Proposition 4.4 ([Efimov (2024), Proposition 2.39], [Krause et al. (2024), Proposition 2.4.1]). Let \(C\) be compactly assembled and let \(f\colon x \to x'\) be a morphism in \(C\). Then the following are equivalent:
- (1)
-
\(f\) is compact (in the sense of Definition 3.3);
- (2)
-
\(f\) is weakly compact;
- (3)
-
\(y(f)\colon y(x) \to y(x')\) factors through \(\varepsilon _{x'}\colon \hat {y}(x') \to y(x')\);
- (4)
-
\(\hat {y}(f)\colon \hat {y}(x) \to \hat {y}(x')\) factors through \(\varepsilon _x\colon \hat {y}(x) \to y(x)\);
- (5)
-
\(\hat {y}(f)\) is a weakly compact morphism in \(\Ind (C)\).
Proof.
We use repeatedly that maps \(\hat {y}(w) \to Z\) in \(\Ind (C)\) correspond, under the adjunction \(\hat {y} \dashv \colim \), to maps \(w \to \colim Z\); in particular, two maps \(\hat {y}(w) \to Z\) are homotopic as soon as their images under \(\colim \) are, where we identify \(\colim \hat {y}(w) \simeq w\). Similarly, two maps \(y(w) \to y(w')\) are homotopic as soon as their images under \(\colim \) are, since \(y\) is fully faithful. Recall also that \(\colim (\varepsilon _w) \simeq \id _w\).
(1) \(\iff \) (3) is Lemma 3.5(1), and (1) \(\implies \) (2) was observed in Remark 4.2.
(2) \(\implies \) (3): Write \(\hat {y}(x') \simeq \quotcolim _i z_i\). Then \(\colim _i z_i \simeq \colim \hat {y}(x') \simeq x'\). Applying weak compactness to the identity \(x' \to \colim _i z_i\), we find a map \(h\colon x \to z_i\) for some \(i\) such that the composite \(x \to z_i \to \colim _i z_i \simeq x'\) is homotopic to \(f\). Let \(g\colon y(x) \to \hat {y}(x')\) be the composite of \(y(h)\) with the canonical map \(y(z_i) \to \quotcolim _i z_i\). Then \(\colim (\varepsilon _{x'} g) \simeq \colim (g) \simeq f\), and hence \(\varepsilon _{x'}g \simeq y(f)\).
(3) \(\implies \) (4): Let \(g\colon y(x) \to \hat {y}(x')\) with \(\varepsilon _{x'}g \simeq y(f)\). Then \(g\varepsilon _x\) and \(\hat {y}(f)\) are maps \(\hat {y}(x) \to \hat {y}(x')\) with \(\colim (g\varepsilon _x) \simeq \colim (g) \simeq f \simeq \colim (\hat {y}(f))\), so \(\hat {y}(f) \simeq g\varepsilon _x\).
(4) \(\implies \) (5): The object \(y(x)\) is compact in \(\Ind (C)\), so this follows from Example 4.3(3).
(5) \(\implies \) (2): Let \(g\colon x' \to \colim _i z_i\) be a map in \(C\), and let \(Z = \quotcolim _i z_i = \colim _i y(z_i)\). By adjunction, \(g\) corresponds to a map \(\tilde {g}\colon \hat {y}(x') \to Z\) with \(\colim (\tilde {g}) \simeq g\). By (5), the composite \(\tilde {g}\hat {y}(f)\colon \hat {y}(x) \to \colim _i y(z_i)\) factors through some \(y(z_i)\), say as \(\hat {y}(x) \xrightarrow {u} y(z_i) \to Z\). Applying \(\colim \), we find that \(gf \simeq \colim (\tilde {g}\hat {y}(f))\) factors as \(x \xrightarrow {\colim (u)} z_i \to \colim _i z_i\). ā”