Proposition 16.5.12 (Excisive approximation). Let \(C\) be an \(\infty \)-category that admits finite limits, finite colimits, and sequential colimits, and assume that the loop functor \(\Omega \colon C_*\to C_*\) preserves sequential colimits. Then the two inclusions \[ \Sp ^{\exc }(C)=\Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \hookrightarrow \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \qquadtext { and } \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \hookrightarrow \Fun (\An _*^{\fin },C) \] admit left adjoints \[ P_1\colon \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \to \Exc _*(\An _*^{\fin },C) \qquadtext { and } (-)^{\mathrm {red}}\colon \Fun (\An _*^{\fin },C) \to \Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C). \]

Proof. For the reduction functor, let \(F\colon \An _*^{\fin }\to C\) be arbitrary. Since \(*\) is initial in \(\An _*^{\fin }\), the unique natural transformation \(\const _*\to \id \) induces \(\const _{F(*)}\to F\). Define \[ F^{\mathrm {red}}(X):=*\sqcup _{F(*)}F(X). \] This is reduced. If \(G\) is reduced, every natural transformation \(F\to G\) vanishes on \(F(*)\), and hence factors uniquely through \(F\to F^{\mathrm {red}}\). Thus \((-)^{\mathrm {red}}\) is left adjoint to the inclusion of reduced functors.

For \(P_1\), we may replace \(C\) by \(C_*\), which inherits finite and sequential colimits from \(C\), so assume \(C\) is pointed. Write \[ T(F):=\Omega F\Sigma \] for the endofunctor of \(\Fun _*(\An _*^{\fin },C)\), equipped with the natural transformation \(\eta \colon \id \to T\) from Construction 16.5.4. Apply the final composite identity in the proof of Proposition 16.5.5 to the suspension square of \(X\). In the notation of that proof, \(P=T(F)(X)\) and \(\beta \) is the identity, so it gives a natural identification \[ T(\eta _F)\simeq \eta _{T(F)}. \]

Now let \(F\colon \An _*^{\fin }\to C\) be reduced. Iterate \(\eta \) to form \[ F \xrightarrow {\eta _F} T(F) \xrightarrow {\eta _{T(F)}} T^2(F) \longrightarrow \cdots \] and define \[ P_1(F):=\colim _{n\geq 0}T^n(F). \] Thus \(T^n(F)\simeq \Omega ^nF\Sigma ^n\), with the transition maps given by \(\eta _{T^n(F)}\).

The functor \(T\) preserves sequential colimits by assumption. Consequently, \[ T(P_1(F))\simeq \colim _{n\geq 0}T^{n+1}(F), \] and under this isomorphism \(\eta _{P_1(F)}\) is the map from the defining telescope to its tail. The shift \(n\mapsto n+1\) is cofinal, so this map is an isomorphism. The excisiveness criterion now shows that \(P_1(F)\) is excisive.

It remains to verify the universal property. The coherence \(T(\eta _G)\simeq \eta _{T(G)}\) identifies the sequential diagram defining \(P_1(T(G))\) with the tail of the diagram defining \(P_1(G)\), compatibly with \[ P_1(\eta _G)\colon P_1(G)\longrightarrow P_1(T(G)). \] Thus \(P_1(\eta _G)\) corresponds to the cofinal tail map and is an isomorphism. Moreover, \(P_1\) preserves sequential colimits, since \(T\) does.

Let \(u_F\colon F\to P_1(F)\) be the map into the telescope. Since \(P_1\) preserves sequential colimits, the map \[ P_1(u_F)\colon P_1(F)\longrightarrow P_1(P_1(F)) \] is the sequential colimit of the maps \(P_1(F)\to P_1(T^n(F))\). Each of these is a composite of the isomorphisms \(P_1(\eta _{T^k(F)})\), so \(P_1(u_F)\) is an isomorphism. If \(G\) is already excisive, the excisiveness criterion shows that every map in the defining telescope for \(P_1(G)\) is an isomorphism, so \(u_G\colon G\to P_1(G)\) is an isomorphism. In particular, \(u_{P_1(F)}\) is an isomorphism. By Proposition 22.7.9, the functor \(P_1\) is left adjoint to the inclusion of reduced excisive functors. β–‘