Proposition 5.28 (Efimov [Efimov (2024), Proposition 6.3]). In the above situation, let \(\Psi \colon B \to \Pro (\Ind (A))\) be the functor corresponding to \(\Phi = G^{RR} \circ F\). Then the following are equivalent:
- (1)
-
\(D\) is dualizable;
- (2)
-
\(D\) is compactly generated;
- (3)
-
The essential image of \(\Psi \) is contained in \(\mathrm {Tate}(A)\).
Proof.
We first show that \(D\) is compactly generated if and only if for every \(b \in B\) there is a compact object \(d \in D^{\omega }\) with \(G(d) \simeq b \oplus \Sigma b\). If \(D\) is compactly generated, this follows from Theorem 2.17(2) and Remark 2.9. Conversely, suppose such lifts \(d_b\) exist. Since \(F\) is strongly continuous, the objects \(F(a)\), \(a \in A\), are compact, and we claim that together with the \(d_b\) they generate \(D\). Indeed, if \(x \in D\) is right orthogonal to all of them, then \(F^R(x) = 0\), so \(x \simeq G^RG(x)\), and \(0 \simeq \hom _D(d_b, G^RG(x)) \simeq \hom _{\Ind (B)}(b \oplus \Sigma b, G(x))\) for all \(b\), so \(G(x) = 0\) and hence \(x = 0\).
(1) \(\Rightarrow \) (2): If \(D\) is dualizable, then the required lifts exist by [Efimov (2024), Proposition 2.10] (which reduces to the compactly generated case by embedding \(D\) strongly continuously into a compactly generated category). (2) \(\Rightarrow \) (1) is clear.
(2) \(\Leftrightarrow \) (3): Let \(d \in D\), and put \(z := G(d)\) and \(w := F^R(d)\), so that we have a fiber sequence \(F(w) \to d \to G^R(z)\). Applying \(\hom _D(-,F(w'))\) for \(w' \in \Ind (A)\) and using \(\hom _D(G^R(z),F(w')) \simeq \hom _{\Ind (B)}(z,\Phi (w'))\), we obtain a fiber sequence of functors \(\Ind (A) \to \Sp \) \[ \hom _{\Ind (B)}(z,\Phi (-)) \to \hom _D(d,F(-)) \to \hom _{\Ind (A)}(w,-). \] Every filtered colimit in \(D\) is an extension of a filtered colimit in \(F(\Ind (A))\) by one in \(G^R(\Ind (B))\), as \(F^R\) and \(G\) preserve colimits. Since \(\hom _D(d,G^R(-)) \simeq \hom _{\Ind (B)}(z,-)\), it follows that \(d\) is compact if and only if \(z\) is compact and \(\hom _D(d,F(-))\) preserves filtered colimits. Now identify exact accessible functors \(\Ind (A) \to \Sp \) with \(\Pro (\Ind (A))\catop \); under this identification, the functors preserving filtered colimits correspond to \(\Pro (A)\). The first term of the fiber sequence corresponds to \(\Psi (z)\) by definition, and the last one to \(w \in \Ind (A)\). So \(d\) is compact if and only if \(z \in B\) and there is a cofiber sequence \(u \to \Psi (z) \to \Sigma w\) in \(\Pro (\Ind (A))\) with \(u \in \Pro (A)\). Conversely, given \(z \in B\) and a cofiber sequence \(u \to \Psi (z) \to v\) with \(u \in \Pro (A)\) and \(v \in \Ind (A)\), the map \(\Psi (z) \to v\) corresponds to a map \(z \to \Phi (v)\), i.e. to a map \(G^R(z) \to F(v)\), and its fiber \(d\) is a compact object with \(G(d) \simeq z\) by the same computation. Using Hennion’s theorem, we conclude that \(z \in B\) lifts to \(D^{\omega }\) if and only if \(\Psi (z) \in \mathrm {Tate}^{\mathrm {el}}(A)\).
Combining this with the first paragraph, \(D\) is compactly generated if and only if \(\Psi (b) \oplus \Sigma \Psi (b) \in \mathrm {Tate}^{\mathrm {el}}(A)\) for all \(b \in B\). This implies \(\Psi (b) \in \mathrm {Tate}(A)\). Conversely, if \(\Psi (b) \in \mathrm {Tate}(A)\), then \(\Psi (b) \oplus \Sigma \Psi (b) \in \mathrm {Tate}^{\mathrm {el}}(A)\) by Thomason’s classification of dense subcategories, as in Remark 2.9. □