Proposition 16.5.5 (Excisiveness criterion). Let \(C\) be a pointed \(\infty \)-category with finite colimits and let \(D\) be a pointed \(\infty \)-category with finite limits. A reduced functor \(F\colon C \to D\) is excisive if and only if the map \(\eta _X\colon F(X) \to \Omega _DF(\Sigma _CX)\) is an isomorphism for every object \(X \in C\).

Proof. If \(F\) is excisive, it sends the pushout square defining \(\Sigma _CX\) to a pullback square, so the canonical map \[ \eta _X\colon F(X)\longrightarrow \Omega _DF(\Sigma _CX) \] is an isomorphism.

Conversely, suppose these maps are isomorphisms. Consider a pushout square

Commutative square with maps Z to X, Y to W, Z to Y, X to W.

We must show that its comparison map \[ \alpha \colon F(Z)\longrightarrow P:=F(X)\times _{F(W)}F(Y) \] is an isomorphism. Put \(A:=X\sqcup _Z 0\) and \(B:=0\sqcup _Z Y\), and extend the square by pushouts to the diagram

Commutative diagram involving Z, X, 0, Y, W, B, A, \Sigma C Z, \Sigma C Y, \Sigma C X, and further objects.

Applying \(F\), the map \(W\to \Sigma _C Z\) and its specified nullhomotopies on \(X\) and \(Y\) induce a map \[ \beta \colon P\longrightarrow \Omega _DF(\Sigma _C Z). \] The outer suspension square of \(Z\) identifies \(\beta \alpha \) with \(\eta _Z\).

The suspension rectangles of \(Z,X,Y,W\) form a coherent square of squares. After applying \(F\) and replacing \(F(Z)\) by its pullback cone \(P\), they give a square of arrows with vertices \(\beta ,\eta _X,\eta _Y,\eta _W\). Taking the pullback of the last three arrows therefore identifies the composite \[ P\xrightarrow {\beta }\Omega _DF(\Sigma _C Z) \longrightarrow \Omega _DF(\Sigma _C X)\times _{\Omega _DF(\Sigma _C W)}\Omega _DF(\Sigma _C Y) \] with the map induced by \(\eta _X,\eta _W,\eta _Y\). This composite is an isomorphism, since all three maps are isomorphisms. Since \(\beta \alpha =\eta _Z\) is also an isomorphism, two-out-of-six shows that \(\alpha \) is an isomorphism. Thus \(F\) is excisive. β–‘