Limits and colimits in the underlying category of an \(\infty \)-operad need not interact with its multimorphisms. We call them operadic when they satisfy the corresponding universal properties for multimorphism animae.
Definition 20.1.1. Let \(\Oo \) be an \(\infty \)-operad and let \(F\colon I \to U(\Oo )\) be a functor.
- (1)
-
A cone \(\eta \colon \const _y \to F\) in \(U(\Oo )\) is called an operadic limit if for every \(n \geq 0\) and all colors \(x_1, \dots , x_n \in \Oo ^{\simeq }\) the induced map \[ \Oo ((x_1, \dots , x_n); y) \to \lim _{i \in I} \Oo ((x_1, \dots , x_n); F(i)) \] is an equivalence of animae.
- (2)
-
A cocone \(\epsilon \colon F \to \const _x\) in \(U(\Oo )\) is called an operadic colimit if for every \(n \geq 1\) and all colors \(x_2, \dots , x_n, y \in \Oo ^{\simeq }\) the induced map \[ \Oo ((x, x_2, \dots , x_n); y) \to \lim _{i \in I\catop } \Oo ((F(i), x_2, \dots , x_n); y) \] is an equivalence of animae.
Remark 20.1.2. Taking \(n=1\) shows that operadic limits and colimits are limits and colimits in \(U(\Oo )\). We will usually assume that these exist and ask whether they are operadic.
Every object of \(\Env (\Oo )\) is a tensor \(x_1\otimes \cdots \otimes x_n\) of colors. By Lemma 19.3.14, maps from this tensor to a color \(y\) form the multimorphism anima \(\Oo ((x_1,\dots ,x_n);y)\). Thus a cone in \(U(\Oo )\) is an operadic limit if and only if it becomes a limit cone under the inclusion \(U(\Oo )\hookrightarrow \Env (\Oo )\).
The colimit condition tests maps into colors after tensoring the cocone with any fixed colors \(x_2,\dots ,x_n\). It does not test maps into arbitrary objects of the envelope. In particular, an operadic initial object need not be initial in \(\Env (\Oo )\).
Example 20.1.3. If \(\Oo = \Mm _C\) for a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\), then any limit in \(C\) is automatically operadic. This is because the tensor product provides a natural equivalence \[ \Mm _C((x_1, \dots , x_n); -) \simeq \Hom _C(x_1 \otimes \dots \otimes x_n, -), \] and the functor \(\Hom _C(X,-)\) preserves limits for any object \(X\).
Example 20.1.4. The unique color of the trivial operad \(\Triv \) is terminal in \(U(\Triv )\simeq *\), but it is not operadic terminal: the anima of nullary operations into it is empty.
Example 20.1.5. If \(\Oo = \Mm _C\) for a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\), then a colimit in \(C\) is operadic if and only if it is preserved by the functor \(x \otimes - \colon C \to C\) for every object \(x \in C\); the argument is similar to Example 20.1.3.
Corollary 20.1.6. Let \(\Oo \) be a small \(\infty \)-operad admitting finite operadic limits. The multiplicative Yoneda embedding identifies \(\Oo \) with a full suboperad of \(\Mm _{\PSh (\Env (\Oo ))}\) whose colors are closed under finite limits in \(\PSh (\Env (\Oo ))\).
Proof. An operadic limit in \(\Oo \) becomes a limit in \(\Env (\Oo )\) by Remark 20.1.2. The Yoneda embedding preserves limits, so the multiplicative Yoneda embedding preserves these limits. Full faithfulness follows from Proposition 19.5.3. □
We can now extend pointedness, semiadditivity, additivity, and stability to \(\infty \)-operads.
Definition 20.1.7. An \(\infty \)-operad \(\Oo \) is called:
- (1)
-
Pointed if \(U(\Oo )\) has a zero object which is both operadic initial and operadic terminal.
- (2)
-
Semiadditive if \(U(\Oo )\) is semiadditive and all finite products and coproducts are operadic.
- (3)
-
Additive if \(U(\Oo )\) is additive and all finite products and coproducts are operadic.
- (4)
-
Stable if \(U(\Oo )\) is stable and all finite limits and colimits are operadic.
This allows us to define various subcategories of the \(\infty \)-category \(\Op _{\infty }\) of \(\infty \)-operads:
- We define \(\Op _{\infty }^* \subseteq \Op _{\infty }\) as the (non-full) subcategory spanned by \(\infty \)-operads with an operadic terminal object and maps preserving them. We denote by \(\Op _{\infty }^{\pt } \subseteq \Op _{\infty }^*\) the full subcategory spanned by pointed \(\infty \)-operads.
- We define \(\Op _{\infty }^{\mathrm {prod}} \subseteq \Op _{\infty }\) as the (non-full) subcategory spanned by \(\infty \)-operads with finite operadic products and maps preserving them. We denote by \(\Op _{\infty }^{\sadd }, \Op _{\infty }^{\add } \subseteq \Op _{\infty }^{\mathrm {prod}}\) the full subcategories spanned by semiadditive and additive \(\infty \)-operads, respectively.
- We define \(\Op _{\infty }^{\lex } \subseteq \Op _{\infty }\) as the (non-full) subcategory spanned by \(\infty \)-operads with finite operadic limits and maps preserving them. We denote by \(\Op _{\infty }^{\st } \subseteq \Op _{\infty }^{\lex }\) the full subcategory spanned by stable \(\infty \)-operads.
For example, the \(\infty \)-operad \(\Mm _{\Sp }\) associated with the symmetric monoidal structure constructed in Section 16.6 is stable.
Example 20.1.8 (Pointed objects). Let \(C\) satisfy the hypotheses of Lemma 16.3.4, and equip \(C_*\) with its smash product monoidal structure. Its zero object is both operadic terminal and operadic initial, so \(\Mm _{C_*}\) is a pointed \(\infty \)-operad. Indeed, operadic terminality is automatic by Example 20.1.3, while operadic initiality says that tensoring with the zero object gives the zero object.
Lemma 20.1.9 (Properties inherited by full suboperads). Let \(\Oo \subseteq \Pp \) be a full suboperad.
- (1)
-
If \(\Pp \) is pointed and \(U(\Oo )\) contains its zero object, then \(\Oo \) is pointed.
- (2)
-
If \(\Pp \) is semiadditive or additive and \(U(\Oo )\) is closed under finite biproducts in \(U(\Pp )\), then \(\Oo \) is semiadditive or additive, respectively.
- (3)
-
If \(\Pp \) is stable and \(U(\Oo )\) is closed under finite limits and finite colimits in \(U(\Pp )\), then \(\Oo \) is stable.
Proof. In each case the relevant (co)limits in \(U(\Oo )\) are inherited from \(U(\Pp )\). This gives the asserted property of the underlying \(\infty \)-category. Since \(\Pp \) has the corresponding operadic (co)limits and \(\Oo \subseteq \Pp \) is full, the same multimorphism animae compute the operadic (co)limit conditions in \(\Oo \). □
The inclusions of pointed, semiadditive, additive, and stable \(\infty \)-operads into the respective ambient \(\infty \)-categories above all admit right adjoints. We begin with stabilization.