We now prove Proposition 10.2.12. We first construct fiberwise one-point compactification on the ordinary groupoids of vector bundles, compatibly with direct sums and pullback. We then pass to underlying animae, apply the construction over \(X\times \abs {\Delta ^q}\), and take the colimit defining the moduli anima. The passage to animae uses the formalism of pointed \(\infty \)-operads from Part II. This section may be skipped on a first reading.

10.5.1 Fiberwise compactification

Fix a topological space \(X\). Let \(\mathrm {Bun}(X)\) be the 1-category of locally trivial fiber bundles over \(X\) and continuous maps over \(X\). Its terminal object is \(X\to X\), and its finite products are fiber products over \(X\). Let \(\mathrm {Bun}_{*,\mathrm {c}}(X)\) be the 1-category of locally trivial pointed bundles over \(X\) with compact Hausdorff fibers and section-preserving maps. That is, the local trivializations carry the distinguished section to the basepoint of the fiber.

For \(K,L\in \mathrm {Bun}_{*,\mathrm {c}}(X)\) with sections \(s_K\) and \(s_L\), define the fiberwise wedge \[ K\vee _XL := \bigl (K\times _Xs_L(X)\bigr )\cup \bigl (s_K(X)\times _XL\bigr ) \subseteq K\times _XL. \] The fiberwise smash product is the pushout \[ K\wedge _XL:=(K\times _XL)\amalg _{K\vee _XL}X \] in topological spaces over \(X\), pointed by the last term. In each fiber this collapses the wedge to a point. Over a common pointed trivializing open subset \(U\subseteq X\), the quotient map is \[ \id _U\times q\colon U\times (K_0\times L_0)\longrightarrow U\times (K_0\wedge L_0). \] Here \(q\colon K_0\times L_0\to K_0\wedge L_0\) is the quotient map. Since it is a closed surjection with compact fibers, its product with \(U\) is a quotient map. It follows that \(K\wedge _XL\) is locally trivial with compact Hausdorff pointed fiber \(K_0\wedge L_0\). Iterated fiberwise smash products are obtained by collapsing tuples with a basepoint coordinate. The associativity, unit and symmetry maps therefore satisfy the coherence identities, giving a symmetric monoidal structure on \(\mathrm {Bun}_{*,\mathrm {c}}(X)\) with unit \(X\times S^0\). These constructions commute with pullback, as can be checked in local trivializations.

Lemma 10.5.1 (Fiberwise one-point compactification). Fiberwise one-point compactification defines a symmetric monoidal functor \[ \Vect _{\R }^{\disc }(X)^{\simeq } \longrightarrow \mathrm {Bun}_{*,\mathrm {c}}(X)^{\simeq }, \qquad E\longmapsto S^E, \] natural in \(X\) under pullback.

Proof. A linear isomorphism extends uniquely to a pointed homeomorphism of one-point compactifications. The local description of Construction 10.1.1 shows that this extension is continuous in families. It therefore gives a functor on groupoids of vector bundles, commuting with pullback.

The natural homeomorphisms \(S^{V\oplus W}\cong S^V\wedge S^W\) give, in bundle charts, isomorphisms \[ S^{E\oplus F}\cong S^E\wedge _XS^F, \qquad S^{0_X}\cong X\times S^0, \] where \(0_X\) denotes the zero vector bundle on \(X\). The associativity, unit and symmetry diagrams reduce away from infinity to those for direct sums. Since all maps preserve the infinity sections, these diagrams commute everywhere. □

10.5.2 Passage to animae

We next pass from pointed bundles over \(X\) to families of pointed animae over \(\Pi _\infty (X)\). Taking underlying animae preserves fiber products of bundles. The construction of pointed \(\infty \)-operads turns this compatibility into a lax symmetric monoidal functor for smash products; we will then show that its structure maps are isomorphisms on sphere bundles.

We use the following consequence of the construction of pointed \(\infty \)-operads. A finite-product-preserving functor \(F\colon C\to D\) induces a morphism \[ (\Mm _{(C,\times )})_*\longrightarrow (\Mm _{(D,\times )})_* \] by Proposition 15.3.6, Theorem 20.2.10. On pointed objects, this sends \((*\to K)\) to \((*\to F(K))\). If \(D\) admits finite colimits and its cartesian product preserves them separately in each variable, the target is the multimorphism operad of \((D_*,\wedge )\) by Lemma 20.4.2. This construction is functorial in \(F\): the cartesian symmetric monoidal refinement is functorial by the equivalence of Proposition 15.3.6, and \((-)_*\) is a functor. It gives a lax symmetric monoidal functor whenever the source pointed \(\infty \)-operad is represented by a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category.

For \(C=\mathrm {Bun}(X)\), we only need its full pointed suboperad on \(\mathrm {Bun}_{*,\mathrm {c}}(X)\). An operation from \(K_1,\ldots ,K_r\) to \(L\) is a bundle map \[ K_1\times _X\cdots \times _XK_r\longrightarrow L \] which sends a tuple with any coordinate in the distinguished section to the distinguished section of \(L\). Such maps factor uniquely through the fiberwise smash product. Nullary operations are sections of \(L\), equivalently pointed maps \(X\times S^0\to L\). Thus this full suboperad is represented by \((\mathrm {Bun}_{*,\mathrm {c}}(X),\wedge _X)\).

Lemma 10.5.2 (Passage to underlying animae). Taking underlying animae of fiberwise one-point compactifications defines symmetric monoidal functors \[ \xi _X\colon \Vect _{\R }^{\disc }(X)^{\simeq } \longrightarrow \Fun (\Pi _\infty (X),\An _*), \qquad E\longmapsto \xi _E, \] natural in \(X\) under pullback.

Proof. Taking underlying animae of total spaces and projections gives \[ \Pi _{\infty ,X}\colon \mathrm {Bun}(X)\longrightarrow \An _{/\Pi _\infty (X)}. \] This functor preserves finite products: the terminal bundle maps to the terminal object, and for bundles \(K,L\) the canonical map \[ \Pi _\infty (K\times _XL) \longrightarrow \Pi _\infty (K)\times _{\Pi _\infty (X)}\Pi _\infty (L) \] is an isomorphism. Indeed, bundle projections are Serre fibrations by Theorem 2.3.13, so Proposition 2.3.19 applies.

These functors are natural under pullback. More precisely, the categories \(\mathrm {Bun}(X)\) form a cartesian fibration over \(\Top \). Taking underlying animae gives a functor from this fibration to the pullback along \(\Pi _\infty \) of the codomain fibration \(\Ar (\An )\to \An \). It preserves cartesian morphisms, since a pullback square along a bundle projection becomes a pullback square of animae. Cartesian straightening therefore gives a natural transformation of finite-product-preserving functors.

Pointing now gives lax symmetric monoidal functors on \(\mathrm {Bun}_{*,\mathrm {c}}(X)\), naturally in \(X\). Straightening preserves finite products and colimits, so its pointed refinement identifies the target with \(\Fun (\Pi _\infty (X),\An _*)\), equipped with pointwise smash product, by Lemma 20.4.2. Composing with Lemma 10.5.1 gives natural lax symmetric monoidal functors \(\xi _X\).

It remains to check that their structure maps are isomorphisms. This can be checked at each point \(x\in X\). Pullback to \(x\) identifies the fibers of the realized bundles with the underlying animae of their topological fibers, again because bundle projections are Serre fibrations. The binary structure map at \(x\) is consequently \[ \Pi _\infty (S^{E_x})\wedge \Pi _\infty (S^{F_x}) \longrightarrow \Pi _\infty (S^{E_x}\wedge S^{F_x}) \cong \Pi _\infty (S^{E_x\oplus F_x}). \] Choose coordinates identifying the two compactifications with \(S^m\) and \(S^n\). The inclusion \[ (S^m\times \{\infty \})\cup (\{\infty \}\times S^n) \hookrightarrow S^m\times S^n \] is a relative cell complex, as are the inclusions used to form the wedge. Thus Corollary 2.3.20, Proposition 2.3.9 identify the displayed structure map with an isomorphism. The unit structure map is \(S^0\cong \Pi _\infty (S^0)\). Hence the functors \(\xi _X\) are symmetric monoidal, and their naturality gives the asserted transformation. □

10.5.3 Passage to the moduli anima

We now apply the preceding lemma over \(X\times \abs {\Delta ^q}\). Pullback along the projections identifies the resulting targets with the constant simplicial diagram at \(\Fun (\Pi _\infty (X),\An _*)^\simeq \), allowing us to take the colimit defining the moduli anima.

Proof of Proposition 10.2.12. Put \[ D(X):=\Fun (\Pi _\infty (X),\An _*)^\simeq , \] regarded as a commutative monoid in animae under pointwise smash product. Since the source of \(\xi _X\) is a groupoid, Lemma 10.5.2 gives a natural map \[ \Vect _{\R }^{\disc }(X)^\simeq \longrightarrow D(X) \qquad \text {in }\CMon (\An ). \] Applying it over \(X\times \abs {\Delta ^q}\) gives a map of simplicial diagrams \[ \Vect _{\R }^{\disc }(X\times \abs {\Delta ^\bullet })^\simeq \longrightarrow D(X\times \abs {\Delta ^\bullet }). \] On the other hand, pullback along the projections gives \[ \const _{D(X)}\longrightarrow D(X\times \abs {\Delta ^\bullet }). \] Every component of this map is an isomorphism, since \(X\times \abs {\Delta ^q}\to X\) is a homotopy equivalence. Inverting it and composing with the preceding map gives a cocone in \(\CMon (\An )\). By Corollary 9.4.3, the universal property of the colimit in \(\CMon (\An )\) therefore gives \[ S_X^{(-)}\colon \Vect _{\R }(X)^\simeq \longrightarrow D(X) \subseteq \Fun (\Pi _\infty (X),\An _*). \] This functor sends \(E\) to \(\xi _E\), as seen in degree zero, and is natural in \(X\), since both maps of simplicial diagrams are natural in \(X\).

It remains to identify the restriction of \(S_{\pt }^{(-)}\) to \(\bB O(n)\) with the functor classified by the standard orthogonal action. The proof of Proposition 9.4.4, with \(\R \) in place of \(\C \), identifies the rank \(n\) component of \(\Vect _{\R }(\pt )^\simeq \) with \(\bB \GL _n(\R )\simeq \bB O(n)\), compatibly with block sums. In degree \(q\), an automorphism of the trivial bundle is a continuous map \(g\colon \abs {\Delta ^q}\to \GL _n(\R )\). Fiberwise compactification sends it to \[ (t,v)\longmapsto (t,g(t)v), \qquad (t,\infty )\longmapsto (t,\infty ). \] These formulas commute with the simplicial operators and composition. They identify the restriction to \(\bB \GL _n(\R )\) with the functor obtained by realizing the singular simplicial action on \(S^{\R ^n}\). Restricting along \(O(n)\to \GL _n(\R )\) gives the corresponding functor for the orthogonal action.

To identify this with the associated-bundle description used in Subsection 10.2.4, take the universal principal \(O(n)\)-bundle \(P=V_n(\R ^\infty )\to B=\Gr _n(\R ^\infty )\). Its total space is contractible, and \[ S^{\gamma _n}\cong P\times _{O(n)}S^{\R ^n}. \] Over \(P\) this pointed bundle is trivial, and under \(P\times _B P\cong P\times O(n)\) its transition maps are the standard orthogonal action. By Lemma 9.2.9, Proposition 9.2.10, taking underlying animae identifies the Čech nerve of \(P\to B\) with the bar construction for \(O(n)\). The transition maps therefore give the same action as the simplicial formulas above, including their compatibility with composition. Descent for animae (Theorem 5.2.5) identifies the resulting pointed object over \(\bB O(n)\) with the underlying pointed object of \(S^{\gamma _n}\to B\). Its straightening is, by definition, the functor classified by the pointed orthogonal action. This proves the final assertion of the proposition. □

Exercises

Exercise 10.1 (Homotopy invariance of Thom spaces). Let \(f\colon X'\to X\) be a homotopy equivalence between paracompact Hausdorff spaces and let \(E\to X\) be a real vector bundle. Prove part (2) of Lemma 10.1.8: the induced map \(\Th (f^*E)\to \Th (E)\) is a pointed homotopy equivalence. Hint: Use homotopy invariance of vector bundles over cylinders, and observe that it suffices for both composites of the induced Thom maps to be pointed homotopic to homeomorphisms.

Exercise 10.2 (External sums and Thom spectra). Let \(V\colon A\to \BOP \) and \(W\colon B\to \BOP \) be virtual vector bundles. Define their external sum as the composite \[ V\boxplus W\colon A\times B\xrightarrow {V\times W}\BOP \times \BOP \xrightarrow {+}\BOP . \] Show that there is a natural isomorphism \[ \th (V\boxplus W)\cong \th (V)\otimes \th (W). \]

Exercise 10.3 (The Möbius bundle). Let \(L\to S^1\) be the Möbius real line bundle.

(1)

Identify \(\Th (L)\) with \(\R \!\mathrm {P}^2\) as a pointed space.

(2)

Show that \(L\) is not \(\Z \)-orientable.

(3)

Construct its canonical \(\F _2\)-orientation. Writing \(a\in H^1(\R \!\mathrm {P}^2;\F _2)\) for the standard generator, show that the Thom class is \(a\) and that the Thom isomorphism sends the generators of \(H^0(S^1;\F _2)\) and \(H^1(S^1;\F _2)\) to \(a\) and \(a^2\), respectively.

Exercise 10.4 (Collapse of a framed point). Let \(n\geq 1\). Embed a point in \(\R ^n\) and equip its normal bundle with the standard framing. Write down the Pontryagin–Thom collapse map \[ S^n\longrightarrow \Th (\R ^n)\cong S^n. \] Show that, with the standard choices of orientation, this map has degree \(1\). Explain how reversing one vector in the framing changes the degree.

Exercise 10.5 (Low-dimensional unoriented bordism). Compute \(\Omega _0^O(*)\) and \(\Omega _1^O(*)\). Compare your answer with \(\pi _0(\MO )\) and \(\pi _1(\MO )\).

Exercise 10.6 (Thom isomorphism for the tautological line). Let \(\gamma ^1\to \R \!\mathrm {P}^n\) be the tautological real line bundle. Compute the reduced mod-\(2\) cohomology of \(\Th (\gamma ^1)\) as a graded \(\F _2\)-vector space. Identify the Thom class and its restrictions to the fibers.