The notions of algebras and modules make sense in every symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. We first recall some examples of symmetric monoidal structures, and then state the results from Part II that we will use throughout the chapter.

Definition 8.1.1. A symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category is a commutative monoid in \(\Cat _{\infty }\). In particular, it is an \(\infty \)-category \(C\) which comes equipped with a tensor product functor \[ - \otimes - \colon C \times C \to C \] and a monoidal unit \(\unit \in C\), and the tensor product is coherently unital, associative and commutative. We denote this by \((C,\otimes ,\unit )\), or simply \(C\). Given symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-categories \(C\) and \(D\), a symmetric monoidal functor \(F\colon C \to D\) is a morphism in \(\CMon (\Cat _{\infty })\). We write \(\Map ^{\otimes }(C,D)\) for the hom anima in \(\CMon (\Cat _{\infty })\).

Every classical symmetric monoidal category gives an example: a commutative monoid in the full subcategory \(\Cat _1\subseteq \Cat _\infty \) of 1-categories is precisely a symmetric monoidal category, and the inclusion preserves products.

We write \(\Fun ^{\otimes }(C,D)\) for the \(\infty \)-category of symmetric monoidal functors and monoidal natural transformations; its core is \(\Map ^{\otimes }(C,D)\). We will also use the more flexible notion of a lax symmetric monoidal functor \(F\colon C \to D\). Concretely, such a functor is equipped with coherent structure maps \[ \unit _D\longrightarrow F(\unit _C), \qquad F(X)\otimes F(Y)\longrightarrow F(X\otimes Y) \] compatible with the unit, associativity and symmetry. A lax symmetric monoidal functor is symmetric monoidal precisely when these structure maps are isomorphisms. We denote the \(\infty \)-category of lax symmetric monoidal functors by \(\Fun ^{\otimes \text {-lax}}(C,D)\). The formal constructions of these functor categories are given in Definition 14.4.3, Definition 14.5.1.

Example 8.1.2. The following are examples of symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-categories:

(1)

The category \(\Ab \) of abelian groups is symmetric monoidal under the ordinary tensor product, with unit \(\Z \).

(2)

The \(\infty \)-category \(\Sp \) of spectra admits a symmetric monoidal structure \(\otimes \) satisfying the property that for every spectrum \(X\), the functor \(X \otimes -\colon \Sp \to \Sp \) preserves colimits. Furthermore, \(\Sp \) is universal with this structure: if \(D\) is another symmetric monoidal stable \(\infty \)-category which admits colimits and in which the tensor product preserves colimits in both variables, then the \(\infty \)-category of colimit-preserving symmetric monoidal functors \(\Sp \to D\) is contractible. We construct the symmetric monoidal structure in Chapter 16, and discuss its universal property in Section 18.2.

(3)

Let \(R\) be a commutative ring. The derived \(\infty \)-category \(\D (R)\) from Chapter 6 admits a symmetric monoidal structure with unit \(R[0]\) and tensor product given by the derived tensor product of chain complexes. We construct it in Section 21.2.

(4)

An \(\infty \)-category \(C\) with finite products admits the cartesian monoidal structure \((C,\times ,*)\). Dually, finite coproducts give the cocartesian monoidal structure \((C,\amalg ,\emptyset )\). These structures are constructed in Section 15.3, Section 15.2.

(5)

If \(C\) is an \(\infty \)-category and \(D\) is symmetric monoidal, then \(\Fun (C,D)\) admits the pointwise symmetric monoidal structure, with tensor product and unit computed pointwise.

(6)

Let \((C,\otimes ,\unit )\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category and let \(D\subseteq C\) be a full subcategory which contains the monoidal unit and is closed under tensor products. Then \(D\) inherits a symmetric monoidal structure for which the inclusion \(D\hookrightarrow C\) is symmetric monoidal. See Lemma 14.7.1 for the construction.

(7)

Similar to (2), the \(\infty \)-categories \(\An _*\), \(\CMon (\An )\) and \(\CGrp (\An )\) admit universal symmetric monoidal structures for pointed, semiadditive, and additive \(\infty \)-categories. In particular, the functors \[ \An \xrightarrow {(-)_+} \An _* \to \CMon (\An ) \xrightarrow {(-)^{\grp }} \CGrp (\An ) \xhookrightarrow {\bB ^{\infty }} \Sp \] are colimit-preserving and symmetric monoidal; see Proposition 16.6.4.

(8)

For small symmetric monoidal \(C\) and cocomplete symmetric monoidal \(D\) whose tensor product preserves colimits separately in both variables, \(\Fun (C,D)\) also admits the Day convolution structure; see Chapter 16.

Recall from classical algebra that a commutative algebra in a symmetric monoidal category \(C\) is an object \(A\) of \(C\) that comes equipped with a unit \(1\colon \unit \to A\) and a multiplication map \(m\colon A \otimes A \to A\) such that the following diagrams commute:

Commutative diagram involving A tensor unit, A tensor A, unittensor A, A, with arrows labeled simeq, \id A tensor 1, m, 1 tensor \id A.
Commutative square with maps A tensor A tensor A to A tensor A labeled m tensor \id A, A tensor A to A labeled m, A tensor A tensor A to A tensor A labeled \id A tensor m, A tensor A to A labeled m.
Commutative triangle with vertices A tensor A [swap]simeq, A tensor A, A and arrows labeled m, tau.

In a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category, these relations become identifications that must be accompanied by higher coherence data. The following definition encodes all of this data at once:

Definition 8.1.3 (Commutative algebra). Let \((C,\otimes ,\unit )\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. We define a commutative algebra in \(C\) to be a symmetric monoidal functor \[ A \colon \Fin \to C, \] where we equip the category \(\Fin \) of finite sets with the cocartesian monoidal structure. We refer to the object \(A(*)\) in \(C\) as the underlying object of \(A\). We will frequently abuse notation and simply write \(A\) for \(A(*)\).

We define the \(\infty \)-category of commutative algebras in \(C\) as \[ \CAlg (C) \quad := \quad \Fun ^{\otimes }(\Fin ,C). \]

Remark 8.1.4. For the cartesian monoidal structure on an \(\infty \)-category \(C\) with finite products, commutative algebras are precisely commutative monoids: \(\CAlg (C,\times )\simeq \CMon (C)\) by Corollary 15.3.14.

For a finite set \(I\), the unique map \(I\to *\) induces a multiplication map \[ A(*)^{\otimes I}\simeq A(I)\longrightarrow A(*). \] The empty set gives the unit, bijections give symmetry, and composition of maps of finite sets expresses compatibility of iterated multiplication. Functoriality includes the higher coherences between these identifications.

There are analogous coherent notions of associative algebras and of modules. We collect the part of their theory needed in this chapter.

Proposition 8.1.5 (Algebras and modules). Let \(C\) be a cocomplete symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category whose tensor product preserves colimits separately in both variables.

(1)

There are \(\infty \)-categories \(\Alg (C)\) and \(\CAlg (C)\) of associative and commutative algebras in \(C\). Their objects have underlying objects of \(C\) equipped with coherently unital and associative multiplication maps; for commutative algebras the multiplication is coherently commutative as well.

(2)

For every \(A\in \Alg (C)\) there are \(\infty \)-categories \(\LMod _A(C)\) and \(\RMod _A(C)\) of left and right \(A\)-modules. The forgetful functors to \(C\) detect isomorphisms, create every limit admitted by \(C\) and all colimits, and the free left \(A\)-module on \(X\in C\) has underlying object \(A\otimes X\). The forgetful functor \(\LMod _{\unit }(C)\to C\) is an equivalence. If \(C\) is stable, then \(\LMod _A(C)\) and \(\RMod _A(C)\) are stable.

(3)

There is a relative tensor product \[ -\otimes _A-\colon \RMod _A(C)\times \LMod _A(C)\longrightarrow C, \] which preserves colimits separately in both variables. It is unital: for every left \(A\)-module \(M\) and right \(A\)-module \(N\) there are natural isomorphisms \[ A\otimes _A M\iso M, \qquad N\otimes _A A\iso N. \] Commuting actions on the factors induce actions on the relative tensor product. In particular, if \(N\) also has a left \(B\)-action commuting with its right \(A\)-action, then \(N\otimes _A M\) is a left \(B\)-module. Relative tensor products are coherently associative: for a right \(B\)-module \(L\) there is a natural isomorphism \((L\otimes _B N)\otimes _A M\simeq L\otimes _B(N\otimes _A M)\).

(4)

Every morphism \(f\colon A\to B\) in \(\Alg (C)\) induces a restriction functor \[ f_*\colon \LMod _B(C)\longrightarrow \LMod _A(C), \] which admits the extension-of-scalars functor \[ f^*:=B\otimes _A-\colon \LMod _A(C)\longrightarrow \LMod _B(C) \] as a left adjoint. There is an analogous adjunction for right modules, whose left adjoint is \(-\otimes _A B\).

(5)

If \(R\in \CAlg (C)\), then left and right \(R\)-modules agree, and the resulting \(\infty \)-category \(\Mod _R(C)\) is symmetric monoidal under \(-\otimes _R-\). For a morphism \(f\colon R\to S\) in \(\CAlg (C)\), the extension-of-scalars functor \(f^*\colon \Mod _R(C)\to \Mod _S(C)\) is symmetric monoidal; for \(R=\unit \), this is the free module functor \(-\otimes S\colon C\to \Mod _S(C)\). There are natural equivalences \[ \CAlg (\Mod _R(C))\simeq \CAlg (C)_{R/}. \]

(6)

Lax symmetric monoidal functors preserve algebra objects and their modules. In particular, a symmetric monoidal adjunction \(F\colon C\rightleftarrows D\noloc G\) induces adjunctions on algebras and on their module categories. If \(A\in \Alg (C)\) and the unit \(A\to GF(A)\) is an isomorphism, this gives an adjunction \[ \LMod _A(C)\rightleftarrows \LMod _{F(A)}(D) \] whose underlying functors are induced by \(F\) and \(G\). Right adjoints of symmetric monoidal functors are canonically lax symmetric monoidal.

(7)

If \(C\) is presentable, then \(\LMod _A(C)\) and \(\RMod _A(C)\) are presentable for every \(A\in \Alg (C)\).

Proof. Algebras and modules are constructed in Section 17.1, and their limits and colimits are treated in Proposition 17.1.16. For relative tensor products and change of scalars, see Section 17.2, Proposition 17.2.14. The symmetric monoidal structure for a commutative base and its properties are given in Theorem 17.2.16, Corollary 17.2.21, Proposition 17.2.17. Finally, the assertions about adjunctions and presentability are Proposition 14.5.6, Proposition 17.1.17. □

Definition 8.1.6 (Ring spectra and modules). An associative ring spectrum is an associative algebra in \((\Sp ,\otimes ,\S )\), and a commutative ring spectrum is a commutative algebra in \(\Sp \). Every algebra \(A\) is canonically a left and right module over itself via its multiplication \(A\otimes A\to A\); this is called the regular \(A\)-module. We write \[ \Alg :=\Alg (\Sp ), \qquad \CAlg :=\CAlg (\Sp ) \] for their \(\infty \)-categories. For an associative ring spectrum \(R\), we abbreviate \[ \LMod _R:=\LMod _R(\Sp ), \qquad \RMod _R:=\RMod _R(\Sp ). \] If \(R\) is commutative, we write \(\Mod _R:=\Mod _R(\Sp )\) for its symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category of modules.

Unless commutativity is specified, a ring spectrum will mean an associative ring spectrum.

Example 8.1.7. The sphere spectrum \(\S \) is a commutative ring spectrum, and \(\Mod _{\S }\simeq \Sp \). Every ordinary ring \(A\) gives an associative ring spectrum, again denoted by \(A\), which is commutative if \(A\) is commutative. We construct these Eilenberg–MacLane ring spectra in Section 8.2.

For every associative ring spectrum \(R\), the \(\infty \)-category \(\LMod _R\) is stable. When \(R\) is commutative, \(\Mod _R\) also has a symmetric monoidal structure given by the relative tensor product over \(R\).

Observation 8.1.8 (Graded homotopy rings). The homotopy groups of an associative ring spectrum \(R\) form a graded ring. For \(x\in \pi _p(R)\) and \(y\in \pi _q(R)\), the product \(xy\in \pi _{p+q}(R)\) is represented by \[ \S [p+q]\simeq \S [p]\otimes \S [q] \xrightarrow {x\otimes y}R\otimes R\xrightarrow {m}R. \] The same construction using the action map \(R\otimes M\to M\) makes \(\pi _*(M)\) a graded left \(\pi _*(R)\)-module for every left \(R\)-module \(M\), and similarly for right modules.

If \(R\) is commutative, then \(\pi _*(R)\) is graded-commutative: \[ xy=(-1)^{pq}yx. \] Indeed, interchanging \(\S [p]\) and \(\S [q]\) acts by \((-1)^{pq}\) on \(\S [p+q]\). For nonnegative \(p,q\), this is the degree of the permutation interchanging the two blocks of suspension coordinates; the general case follows by invertibility of suspension. See also Warning 4.2.11, Observation 16.6.7.

Construction 8.1.9 (Cup products). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and \(X\) an anima. The diagonal of \(X\) induces a map \[ \Delta \colon \S [X]\longrightarrow \S [X\times X]\simeq \S [X]\otimes \S [X]. \] For cohomology classes \(x\in R^p(X)\) and \(y\in R^q(X)\) represented by maps \(x\colon \S [X]\to R[p]\) and \(y\colon \S [X]\to R[q]\), the cup product \(x\smile y\in R^{p+q}(X)\) is represented by \[ \begin {aligned} \S [X]&\xrightarrow {\Delta }\S [X]\otimes \S [X] \xrightarrow {x\otimes y}R[p]\otimes R[q]\simeq (R\otimes R)[p+q]\xrightarrow {m[p+q]}R[p+q]. \end {aligned} \] This gives \(R^*(X)\) the structure of a graded ring, natural in \(X\), with unit represented by \(\S [X]\to \S \to R\). Associativity follows from associativity of \(m\) and coassociativity of the diagonal. If \(R\) is commutative, the same symmetry calculation as above gives \(x\smile y=(-1)^{pq}y\smile x\). For a topological space, we apply the construction to its underlying anima.

The regular module generates an important finiteness class.

Definition 8.1.10 (Perfect module). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum. We denote by \[ \Perf (R) \quad \subseteq \quad \LMod _R \] the smallest thick subcategory containing the regular left \(R\)-module \(R\), where a full subcategory is called thick if it is stable and closed under retracts. A left \(R\)-module is called perfect if it belongs to \(\Perf (R)\).

Thus a perfect module is obtained from finitely many shifts of \(R\) by iterating finite cofiber sequences and retracts. The compact-generation results from Chapter 23 identify this intrinsic finite construction with compactness.

Lemma 8.1.11 (Perfect modules and compact objects, [Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.2.4.2]). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum.

(1)

The regular left \(R\)-module \(R\) is compact.

(2)

The \(\infty \)-category \(\LMod _R\) is compactly generated by \(R\).

(3)

A left \(R\)-module is perfect if and only if it is compact.

Proof. The functor \(\Hom _{\LMod _R}(R,-)\) is naturally isomorphic to the composite \[ \LMod _R \xrightarrow {\fgt } \Sp \xrightarrow {\Omega ^\infty } \An , \] which preserves filtered colimits. Thus \(R\) is compact. Its shifts jointly detect isomorphisms, since \[ \pi _n(M) \cong \pi _0\Hom _{\LMod _R}(R[n],M). \] Hence \(R\) is a compact generator of \(\LMod _R\). The characterization of compact objects in a compactly generated stable \(\infty \)-category from Proposition 23.3.4 now identifies the compact objects with the thick subcategory generated by \(R\), which is \(\Perf (R)\). □