Proposition 16.2.11. Let \(A\) be a weakly contractible small category. The following conditions are equivalent.

  • (i) The category \(A\) is sifted.

  • (ii) For any object \(x : A^\simeq\), the projection \[ A_{x/}\to A \] is a terminal functor.

  • (iii) The diagonal functor \(\Delta\colon A\to A\times A\) is a terminal functor.

  • (iv) For any functors \(X,Y\colon A\to\An\), the canonical map \[ \underset{a : A}{\colim \ } X_a\times Y_a\iso \underset{a : A}{\colim \ } X_a\times \underset{a : A}{\colim \ } Y_a \] is an equivalence.

  • (v) For any objects \(x,y,z : A^\simeq\), the category \(A_{x/}\times_A A_{y/}\times_A A_{z/}\) is weakly contractible.

  • (vi) For any objects \(x,y : A^\simeq\), the projection \[ A_{x/}\times_A A_{y/}\to A \] is a terminal functor.

Proof

Quillen’s Theorem A (more precisely, the dual version of Corollary 9.5.8) implies that conditions (i) and (ii) are equivalent. Similarly, it shows that conditions (v) and (vi) are equivalent.

Given any object \((x,y)\) in \(A\times A\) we have \[ A\times_{A\times A} (A\times A)_{(x,y)/}=A_{x/}\times_A A_{y/} \, . \] Quillen’s Theorem A thus proves that conditions (i) and (iii) are equivalent.

Since \(A\) is weakly contractible, it is clear that condition (i) follows from condition (vi).

By Theorem 13.1.4 for \(C=\An\catop\), we see that condition (iii) implies that, for any functors \(X,Y\colon A\to\An\), we have: \[ \underset{a : A}{\colim \ } X_a\times Y_a\iso \underset{(a,b) : A\times A}{\colim \ } X_a\times Y_b\, . \] There is furthermore a canonical equivalence \[ \underset{(a,b) : A\times A}{\colim \ } F(a,b)\iso \underset{a : A}{\colim \ }\underset{b : A}{\colim \ }F(a,b) \] for any functor \(F\colon A\times A\to\An\). Since the functor \(T\times(-)\) commutes with small colimits in \(\An\) for any small anima \(T\), we also have \[ \underset{a : A}{\colim \ }\underset{b : A}{\colim \ } X_a\times Y_b\iso \underset{a : A}{\colim \ } X_a\times \underset{b : A}{\colim \ }Y_b\, . \] Putting all this together shows that condition (iv) follows from condition (iii).

It suffices now to prove that condition (iv) implies condition (v).

Condition (iv) means that the functor \[ \colim_A\colon\Fun(A,\An)\to\An \] commutes with binary cartesian products. This implies that it commutes with ternary cartesian products. For \(x,y,z : A^\simeq\), we have \[ \underset{a : A}{\colim \ }\Hom_A(x,a)\times\Hom_A(y,a)\times\Hom_A(z,a) =\Pi_\infty(A_{x/}\times_A A_{y/}\times_A A_{z/})\, . \] We also have \[ \underset{a : A}{\colim \ }\Hom_A(t,a)=\Pi_\infty(A_{t/})=* \] for any \(t : A^\simeq\). Therefore, \[ \underset{a : A}{\colim \ }\Hom_A(x,a)\times \underset{a : A}{\colim \ }\Hom_A(y,a)\times \underset{a : A}{\colim \ }\Hom_A(z,a)=* \] and thus condition (iv) implies that \(A_{x/}\times_A A_{y/}\times_A A_{z/}\) is weakly contractible.

From Section 16.2, Filtered categories.