Proposition 3.22. Let \(F\colon C \to D\) be a colimit-preserving functor between dualizable categories. Then \(F\) is strongly continuous if and only if \(F\) preserves compact morphisms.
Proof.
Write \(\varepsilon \colon \hat {y} \to y\) for the natural transformation from Section 3.1, and let \(\beta \colon \hat {y}_DF \to \Ind (F)\hat {y}_C\) be the mate from Definition 3.9. By Proposition A.27, \(F\) is strongly continuous if and only if \(\beta \) is an equivalence. We will repeatedly use the following observation: a map \(\hat {y}_D(z) \to Y\) in \(\Ind (D)\) is determined, via the adjunction \(\hat {y}_D \dashv \colim \), by its image under \(\colim \) (composed with the identification \(z \simeq \colim \hat {y}_D(z)\)). Applying \(\colim \) to \(\varepsilon _{Fx}\), to \(\Ind (F)(\varepsilon _x) \circ \beta _x\), and to \(\beta _x\) yields the identity of \(Fx\) in each case (up to the canonical identifications), by construction of \(\varepsilon \) and of the mate \(\beta \). Hence \begin {equation} \tag{3.1}\label {eq:Mate_Compatible_Epsilon} \varepsilon _{Fx} \simeq \Ind (F)(\varepsilon _x) \circ \beta _x\colon \hat {y}_D(Fx) \to y(Fx). \end {equation}
Suppose first that \(F\) is strongly continuous, and let \(f\colon x \to x'\) be a compact morphism in \(C\). By Lemma 3.5, there is \(g\colon y(x) \to \hat {y}_C(x')\) with \(\varepsilon _{x'}g \simeq y(f)\). Then \(g' := \beta _{x'}^{-1} \circ \Ind (F)(g)\colon y(Fx) \to \hat {y}_D(Fx')\) satisfies \[ \varepsilon _{Fx'} \circ g' \simeq \Ind (F)(\varepsilon _{x'}) \circ \Ind (F)(g) \simeq \Ind (F)(y(f)) = y(Ff) \] by (3.1), so \(Ff\) is compact by Lemma 3.5.
Conversely, suppose that \(F\) preserves compact morphisms. Both functors \(\hat {y}_DF\) and \(\Ind (F)\hat {y}_C\) preserve colimits: \(\hat {y}_C\) and \(\hat {y}_D\) are left adjoints, and \(\Ind (F)\) is an exact functor between stable categories which preserves filtered colimits. Since \(C\) is generated under colimits by its \(\omega _1\)-compact objects (Theorem 3.20(1)), it suffices to show that \(\beta _x\) is an equivalence for \(x\) \(\omega _1\)-compact. By Theorem 3.20(2) and Lemma 3.5, we may write \(x \simeq \colim (x_0 \to x_1 \to \cdots )\) with compact transition maps, and the proof of “\(\impliedby \)” in Theorem 3.20(2) shows that the canonical map \[ \hat {y}_C(x) \simeq \colim _n \hat {y}_C(x_n) \xrightarrow {\colim _n \varepsilon _{x_n}} \colim _n y(x_n) \] is an equivalence in \(\Ind (C)\). Since \(F\) preserves colimits and compact morphisms, \(Fx \simeq \colim _n Fx_n\) with compact transition maps, so likewise \(\hat {y}_D(Fx) \to \colim _n y(Fx_n)\) is an equivalence. Now consider the composite \[ \hat {y}_D(Fx) \xrightarrow {\beta _x} \Ind (F)(\hat {y}_C(x)) \xrightarrow {\simeq } \Ind (F)\big (\colim _n y(x_n)\big ) \simeq \colim _n y(Fx_n). \] Applying \(\colim \) to it gives the identity of \(Fx\) (up to the canonical identifications), so by the observation above it agrees with the canonical equivalence \(\hat {y}_D(Fx) \to \colim _n y(Fx_n)\). Hence \(\beta _x\) is an equivalence. □