Pointed objects, commutative monoids, and commutative groups are obtained by restricting Day convolution to suitable diagrams. In place of \(\An _*^{\fin }\), we use \([1]\) for pointed objects and \(\Span (\Fin )\) for monoids and groups. Evaluation at their monoidal units gives the counits of the adjunctions in Theorem 20.2.10.
Definition 20.4.1. If \(\Oo \) is an \(\infty \)-operad with an operadic terminal object, equip \([1]\) with the symmetric monoidal structure given by the minimum, as used in the proof of Lemma 16.3.3, and denote by \[ \Oo _* \quad \subseteq \quad \oDay (\Mm _{[1]}, \Oo ) \] the full suboperad whose colors are those functors \(F\colon [1] \to U(\Oo )\) satisfying \(F(0) \simeq *\). If in addition \(\Oo \) has finite operadic products, equip \(\Span (\Fin )\) with the symmetric monoidal structure induced by the cartesian product of finite sets, and denote by \[ \oCGrp (\Oo ) \quad \subseteq \quad \oCMon (\Oo ) \quad \subseteq \quad \oDay (\Mm _{\Span (\Fin )}, \Oo ) \] the full suboperads whose colors are those functors \(F\colon \Span (\Fin ) \to U(\Oo )\) that are commutative groups or commutative monoids in \(U(\Oo )\), respectively.
The tensor product on \(\Span (\Fin )\) is the cartesian product of finite sets, as in Proposition 16.4.1. Its categorical products, which the functors defining commutative monoids preserve, are disjoint unions by Lemma 13.3.8.
By construction, their underlying \(\infty \)-categories are \(U(\Oo )_*\), \(\CMon (U(\Oo ))\), and \(\CGrp (U(\Oo ))\), respectively.
Lemma 20.4.2 (Day convolution on pointed objects). Let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category satisfying the hypotheses of Lemma 16.3.4, and denote the resulting tensor on \(C_*\) by \(\wedge \). Then there is a natural equivalence \[ (\Mm _C)_* \simeq \Mm _{(C_*,\wedge )}. \]
Proof. The \(\infty \)-operad \((\Mm _C)_*\) is the full suboperad of the Day convolution operad on \(\Ar (C)\) spanned by the arrows with source the terminal object. The monoidal localization \[ \cofib \colon \Ar (C)^{\square }\longrightarrow (C_*,\wedge ) \] of Lemma 16.3.4 identifies this full suboperad with the multimorphism operad of its local objects. □
Lemma 20.4.3. If \(\Oo \) is pointed, then evaluation at the target defines an equivalence of \(\infty \)-operads \[ \ev _1\colon \Oo _* \to \Oo . \]
Proof. On underlying \(\infty \)-categories, evaluation identifies the \(\infty \)-category of arrows from the zero object with \(U(\Oo )\). It remains to prove full faithfulness on multimorphism animae.
Let \(\{F_i\}_{i\in I}\) and \(G\) be colors of \(\Oo _*\). By Theorem 19.6.3, their multimorphism anima is an end over \([1]^I\). We evaluate its variables at \(1\) one at a time. By Fubini, each step is the end of a bifunctor \(T\colon [1]\catop \times [1]\to \An \), allowing additional fixed colors among the inputs. This end is the pullback \[ T(0,0)\times _{T(0,1)}T(1,1). \] Both \(T(0,0)\) and \(T(0,1)\) are contractible because \(F_i(0)\) is the zero object and hence operadic initial. Thus this pullback is equivalent to \(T(1,1)\). Fubini for ends and induction, with the values \(F_i(1)\) already obtained treated as fixed inputs, identify the original end with \[ \Oo (\{F_i(1)\}_{i\in I};G(1)). \] By naturality of the end formula, this equivalence is the map induced by evaluation at \(1\). □
For commutative monoids, we use the following finite-product analogue of Lemma 20.2.4.
Lemma 20.4.4. Let \(T\colon \Span (\Fin )\catop \times \Span (\Fin )\to \An \) be a functor such that \(T(-,L)\) sends finite coproducts to products for every \(L\), and \(T(K,-)\) preserves finite products for every \(K\). Then the projection \[ \int _{K\in \Span (\Fin )}T(K,K)\longrightarrow T(1,1) \] is an equivalence, where \(1\) denotes a singleton.
Proof. Put \(B:=\Fun ^{\times }(\Span (\Fin )\catop ,\An )\). Reversal of spans identifies \(B\) with \(\CMon (\An )\) by Lemma 13.1.15, so \(B\) is semiadditive by Proposition 5.3.20. Since finite products and coproducts agree in \(\Span (\Fin )\), the Yoneda embedding factors through a finite-product-preserving functor \(j\colon \Span (\Fin )\to B\). The hypotheses on \(T\) give another such functor \(F\colon \Span (\Fin )\to B\), defined by \(F(L)=T(-,L)\). Yoneda and Proposition 5.3.17 give \[ \int _K T(K,K)\simeq \Nat (j,F) \simeq \Hom _B(j(1),F(1))\simeq T(1,1). \] The last two maps evaluate a natural transformation at \(1\) and then its component on \(\id _1\). Thus the composite is the stated projection. □
Proof of Theorem 20.2.10. We first prove the pointed case. Put \(E:=\Env (\Oo )\). The multiplicative Yoneda embedding and Lemma 19.6.1 give a fully faithful map \[ \Oo _* \hookrightarrow (\Mm _{\PSh (E)})_*. \] By Lemma 20.4.2, the target is the multimorphism operad of the pointed presheaf category and is therefore pointed by Example 20.1.8. The suboperad \(\Oo _*\) contains its zero object, since the multiplicative Yoneda embedding preserves the operadic terminal object of \(\Oo \). It follows from Lemma 20.1.9(1) that \(\Oo _*\) is pointed.
Evaluation at the target gives a natural operad map \(\Oo _*\to \Oo \). If \(\Oo \) is pointed, this map is an equivalence by Lemma 20.4.3. Applying the pointed-object construction a second time gives the same conclusion because \(\Oo _*\) is pointed. Interchanging the two coordinates of \([1]\times [1]\) exchanges the two ways of evaluating a doubly pointed object at \(1\), so both whiskerings of the evaluation transformation are equivalences. The dual of Proposition 22.7.9, applied in \((\Op _{\infty }^*)\catop \), therefore identifies \((-)_*\) as right adjoint to the inclusion of pointed \(\infty \)-operads.
For commutative monoids and groups, apply the same embedding into \(\Mm _{\PSh (E)}\). Proposition 16.4.1 constructs their Day convolution monoidal structures in \(\PSh (E)\). Their underlying categories are semiadditive and additive by Proposition 5.3.20, and their tensor products preserve colimits separately in both variables. Hence their finite biproducts are operadic. These biproducts are computed pointwise. Since the multiplicative Yoneda image is closed under finite products, the full suboperads consisting of objects valued in that image are closed under these biproducts. They are \(\oCMon (\Oo )\) and \(\oCGrp (\Oo )\), so Lemma 20.1.9(2) shows that the former is semiadditive and the latter additive.
Suppose now that \(\Oo \) is semiadditive. Evaluation at \(1\) gives an equivalence on underlying categories by Proposition 5.3.17. By Theorem 19.6.3, its map on multimorphism animae is the projection \[ \int _{\{K_i\}\in \Span (\Fin )^I} \Oo (\{F_i(K_i)\}_{i\in I};G(\prod _{i\in I}K_i)) \longrightarrow \Oo (\{F_i(1)\}_{i\in I};G(1)). \] We apply Lemma 20.4.4 one variable at a time, as in the proof of Proposition 20.2.5. Each \(F_i\) preserves finite coproducts: a finite-product-preserving functor between semiadditive \(\infty \)-categories preserves zero morphisms and hence the biproduct injections. Since these coproducts in \(\Oo \) are operadic, the contravariant variable sends them to products. For the covariant variable, \((-)\times R\) preserves disjoint unions in \(\Span (\Fin )\) for every finite set \(R\), hence preserves its finite products. Applying \(G\) and using operadic products gives the other hypothesis of the lemma. Taking ends preserves these products. The same arguments allow additional fixed inputs, so induction identifies the displayed projection with an equivalence. For \(I=\emptyset \), it is already the identity of \(\Oo (;G(1))\). Thus \(\oCMon (\Oo )\to \Oo \) is an equivalence of \(\infty \)-operads.
If \(\Oo \) is additive, every commutative monoid in \(U(\Oo )\) is grouplike by Proposition 5.3.17, so the same conclusion holds for \(\oCGrp (\Oo )\to \Oo \).
Finally, postcomposition with maps preserving finite operadic products preserves commutative monoids and groups, and their finite products are computed pointwise. Thus both constructions and their evaluation maps belong to \(\Op _\infty ^{\mathrm {prod}}\). Applying either construction twice gives functors on \(\Span (\Fin )\times \Span (\Fin )\) satisfying the respective monoid or group conditions in each variable. Interchanging the variables exchanges the two evaluation maps. Since the once-constructed \(\infty \)-operads are semiadditive or additive, the preceding paragraph shows that both whiskerings of evaluation are equivalences. The dual of Proposition 22.7.9 therefore gives the two remaining right adjoints. □
Corollary 20.4.5. Let \(C\) be a presentably symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. With the smash product on \(C_*\), the localized Day convolution structures on \(\CMon (C)\) and \(\CGrp (C)\), and the symmetric monoidal structure on \(\Sp (C)\simeq \Sp \otimes C\), there are natural equivalences \[ (\Mm _C)_* \simeq \Mm _{(C_*,\wedge )},\qquad \oCMon (\Mm _C) \simeq \Mm _{\CMon (C)}, \] \[ \oCGrp (\Mm _C) \simeq \Mm _{\CGrp (C)},\qquad \oSp (\Mm _C) \simeq \Mm _{\Sp (C)}. \] Taking \(C=(\An ,\times )\) recovers the four symmetric monoidal structures of Chapter 16.
Proof. The pointed case is Lemma 20.4.2. By Definition 20.4.1, \(\oCMon (\Mm _C)\) is the full Day convolution suboperad on product-preserving functors \(\Span (\Fin )\to C\). These are precisely the local objects of the symmetric monoidal localization onto \(\CMon (C)\) in Proposition 16.4.1, so this suboperad is \(\Mm _{\CMon (C)}\). The same argument with grouplike objects gives the assertion for \(\CGrp (C)\). The stable case is Corollary 20.2.7. □
Exercises
Exercise 20.1 (A stable suboperad of dualizable objects). Let \(C\) be a stably symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. Use Chapterexercise 11.2 to show that the full suboperad of \(\Mm _C\) on the dualizable objects is stable. Deduce that the full suboperad of \(\Mm _{\Sp }\) on the finite spectra is stable.
Exercise 20.2 (A stabilization that is not represented). Let \(C\) be a nonzero stable \(\infty \)-category, and consider its cartesian operad \(\OpCart (C)\). Show that evaluation identifies the underlying category of \(\oSp (\OpCart (C))\) with \(C\), but every multimorphism anima of arity other than one is contractible. Deduce that \(\oSp (\OpCart (C))\) is not represented by a symmetric monoidal structure on \(C\). Hint: Use finite biproducts to split the multimorphism end, then evaluate each factor in a variable absent from its input at the initial pointed anima.