Over a connective ring spectrum, projective modules are retracts of free modules, and flat modules are filtered colimits of finitely generated free modules. We deduce these descriptions from the theory of t-projective and t-flat objects in Section 6.4, Section 6.5. We then study Tor-amplitude, which bounds the degrees that can occur after tensoring with a discrete module, and show that perfect modules have finite Tor-amplitude.

8.5.1 Projective modules

Definition 8.5.1 (Ext-groups for modules). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum and let \(M, N \in \LMod _R\) be left \(R\)-modules. We define the \(n\)-th Ext-group of \(M\) and \(N\) over \(R\) to be \[ \Ext ^n_R(M,N) \quad := \quad \Ext ^n_{\LMod _R}(M,N) \quad = \quad \pi _{-n}\hom _R(M,N) \quad \simeq \quad \pi _0 \Hom _{\LMod _R}(M,N[n]). \] These are the Ext-groups from Definition 6.4.6 specialized to the stable \(\infty \)-category \(\LMod _R\).

The long exact sequence from Observation 6.4.11 applies to these groups. When \(R\) is connective and \(M,N\) are discrete, Observation 6.4.7, Observation 6.4.8 show that negative Ext-groups vanish and that \(\Ext ^0_R(M,N)\) is the ordinary Hom group over \(\pi _0(R)\).

Definition 8.5.2 (Projective module). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. A left \(R\)-module \(P\) is projective if it is a t-projective object of \(\LMod _R\) in the sense of Definition 6.4.1; that is, if the mapping spectrum functor \(\hom _R(P,-)\colon \LMod _R \to \Sp \) is t-exact.

Observation 8.5.3. Projective modules are connective by Observation 6.4.2. The characterizations of t-projective objects from Proposition 6.4.12 specialize to the following equivalent conditions for a connective left \(R\)-module \(P\):

(1)

\(P\) is projective;

(2)

For every connective left \(R\)-module \(Q\) and every \(i > 0\), we have \(\Ext ^i_R(P,Q) = 0\);

(3)

For every connective left \(R\)-module \(Q\), we have \(\Ext ^1_R(P,Q) = 0\);

(4)

Given an exact sequence \(N' \to N \to N''\) of connective left \(R\)-modules, the induced map \(\Ext ^0_R(P,N) \to \Ext ^0_R(P,N'')\) is surjective.

Since the t-structure on \(\LMod _R\) is left complete (Corollary 8.3.4), these are further equivalent to:

(5)

For every \(Q \in \LMod _R^{\heartsuit }\) and every \(i > 0\), we have \(\Ext ^i_R(P,Q) = 0\).

The projective \(R\)-modules admit a simple description as retracts of free \(R\)-modules.

Definition 8.5.4 (Free module). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum. A left \(R\)-module \(M\) is free if \(M\) is a (possibly infinite) coproduct of (unshifted) copies of \(R\), viewed as a left module over itself. A free left \(R\)-module is finitely generated if it is isomorphic to a finite coproduct of copies of \(R\).

Remark 8.5.5. This is a special case of the free-module construction from Subsection 17.1.2. There one allows modules of the form \(R \otimes X\) for an arbitrary spectrum \(X\); here \(X = \bigoplus _{i \in I} \S \) is required to be a coproduct of unshifted copies of the sphere spectrum.

Proposition 8.5.6 ([Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.2.2.7]). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum, and let \(P\) be a connective left \(R\)-module. The following conditions are equivalent:

(1)

The left \(R\)-module \(P\) is projective.

(2)

There exists a free \(R\)-module \(M\) such that \(P\) is a retract of \(M\).

Proof. Suppose first that \(P\) is projective. We can choose a map of left \(R\)-modules \(p\colon N \to P\), where \(N\) is free, such that the induced map \(\pi _0(p)\colon \pi _0(N) \to \pi _0(P)\) is surjective. (For instance, we can take \(N\) to be the free module generated by the set \(\pi _0(P)\).) Letting \(N'\) be the fiber of \(p\), it follows from the long exact sequence on homotopy groups that \(N'\) is connective as well. The exact sequence \(N' \to N \to P\) of connective \(R\)-modules induces by Observation 6.4.11 a sequence \[ \Ext ^0_R(P,N') \to \Ext ^0_R(P,N) \to \Ext ^0_R(P,P) \to \Ext ^1_R(P,N'). \] Since \(P\) is projective, the last term vanishes by criterion (3) of Observation 8.5.3. In particular, there exists a map \(s\colon P \to N\) such that \(p \circ s = \id _P\), exhibiting \(P\) as a retract of the free \(R\)-module \(N\).

For the converse, we observe that the collection of projective left \(R\)-modules is stable under retracts. It will therefore suffice to show that every free left \(R\)-module is projective. We check criterion (2) from Observation 8.5.3. Since \(\Ext ^i_R(\bigoplus _I R, Q) \cong \prod _{I} \Ext ^i_R(R,Q)\), we may assume \(P = R\) is free on a single generator. But then \[ \Ext ^i_R(R,Q) = \pi _{0} \Hom _{\LMod _R}(R,Q[i]) \simeq \pi _0 \Hom _{\Sp }(\S ,Q[i]) = \pi _{-i}(Q). \] Since \(Q\) is connective, this is zero for \(i > 0\), as desired. □

Definition 8.5.7. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. A left \(R\)-module is finitely generated projective if it is a retract of a finite coproduct of copies of \(R\).

For a projective module \(P\), this is equivalent to finite generation of \(\pi _0(P)\) over \(\pi _0(R)\). Indeed, finitely many generators give a map from a finite free module that is surjective on \(\pi _0\), and the preceding proof shows that this map splits. The converse follows by applying \(\pi _0\) to a retraction.

Remark 8.5.8. If \(R\) is an ordinary associative ring, it follows from the proposition that the projective \(R\)-module spectra are precisely the ordinary projective \(R\)-modules, regarded as discrete module spectra.

8.5.2 Flat modules

We now turn to flat modules. Recall from Definition 6.5.1 the general notion of t-flatness with respect to a tensor product \(C \times D \to E\) of stable \(\infty \)-categories with t-structures. We will specialize this to the relative tensor product of modules over a ring spectrum.

Definition 8.5.9 (Tor-groups for modules). Let \(R\) be an associative ring spectrum. For a right \(R\)-module \(M\) and a left \(R\)-module \(N\), we define the \(n\)-th Tor-group of \(M\) and \(N\) over \(R\) to be \[ \Tor ^R_n(M,N) \quad := \quad \pi _n(M \otimes _R N) \qin \Ab . \] These are the Tor-groups from Definition 6.5.6 specialized to the relative tensor product \(\RMod _R \times \LMod _R \xrightarrow {\otimes _R} \Sp \).

Observation 8.5.10. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. By Observation 8.3.5, the relative tensor product of a connective right \(R\)-module \(M\) and a connective left \(R\)-module \(N\) is connective, and \[ \Tor ^R_0(M,N) = \pi _0(M \otimes _R N) \cong \pi _0(M) \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N). \] In particular, \(\Tor ^R_n(M,N) = 0\) for \(n < 0\) whenever \(M\) and \(N\) are connective.

Observation 8.5.11 (Tor long exact sequence). Specializing Observation 6.5.7, every exact sequence of right \(R\)-modules induces a long exact sequence of Tor-groups after tensoring with a fixed left \(R\)-module. The same holds for exact sequences in the left-module variable.

Definition 8.5.12 (Flat module). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. A connective left \(R\)-module \(N\) is said to be flat if the functor \((-) \otimes _R N \colon \RMod _R \to \Sp \) is t-exact.

Remark 8.5.13. By Observation 8.5.10, the functor \((-) \otimes _R N\) is automatically right t-exact when \(N\) is connective. Thus a connective left \(R\)-module \(N\) is flat if and only if this functor is left t-exact: for every coconnective right \(R\)-module \(M\), the spectrum \(M \otimes _R N\) is coconnective.

We now give several complementary tests for flatness. Conditions (2) and (3) describe the homotopy groups of a flat module and of its tensor products, while conditions (4) and (5) reduce flatness to discrete modules. The final two conditions recover the classical criterion for an ordinary ring.

Theorem 8.5.14 (Characterization of flat modules, [Lurie (2017), Proposition 7.2.2.13, Theorem 7.2.2.15]). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum and let \(N\) be a connective left \(R\)-module. The following conditions are equivalent:

(1)

The left \(R\)-module \(N\) is flat.

(2)

For every right \(R\)-module \(M\) and \(n \in \Z \), the following map is an isomorphism: \[ \pi _n(M) \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \iso \pi _n(M \otimes _R N), \qquad \quad [x] \otimes [y] \mapsto [x \otimes y]. \]

(3)

The discrete \(\pi _0(R)\)-module \(\pi _0(N)\) is flat, and for each integer \(n\) the map \[ \pi _n(R) \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to \pi _n(N), \qquad \qquad [r] \otimes [x] \mapsto [rx] \] is an isomorphism of abelian groups.

(4)

For every discrete right \(R\)-module \(M\), the spectrum \(M \otimes _R N\) is discrete. Equivalently, \(\Tor ^R_i(M,N) = 0\) for all discrete \(M\) and all \(i > 0\).

(5)

The left \(\pi _0(R)\)-module \(\pi _0(R) \otimes _R N\) is discrete and flat.

If \(R\) and \(N\) are both discrete, these conditions are further equivalent to:

(6)

For every injection \(M' \hookrightarrow M\) of discrete right \(R\)-modules, the induced map \(M' \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_R N \to M \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_R N\) is injective.

(7)

For every discrete right \(R\)-module \(M\), we have \(\Tor ^R_1(M,N) = 0\).

Proof. We first show that the t-structural conditions are equivalent. Apply Proposition 6.5.9 to the relative tensor product \(\RMod _R \times \LMod _R \to \Sp \). The t-structure on \(\RMod _R\) is right complete by Corollary 8.3.4, relative tensor products preserve sequential colimits, and \(\Sp _{\leq 0}\) is closed under sequential colimits. Moreover, \(M \otimes _R N\) is connective when \(M\) and \(N\) are connective by Observation 8.5.10. Thus the heart criterion of Proposition 6.5.9 gives \(\text{(1)} \Leftrightarrow \text{(4)}\).

\(\text{(1)} \Rightarrow \text{(2)}\): A t-exact functor commutes with homotopy group objects by Lemma 6.3.26. On hearts, \((-)\otimes _R N\) is identified with \((-)\otimes _{\pi _0(R)}^{\heartsuit }\pi _0(N)\) by Observation 8.5.10, giving the required formula.

\(\text{(2)} \Rightarrow \text{(3)}\): Taking \(M = R\) gives the displayed isomorphisms in (3). To prove that \(\pi _0(N)\) is flat, consider a short exact sequence \(0 \to M' \to M \to M'' \to 0\) of ordinary right \(\pi _0(R)\)-modules, regarded as discrete right \(R\)-modules. Tensoring the associated exact sequence with \(N\) and applying (2) gives a short exact sequence \[ 0 \to M' \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to M \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to M'' \otimes ^{\heartsuit }_{\pi _0(R)} \pi _0(N) \to 0. \] Hence \(\pi _0(N)\) is flat over \(\pi _0(R)\).

\(\text{(3)} \Rightarrow \text{(2)}\): The right \(R\)-modules for which the formula holds in every degree form a localizing subcategory. Indeed, they are closed under shifts and coproducts, and closure under cofibers follows from the five lemma applied to the long exact sequences, using flatness of \(\pi _0(N)\). By assumption this subcategory contains \(R\), so it is all of \(\RMod _R\) by the right-module version of Lemma 8.1.11.

\(\text{(2)} \Rightarrow \text{(1)}\): The formula shows that \((-)\otimes _R N\) preserves both connective and coconnective modules.

\(\text{(4)} \iff \text{(5)}\): Let \(A := \pi _0(R)\) and let \(L := A \otimes _R N\). Every discrete right \(R\)-module is equivalently a discrete right \(A\)-module, and for such an \(M\), associativity of relative tensor products gives a natural isomorphism \[ M \otimes _A L \iso M \otimes _R N. \] If (4) holds, then taking \(M = A\) shows that \(L\) is discrete. Moreover, the displayed isomorphism shows that \(M \otimes _A L\) is discrete for every discrete right \(A\)-module \(M\). Thus \(L\) satisfies (4) as an \(A\)-module, and hence is flat by the equivalence between (1) and (4) already proved above.

Conversely, if \(L\) is discrete and flat as an \(A\)-module, then for every discrete right \(R\)-module \(M\), regarded as a discrete right \(A\)-module, the spectrum \(M \otimes _A L\) is discrete. By the displayed isomorphism, so is \(M \otimes _R N\), which is (4).

For discrete \(R\) and \(N\), Lemma 6.5.10 gives \(\text{(1)}\Leftrightarrow \text{(7)}\), since every discrete right module is a quotient of a free one. Vanishing of \(\Tor _1^R(-,N)\) implies (6) by the Tor long exact sequence. Conversely, given a free presentation \(0\to K\to F\to M\to 0\), that sequence identifies \(\Tor _1^R(M,N)\) with the kernel of \(K\otimes _R^{\heartsuit }N\to F\otimes _R^{\heartsuit }N\), which vanishes under (6). □

Observation 8.5.15. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum. Condition (3) of Theorem 8.5.14 immediately gives the following facts:

(a)

The subcategory of \(\LMod _R\) spanned by the flat \(R\)-modules is closed under coproducts, retracts, and filtered colimits.

(b)

Every free module is flat. Combining this with (a) and Proposition 8.5.6, it follows that every projective module is flat.

(c)

If \(A\) is an ordinary associative ring, then a connective left \(A\)-module \(N\) is flat if and only if \(N\) is discrete and \(\pi _0 N\) is a flat \(A\)-module in the classical sense, i.e., satisfies condition (6) of Theorem 8.5.14.

Lemma 8.5.16. Let \(R \in \CAlg (\Sp _{\geq 0})\) be a connective commutative ring spectrum, and let \(M\) and \(N\) be flat \(R\)-modules. Then \(M \otimes _R N\) is again flat.

Proof. Connectivity and coconnectivity are detected on underlying spectra by Corollary 8.3.4. Thus \((-)\otimes _R M\) and \((-)\otimes _R N\) are t-exact endofunctors of \(\Mod _R\). Their composite is \((-)\otimes _R(M\otimes _R N)\) by associativity, so \(M\otimes _R N\) is flat. □

Observation 8.5.17. Every free \(R\)-module is flat (Observation 8.5.15), so in particular the monoidal unit \(R\) is flat. Combined with Lemma 8.5.16, this shows that the full subcategory \(\Mod _R^{\flat } \subseteq \Mod _{R,\geq 0}\) spanned by the flat \(R\)-modules contains the unit and is closed under the tensor product. It therefore inherits a symmetric monoidal structure by the Part II result Lemma 14.7.1.

For connective ring spectra, flat modules admit a characterization analogous to Lazard’s theorem in ordinary algebra. It expresses them as filtered colimits of the simplest flat modules, the finitely generated free ones.

Theorem 8.5.18 (Lazard’s theorem for spectra, [Lurie (2017), Theorem 7.2.2.15]). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum and let \(N\) be a connective left \(R\)-module. The following conditions are equivalent:

(1)

The left \(R\)-module \(N\) can be obtained as a filtered colimit of finitely generated free left \(R\)-modules.

(2)

The left \(R\)-module \(N\) can be obtained as a filtered colimit of finitely generated projective left \(R\)-modules.

(3)

The left \(R\)-module \(N\) is flat.

Proof sketch. The implication \((1) \Rightarrow (2)\) is immediate because every free module is projective. The implication \((2) \Rightarrow (3)\) follows from Observation 8.5.15: projective modules are flat, and flat modules are closed under filtered colimits. The reverse implication is the substantive content of [Lurie (2017), Theorem 7.2.2.15], which we use as a black box. Its proof shows that the \(\infty \)-category of maps \(F \to N\), with \(F\) finitely generated and free, is filtered and that the canonical map from the colimit of this diagram to \(N\) is an isomorphism. The filteredness is ultimately reduced to the classical Lazard theorem over \(\pi _0(R)\). □

8.5.3 Tor-amplitude

We conclude with two boundedness properties of perfect modules. The first is immediate from their construction out of the unit.

Lemma 8.5.19. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum and let \(M\) be a perfect \(R\)-module in the sense of Definition 8.1.10. Then \(M\) is bounded below: there exists an integer \(n\) such that \(\pi _i(M) = 0\) for all \(i < n\).

Proof. The ring spectrum \(R\) is bounded below, and the bounded below \(R\)-modules form a thick subcategory of \(\LMod _R\): they are closed under shifts, cofibers, and retracts. The claim follows from the definition of a perfect module. □

Tor-amplitude gives a uniform bound after tensoring with discrete modules. By Theorem 8.5.14, flat modules are precisely the connective modules of Tor-amplitude contained in \([0,0]\).

Definition 8.5.20 (Tor-amplitude). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum and let \(M\) be a left \(R\)-module. We say that \(M\) has Tor-amplitude contained in \([a,b]\) for integers \(a \leq b\) if for every discrete right \(R\)-module \(N\), the homotopy groups of \(N \otimes _R M\) are concentrated in degrees \([a,b]\), that is, \(\Tor _i^R(N,M) = 0\) whenever \(i < a\) or \(i > b\). If such \(a\) and \(b\) exist, \(M\) is said to have finite Tor-amplitude.

The last three statements below make this bound effective for perfect modules. A perfect module concentrated in a single Tor degree is a shifted finitely generated projective module; in general, one can successively remove the bottom Tor degree.

For commutative \(R\), these properties appear in Antieau and Gepner (2014), Proposition 2.13. The following proofs also apply to associative \(R\).

Proposition 8.5.21. Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum and let \(M\) and \(N\) be left \(R\)-module spectra.

(1)

If \(M\) has Tor-amplitude contained in \([a,b]\), then the shift \(M[k]\) has Tor-amplitude contained in \([a + k, b + k]\) for all \(k \in \Z \).

(2)

If \(M\) is perfect, then \(M\) has finite Tor-amplitude.

(3)

If \(R\to S\) is a morphism of connective associative ring spectra and \(M\) has Tor-amplitude contained in \([a,b]\), then the left \(S\)-module \(S\otimes _R M\) has Tor-amplitude contained in \([a,b]\).

(4)

If \(M\) and \(N\) have Tor-amplitude contained in \([a, b]\), then the fiber and cofiber of a map \(M \to N\) have Tor-amplitude contained in \([a - 1, b]\) and \([a, b + 1]\).

(5)

If \(M\) is perfect with Tor-amplitude contained in \([0,b]\), then \(M\) is connective and \(\pi _0 M \cong \pi _0(\pi _0(R)\otimes _R M)\).

(6)

If \(M\) is perfect with Tor-amplitude contained in \([a,a]\), then \(M\) is isomorphic to \(P[a]\) for a finitely generated projective left \(R\)-module \(P\).

(7)

If \(M\) is perfect with Tor-amplitude contained in \([a,b]\) and \(a<b\), then there exists an exact sequence \(P[a]\to M\to Q\) with \(P\) finitely generated projective and \(Q\) perfect with Tor-amplitude contained in \([a+1,b]\). When \(a=b\), part (6) gives such a sequence with \(Q=0\).

Proof. Part (1) follows directly from the definition. For (2), observe that \(R\) has Tor-amplitude contained in \([0,0]\) and that the left \(R\)-modules of finite Tor-amplitude form a thick subcategory of \(\LMod _R\): they are closed under shifts and retracts, while closure under cofibers follows from the long exact sequence of Tor-groups (Observation 8.5.11). For (3), if \(T\) is a discrete right \(S\)-module, then \[ T \otimes _S (S \otimes _R M) \simeq T \otimes _R M. \] Part (4) follows from the same long exact sequence of Tor-groups.

For (5), suppose \(M\neq 0\) and let \(k\) be its lowest nonzero homotopy degree, which exists by Lemma 8.5.19. Applying Observation 8.5.10 to the connective module \(M[-k]\) gives \[ \pi _k(\pi _0(R)\otimes _R M)\cong \pi _k(M)\neq 0. \] The amplitude bound forces \(k\geq 0\), so \(M\) is connective. The assertion about \(\pi _0\) follows from the same tensor-product formula. For \(M=0\), both claims are immediate.

For (6), shift to \(a=0\). By (5), \(M\) is connective, and the discrete-module test in Theorem 8.5.14 makes it flat. By Theorem 8.5.18, \(M\) is a filtered colimit of finitely generated free modules. Since \(M\) is compact by Lemma 8.1.11, its identity factors through one of these modules, exhibiting \(M\) as a retract of it.

For (7), shift to \(a=0<b\). Then \(M\) is connective by (5). Write \(\pi _0(M)\) as the filtered union of its finitely generated submodules \(A_i\). Since \(M\) is compact and the inclusion of discrete modules preserves filtered colimits, the truncation map \(M\to \pi _0(M)\) factors through some \(A_i\). On \(\pi _0\), this forces \(A_i=\pi _0(M)\). Choose a finite free module \(P\) and a map \(P\to M\) surjective on \(\pi _0\), and let \(Q\) be its cofiber. For any discrete right \(R\)-module \(T\), the map \[ \pi _0(T\otimes _R P)\to \pi _0(T\otimes _R M) \] is surjective by Observation 8.5.10 and right exactness of ordinary tensor products. Moreover, \(T\otimes _R P\) is discrete. The long exact sequence therefore puts \(T\otimes _R Q\) in degrees \([1,b]\). Finally, \(Q\) is perfect as the cofiber of a map between perfect modules. □

Example 8.5.22. Perfectness, projectivity, and flatness impose different conditions. Over \(\Z \), the module \((\Z /p)\) for a prime \(p\) is perfect, being the cofiber of multiplication by \(p\) on \(\Z \). It has Tor-amplitude contained in \([0,1]\), but is not flat: tensoring this cofiber sequence with \((\Z /p)\) gives a nonzero homotopy group in degree \(1\).

In the other direction, \(\bigoplus _{n\geq 0}\Z \) is projective and flat, but not perfect. Indeed, it is the filtered colimit of its finite partial sums, and its identity cannot factor through any of them, so it is not compact.

Exercises

Exercise 8.1 (Perfect modules and base change). Let \(f\colon R\to S\) be a morphism of associative ring spectra.

(1)

Show that extension of scalars \(S\otimes _R-\colon \LMod _R\to \LMod _S\) sends perfect \(R\)-modules to perfect \(S\)-modules.

(2)

Assume that \(R\) and \(S\) are commutative and let \(x\in \pi _0(R)\). Write \(R/x\) for the cofiber of multiplication by \(x\) on \(R\). Show that \(R/x\) is perfect and that \[ S\otimes _R(R/x)\cong S/f(x). \]

Exercise 8.2 (Relative tensor products and mapping spectra). Let \(m,n\geq 1\) and put \(d:=\gcd (m,n)\).

(1)

Compute \(\pi _*\hom _{\Z }((\Z /m),(\Z /n))\). Show that these groups vanish outside degrees \(0\) and \(-1\), and are isomorphic to \(\Z /d\) in each of those degrees.

(2)

Compute \(\pi _*((\Z /m)\otimes _{\Z }(\Z /n))\). Show that these groups vanish outside degrees \(0\) and \(1\), and are isomorphic to \(\Z /d\) in each of those degrees.

Hint: Apply the two functors to the cofiber sequence defining \((\Z /m)\).

Exercise 8.3 (Graded localization). Let \(R\) be a commutative ring spectrum with \(\pi _*(R)\cong A[u]\), where \(A\) is a nonzero ordinary commutative ring concentrated in degree \(0\) and \(u\) has degree \(2\).

(1)

Compute \(\pi _*(R[u^{-1}])\). Show that multiplication by \(u\) gives an isomorphism \(R[u^{-1}][2]\iso R[u^{-1}]\), and that \(R[u^{-1}]\) is not connective.

(2)

Let \(R/u\) be the cofiber of multiplication by \(u\): \[ R[2]\xrightarrow {u}R\to R/u. \] Show that \(R/u\) is a nonzero perfect \(R\)-module, compute its homotopy groups, and show that \(R[u^{-1}]\otimes _R(R/u)=0\).

Exercise 8.4 (Projectivity and flatness of the discrete truncation). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum, and regard \(\pi _0(R)\) as a left \(R\)-module via the canonical morphism \(R \to \pi _0(R)\). Show that the following conditions are equivalent:

(1)

The ring spectrum \(R\) is discrete.

(2)

The left \(R\)-module \(\pi _0(R)\) is projective.

(3)

The left \(R\)-module \(\pi _0(R)\) is flat.

Deduce that \(\Z \) is neither projective nor flat as a module over the sphere spectrum, even though \(\pi _0(\Z )\) is free of rank one over \(\pi _0(\S )\).

Exercise 8.5 (Finite projective filtrations). Let \(R\) be a connective associative ring spectrum and let \(M\) be a perfect left \(R\)-module of Tor-amplitude contained in \([a,b]\). Show that there is a filtration \[ 0=M_{a-1}\to M_a\to \cdots \to M_b=M \] with \(\cofib (M_{i-1}\to M_i)\cong P_i[i]\) for finitely generated projective left \(R\)-modules \(P_i\). Hint: Induct on \(b-a\) using Proposition 8.5.21, and pull back a filtration of the cofiber along \(M\to Q\).