to P_1(T^n(F))\). Each of these is a composite of the isomorphisms \(P_1(\eta _{T^k(F)})\), so \(P_1(u_F)\) is an isomorphism. If \(G\) is already excisive, the excisiveness criterion shows that every map in the defining telescope for \(P_1(G)\) is an isomorphism, so \(u_G\colon G\to P_1(G)\) is an isomorphism. In particular, \(u_{P_1(F)}\) is an isomorphism. By Proposition 22.7.9, the functor \(P_1\) is left adjoint to the inclusion of reduced excisive functors. β–‘

Corollary 16.5.13. The conclusion of Proposition 16.5.12 applies when \(C=\An \) or \(C=\An _*\).

Proof. Both \(\infty \)-categories admit the required limits and colimits. Moreover, filtered colimits of animae commute with finite limits, so their loop functors preserve sequential colimits. β–‘

Lemma 16.5.14. The evaluation functor \[ \ev _{S^0}\colon \Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },\An _*) \to \An _* \] admits a left adjoint. It sends a pointed anima \(X\) to the excisive approximation of the smash product functor \[ P_1(X \wedge -) \colon \An _*^{\fin } \to \An _*. \]

Proof. First consider evaluation at \(S^0\) on the full functor category. Its left adjoint is the left Kan extension along \(S^0\colon *\to \An _*^{\fin }\), which sends a pointed anima \(X\) to the functor \[ K\longmapsto X\wedge \fgt (K)_+. \] Its value at the zero object is \(X\). Applying the reduction functor gives \(K\mapsto X\wedge K\), since the cofiber of the canonical map \(S^0\to \fgt (K)_+\) is \(K\). Thus \(X\wedge -\) is left adjoint to evaluation on reduced functors. Composing with the excisive approximation \(P_1\), which exists by Corollary 16.5.13, gives the asserted left adjoint on reduced excisive functors. β–‘