Let \(R\in \CAlg (\Sp )\) be a commutative ring spectrum. A virtual vector bundle \(V\) of rank \(d\) on an anima \(A\) determines a family of \(R\)-modules \(\xi _V[-d]\otimes R\), each isomorphic to \(R\). An \(R\)-orientation is a trivialization of this family. Taking colimits will give the Thom isomorphism. We follow Ando et al. (2014), Section 2.6; for the classical account, see May (1999a), Chapter 23, Section 5.

Definition 10.4.1 (\(R\)-lines). We denote by \[ \Line _R \subseteq \Mod _R^{\simeq } \] the full subanima spanned by those \(R\)-modules that are isomorphic to \(R\). Its objects are called \(R\)-lines.

Remark 10.4.2. The group \(\Aut _R(R)\) of \(R\)-linear automorphisms of \(R\) is also denoted by \(\GL _1(R)\). The pointed connected anima \(\Line _R\) is its classifying anima: \(\Line _R \simeq \bB \Aut _R(R)\).

Example 10.4.3. For an ordinary commutative ring \(k\), the group \(\Aut _{Hk}(Hk)\) is the discrete group \(k^\times \). In particular, \[ \Line _{\F _2} \simeq * \qquadtext {and} \Line _{\Z } \simeq \bB C_2. \]

Definition 10.4.4 (Local systems and trivializations). A local system of \(R\)-lines on an anima \(A\) is a functor \(\xi \colon A \to \Line _R\). A trivialization of \(\xi \) is an isomorphism \(\xi \cong R_A\), where \(R_A\) is the constant functor with value \(R\).

Definition 10.4.5 (Orientation). Let \(V\) be a virtual vector bundle of rank \(d\) on an anima \(A\). Its associated local system of \(R\)-lines is \[ \xi _{V,R}\colon A \xrightarrow {\;\xi _V[-d]\;} \Line _{\S } \xrightarrow {-\otimes R} \Line _R. \] Here \(\xi _V[-d]\) lands in the virtual-rank-zero component \(\Line _{\S }\subseteq \Pic (\Sp )\). An \(R\)-orientation of \(V\) is a trivialization \(\xi _{V,R} \cong R_A\).

Theorem 10.4.6 (Thom isomorphism). Let \(V\) be an \(R\)-oriented virtual vector bundle of rank \(d\) on an anima \(A\). Then there is an isomorphism of \(R\)-modules \[ \th (V)\otimes R \cong (\S [A]\otimes R)[d], \] and an isomorphism of spectra \[ \hom (\th (V),R)\cong \hom (\S [A][d],R). \]

Proof. Write \(R[A]:=\S [A]\otimes R\). Passing to colimits in the chosen trivialization \(\xi _{V,R}\cong R_A\) gives \[ \th (V)[-d]\otimes R \cong \colim _A\xi _{V,R} \cong \colim _A R_A \cong R[A], \] which proves the first isomorphism. The second follows by applying \(\hom _R(-,R)\) and using the free-forgetful adjunction between spectra and \(R\)-modules. □

An \(R\)-orientation of \(V\) induces a morphism of \(R\)-modules \[ \th (V)[-d]\otimes R \cong \colim _A\xi _{V,R} \cong R[A] \longrightarrow R, \] where the last map is the augmentation. By adjunction, this corresponds to a map \[ u_V\colon \th (V)\longrightarrow R[d], \] whose homotopy class is called the Thom class of the oriented virtual bundle \(V\).

For vector bundles, we now relate \(R\)-orientations to the classical notion of a Thom class. Let \(E\to X\) be a rank \(n\) vector bundle over a paracompact Hausdorff space of the homotopy type of a cell complex. By Lemma 10.2.22, we have \[ \th ([E])\cong \Sigma ^\infty \Pi _\infty \Th (E). \] Thus a map \(u\colon \th ([E])\to R[n]\) determines a class in \(\widetilde R^n(\Th (E))\), whose restriction to each fiber lies in the free rank-one \(\pi _0(R)\)-module \(\widetilde R^n(S^{E_x})\).

Proposition 10.4.7. Sending an \(R\)-orientation to its associated map \(u_{[E]}\) identifies the anima of \(R\)-orientations of \([E]\) with the full subanima of \[ \Hom _{\Sp }(\th ([E]),R[n]) \] spanned by maps whose restrictions to the fibers represent generators. In particular, homotopy classes of \(R\)-orientations correspond bijectively to classes \(\theta \in \widetilde R^n(\Th (E))\) whose restrictions to the fibers are generators.

Proof. The free-forgetful adjunction and the universal property of the colimit give isomorphisms of animae \[ \begin {aligned} \Hom _{\Sp }(\th ([E]),R[n]) &\cong \Hom _{\Mod _R}(\th ([E])[-n]\otimes R,R)\\ &\cong \Hom _{\Fun (\Pi _\infty (X),\Mod _R)}(\xi _{[E],R},R_{\Pi _\infty (X)}). \end {aligned} \] A natural transformation on the right is an isomorphism precisely when each of its components is an isomorphism. After choosing coordinates on \(E_x\), the homotopy class of the component at \(x\) is multiplication by an element of \(\pi _0(R)\); it is invertible precisely when that element is a unit, or equivalently when the restriction generates \(\widetilde R^n(S^{E_x})\). Restricting to these components therefore gives the anima of trivializations of \(\xi _{[E],R}\). The inverse sends a trivialization to its colimit followed by the augmentation, which is the construction of the Thom class above. □

Corollary 10.4.8 (Classical Thom isomorphism). Let \(E\to X\) be a rank \(n\) vector bundle over a paracompact Hausdorff space of the homotopy type of a cell complex, equipped with an \(R\)-Thom class \(\theta \). Then \[ \widetilde R_m(\Th (E))\cong R_{m-n}(X) \qquadtext {and} \widetilde R^m(\Th (E))\cong R^{m-n}(X). \] The inverse of the cohomological isomorphism is the Thom homomorphism \(x\mapsto x\smile \theta \).

Proof. To get the two isomorphisms, apply Theorem 10.4.6 to \(V=[E]\) and use Proposition 10.4.7, Lemma 10.2.22. To identify the cohomological map, consider the Thom diagonal \[ \Delta _E\colon \Th (E)\longrightarrow X_+\wedge \Th (E), \qquad [v]\longmapsto \big (p(v),[v]\big ). \] It sends the basepoint to the basepoint. We also write \(\Delta _E\colon \th ([E])\to \S [X]\otimes \th ([E])\) for the induced map of spectra. If \(u\colon \th ([E])\to R[n]\) represents \(\theta \), the composite \[ \th ([E])\xrightarrow {\Delta _E}\S [X]\otimes \th ([E]) \xrightarrow {\id \otimes u}\S [X]\otimes R[n] \] extends \(R\)-linearly to the Thom isomorphism \(\th ([E])\otimes R\cong R[X][n]\). Indeed, on the sphere over \(a\in X\), the diagonal records \(a\), while \(u\) gives the fiberwise orientation. The \(R\)-linear extension is therefore the chosen trivialization followed by the inclusion of \(R[n]\) at \(a\) into \(R[X][n]\). These maps form the cocone obtained from the orientation, so the assertion follows by taking colimits. Consequently, for \(x\in R^{m-n}(X)\) the inverse cohomological isomorphism is represented by \[ \th ([E])\xrightarrow {\Delta _E}\S [X]\otimes \th ([E]) \xrightarrow {x\otimes u}R[m-n]\otimes R[n] \xrightarrow {\mu }R[m]. \] This is, by definition, the cup product \(x\smile \theta \) formed with the Thom diagonal. □

Lemma 10.4.9 (Orientations of inverse virtual bundles). Let \(V\) be a virtual vector bundle of fixed rank on \(A\). An \(R\)-orientation of \(V\) canonically induces an \(R\)-orientation of \(-V\).

Proof. Since \(\xi _{-V}\cong \xi _V^{-1}\) by Remark 10.2.19 and \(\rk (-V)=-\rk (V)\), there is an isomorphism \(\xi _{-V,R}\cong \xi _{V,R}^{-1}\). Inverting a trivialization of \(\xi _{V,R}\) gives the required trivialization. □

Example 10.4.10. Since \(\Line _{\F _2}\) is contractible, every virtual vector bundle of fixed rank has a unique \(\F _2\)-orientation. For \(R=\Z \) and a rank \(n\) real vector bundle \(E\to X\) over a paracompact Hausdorff space of cell-complex homotopy type, the local system \(\xi _{[E],\Z }\) is classified by \[ \Pi _\infty (X) \longrightarrow \bB O(n) \xrightarrow {\bB \det } \bB C_2. \] Indeed, an orthogonal transformation acts on the top integral cohomology of its one-point compactification by its determinant. Thus \(\xi _{[E],\Z }\) is the classical orientation local system, and an \(\Z \)-orientation is a classical orientation. It exists precisely when \(E\) is orientable, that is, when the displayed composite \(\Pi _\infty (X)\to \bB C_2\) is nullhomotopic. Classically, this is the vanishing of the first Stiefel–Whitney class \(w_1(E)\).

Example 10.4.11 (The universal \(\MO \)-orientation). The universal rank-zero virtual bundle on \(\bB O\) is canonically \(\MO \)-oriented. For a point \(W\in \bB O\), i.e. a virtual vector space of rank 0, let \(j_W\colon J(W)\to \MO \) be the colimit map. Multiplication on \(\MO \) gives an \(\MO \)-linear map \[ J(W)\otimes \MO \xrightarrow {j_W\otimes \id }\MO \otimes \MO \xrightarrow {\mu }\MO . \] By Construction 10.2.10, its underlying map of spectra is \[ J(W)\otimes \MO \cong \colim _{V\in \bB O}J(W+V) \cong \MO . \] The second map is an isomorphism because translation \(W+(-)\colon \bB O\to \bB O\) is an isomorphism of animae. The colimit cocone makes these \(\MO \)-linear isomorphisms natural in \(W\), so they trivialize the associated local system of \(\MO \)-lines. Pulling back along the classifying map of \([E]-[\ul {\R ^n}]\) gives a canonical \(\MO \)-orientation of a rank \(n\) real vector bundle \(E\).

Remark 10.4.12 (The mod \(2\) homology of \(\MO \)). The universal rank-zero virtual bundle on \(\bB O\) has a unique \(\F _2\)-orientation. The Thom isomorphism gives \[ \F _2 \otimes \MO \; \cong \; \F _2[\bB O] \] of \(\F _2\)-modules, and hence \[ H_*(\MO ;\F _2)\cong H_*(\bB O;\F _2). \] The mod \(2\) cohomology of \(\bB O\) is the polynomial algebra \(\F _2[w_1,w_2,\ldots ]\) on the Stiefel–Whitney classes. The Thom isomorphism is a first step towards the calculation of \(\pi _*(\MO )\) in Remark 10.3.9; the splitting of \(\MO \) into shifts of \(\F _2\) and the coefficient-ring multiplication require further input.