So far, we have been treating \(\infty \)-category theory very axiomatically, focusing on the essential features of the theory itself and ignoring how precisely one might model these objects within traditional set-based mathematics. In this section, we briefly discuss the most common traditional model for \(\infty \)-categories, namely quasicategories. Along the way, we will also introduce some simplicial constructions and notation that will be used later independently of quasicategories themselves. Readers who are only interested in the axiomatic development may therefore treat the specifically quasicategorical parts of this section as optional.
Before we start, some words on history are in order. Quasicategories have played an important role in making \(\infty \)-category theory into a practical and usable tool for mathematics. Their defining condition already appeared in the work of Boardman and Vogt [Boardman and Vogt (1973), Definition 4.8], who called it the ‘restricted Kan condition’. Through deep insights and foundational work by André Joyal [Joyal (2008)] and subsequently Jacob Lurie [Lurie (2009b); Lurie (2017)], the quasicategorical approach developed into a powerful framework for higher category theory and its applications.
We begin with some simplicial preliminaries that will be useful later in any case.
Definition 1.6.1. The simplex category \(\simp \) is the 1-category of non-empty finite linearly ordered sets and order-preserving maps between them.
Observe that any object in \(\simp \) is isomorphic to the linear order \([n] = \{0 \leq 1 \leq \dots \leq n\}\) for some \(n\), and that the isomorphism is unique if it exists. We will therefore frequently denote generic objects of \(\simp \) simply by \([n]\).
Observation 1.6.2. Every morphism in \(\simp \) can be written as a finite composite of face maps \(d_i\colon [n-1] \to [n]\) and degeneracy maps \(s_i\colon [n+1] \to [n]\) (see Notation 1.2.11). The relations these maps satisfy are known as the simplicial identities.
Definition 1.6.3. Let \(C\) be an \(\infty \)-category. A simplicial object in \(C\) is defined to be a functor \(\simp \catop \to C\). We will denote the \(\infty \)-category of simplicial objects by \[ \s C := \Fun (\simp \catop ,C). \]
In light of Observation 1.6.2, we may informally think of a simplicial object in \(C\) as a collection of objects \(X_n\) of \(C\) for every natural number \(n\) together with face maps \(d_i\colon X_n \to X_{n-1}\) and degeneracy maps \(s_i\colon X_n \to X_{n+1}\) satisfying the simplicial identities. We frequently draw simplicial objects as follows:
Since this looks somewhat chaotic, it is common to leave the degeneracy maps implicit and only draw the face maps:
We will now specialize to \(C = \Set \). For a simplicial set \(X \in \sSet \), we refer to the set \(X_n\) as its set of \(n\)-simplices.
Definition 1.6.4 (Simplices). For every natural number \(n\), we define the \(n\)-simplex \(\Delta ^n\) as the simplicial set represented by \([n]\): \[ \Delta ^n := \Hom _{\simp }(-, [n]) \colon \simp \catop \to \Set . \] By the Yoneda lemma this defines a fully faithful functor \[ \Delta ^{\bullet }\colon \simp \hookrightarrow \sSet . \] Again by the Yoneda lemma there is a natural bijection \(X_n \cong \Hom _{\sSet }(\Delta ^n, X)\), so that we may think of an \(n\)-simplex in \(X\) as a morphism \(\sigma \colon \Delta ^n \to X\) of simplicial sets.
Definition 1.6.5 (Horns). For \(n \geq 1\) and \(0 \leq k \leq n\), we define the \(k\)-horn \(\Lambda ^n_k\) as the subsimplicial set \[ \Lambda ^n_k \subseteq \Delta ^n \] whose \(m\)-simplices are those maps \(\phi \colon [m] \to [n]\) in \(\simp \) such that there is some element \(i \in [n] \setminus \{k\}\) which is not in the image of \(\phi \). Equivalently, it is the union inside \(\Delta ^n\) of all of its faces except for the \(k\)-th face.
Example 1.6.6. For \(n = 2\) the three horns \(\Lambda ^2_0\), \(\Lambda ^2_1\) and \(\Lambda ^2_2\) may be displayed as follows:
Definition 1.6.7. Let \(X\) be a simplicial set.
- (1)
-
We say that \(X\) is a Kan complex if for every \(n \geq 1\) and \(0 \leq k \leq n\), every morphism of simplicial sets \(\Lambda ^n_k \to X\) extends to a morphism \(\Delta ^n \to X\):
- (2)
-
We say that \(X\) is a quasicategory if the above condition holds for all \(n \geq 1\) but only for \(0 < k < n\).
We denote by \[ \Kan \quad \subseteq \quad \qCat \quad \subseteq \quad \sSet \] the full subcategories on the Kan complexes and the quasicategories, respectively.
We now discuss three basic sources of quasicategories, of which the first two will be most relevant for us:
Example 1.6.8 (Singular simplicial complex). Let \(X\) be a topological space. We will construct a simplicial set \(\Sing (X) \in \sSet \) called the singular simplicial complex of \(X\).
- For every \(n \geq 0\), let \(\abs {\Delta ^n}\) denote the topological \(n\)-simplex: \[ \abs {\Delta ^n} := \{ (x_0, \dots , x_n)\in \R ^{n+1} \mid x_{0} + \dots + x_n=1, \,\, x_{i}\geq 0{\text { for }}i=0,\dots ,n\}. \]
- For every order-preserving map \(\phi \colon [n] \to [m]\) we get a continuous map \[ \abs {\Delta ^{\phi }}\colon \abs {\Delta ^n} \to \abs {\Delta ^m}, \quad (x_0, \dots , x_n) \mapsto (y_0, \dots , y_m), \qquad y_i := \sum _{j \in \phi ^{-1}(i)} x_j. \] This defines a functor \[ \abs {\Delta ^{\bullet }} \colon \simp \to \Top , \qquad [n] \mapsto \abs {\Delta ^n}, \qquad \phi \mapsto \abs {\Delta ^{\phi }}. \]
- We now define the simplicial set \(\Sing (X)\) as \[ \Sing (X)_n := \Hom _{\Top }(\abs {\Delta ^n}, X), \] i.e. it is the composite \(\simp \catop \xrightarrow {\abs {\Delta ^{\bullet }}} \Top \catop \xrightarrow {\Hom _{\Top }(-,X)} \Set \).
The simplicial set \(\Sing (X)\) is a familiar object from algebraic topology, and is used for example in the definition of the singular (co)homology of \(X\). It is not difficult to see that \(\Sing (X)\) is functorial in \(X\), so that it defines a functor \[ \Sing \colon \Top \to \sSet . \]
Definition 1.6.9 (Geometric realization). Let \(K\colon \simp \catop \to \Set \) be a simplicial set. Its geometric realization is the quotient space \[ \abs {K}:=\left (\bigsqcup _{n\geq 0}K_n\times \abs {\Delta ^n}\right )/\sim , \] where each set \(K_n\) carries the discrete topology and the equivalence relation is generated by \[ (\phi ^*(x),y)\sim (x,\abs {\Delta ^\phi }(y)), \] for all maps \(\phi \colon [n]\to [m]\) in \(\simp \), elements \(x\in K_m\), and points \(y\in \abs {\Delta ^n}\). This construction defines a functor \[ \abs {-}\colon \sSet \to \Top \] which is left adjoint to the singular complex functor \(\Sing \colon \Top \to \sSet \).
Exercise 1.6.10. Show that the singular simplicial complex \(\Sing (X)\) of a topological space \(X\) is a Kan complex.
Example 1.6.11 (Nerve of a 1-category). Let \(C\) be a (small, classical) 1-category. We define the nerve of \(C\) as the simplicial set \(N(C) \in \sSet \) given by \[ N(C)_n := \Hom _{\Cat ^{(1)}}([n],C), \] i.e. it is the composite \(\simp \catop \hookrightarrow (\Cat ^{(1)}_1)\catop \xrightarrow {\Hom _{\Cat ^{(1)}}(-,C)} \Set \). Here \(\Cat ^{(1)}_1\) denotes the 1-category of small 1-categories.1 Again this construction is functorial in \(C\), resulting in a functor \[ N\colon \Cat ^{(1)}_1 \to \sSet . \]
Exercise 1.6.12. Show that the nerve \(N(C)\) of a classical 1-category \(C\) is a quasicategory. Provide an example for which it is not a Kan complex. Give a complete characterization of those 1-categories \(C\) for which \(N(C)\) is a Kan complex.
Exercise 1.6.13. Show that the functor \(N\colon \Cat ^{(1)}_1 \to \sSet \) is fully faithful, and that its essential image consists precisely of the simplicial sets in which every inner horn has a unique filler.
Example 1.6.14 (Homotopy coherent nerve). A further family of quasicategories is given by the homotopy coherent nerve \(\Ntop (D)\) of a topologically enriched category \(D\) (see Definition 25.3.1). Since this construction will not be used in the present book, we do not discuss it here in detail; see [Lurie (2009b), Definition 1.1.5.5]. In Section 25.3, we will instead construct the homotopy coherent nerve directly as an \(\infty \)-category, without passing through quasicategories.
We now relate the theory of quasicategories to our axioms of \(\infty \)-category theory:
Proposition 1.6.15. Quasicategories provide a model of the axioms for \(\infty \)-categories stated above.
Proof sketch. We describe the interpretation of our axioms in the theory of quasicategories. Functors are maps of simplicial sets, whose composition is strictly unital and associative, and animae are modeled by Kan complexes. For functors \(f,g\colon C\to D\), their identification anima is modeled by the mapping anima from \(f\) to \(g\) in the maximal Kan complex of \(\Fun (C,D)\). Composition and whiskering of natural isomorphisms supply the operations on identifications and their coherence laws. The nerve from Exercise 1.6.12 supplies the classical 1-categories.
The categorical constructions used in our axioms exist in this model and satisfy the stated universal properties, including those on identification animae. In particular, our pullbacks are modeled by homotopy pullbacks of quasicategories. The representability axiom identifies the anima of identifications between two objects with their homotopy pullback, while the Rezk axiom expresses the equivalence between a quasicategory and its \(\infty \)-category of invertible morphisms.
The remaining recognition statements are non-trivial results of quasicategory theory. A quasicategory is a Kan complex if and only if all its morphisms are invertible; see [Land (2021), Corollary 2.1.12]. This result, as well as the criteria for equivalences and invertible natural transformations in Axiom J, Axiom K, is due to Joyal [Joyal (2008)]; for the latter two, see also [Land (2021), Theorems 2.2.1 and 2.3.20]. We refer to these sources for the model-specific results; the rest of the book uses the axioms directly. □
Warning 1.6.16. Quasicategories provide a concrete model in which to establish the foundations. However, their simplicial presentation can obscure the conceptual content of \(\infty \)-category theory. Statements that refer to the underlying simplicial set, such as equality of vertices or horn fillers, concern the model rather than the abstract \(\infty \)-category. In the rest of the book we therefore continue to formulate everything model-independently.
Notes
1We use this notation to distinguish it from the (2,1)-category \(\Cat _1\) considered in Example 1.8.15(2).