Proposition 4.2.12. Let \(f\colon A \to B\) be a left fibration.
(1) For \(\beta = \id_b\colon b \to b\), the functor \((\id_b)_!\colon A_b \to A_b\) is identified with the identity functor;
(2) For morphisms \(\beta\colon b \to b'\) and \(\beta'\colon b' \to b''\) in \(B\), the composite functor \[ \beta'_! \circ \beta _!\colon A_b \to A_{b''} \] is identified with \((\beta' \circ \beta)_!\colon A_b \to A_{b''}\).
The dual result for the contravariant transport functors of a right fibration is also valid.
Proof
For (1), observe that for any term \(a : A_b\) the map \(\id_a\colon a \to a\) is a covariant lift of \(\id_b\colon b \to b\) starting in \(a\). By uniqueness of covariant lifts, it follows that \(\id_a = \lift^f_0(a,\id_b)\), and in particular we have \(a = (\id_b)_!a\). Applying this to the universal term of \(A_b\) provides the desired identification \((\id_b)_! = \id_{A_b}\).
For (2), we have for a term \(a : A_b\) a covariant lift \[ \lift^f_0(a,\beta)\colon a \to \beta_!(a) \] of \(\beta\) starting in \(a\), which in turn leads to a covariant lift \[ \lift^f_0(\beta_!(a), \beta') \colon \beta_!(a) \to \beta'_!(\beta_!(a)). \] Since the composite of these two morphisms is a covariant lift of \(\beta' \circ \beta\) starting in \(a\), it follows that there is an isomorphism \[ \lift^f_0(\beta_!(a), \beta') \circ \lift^f_0(a,\beta) = \lift^f_0(a,\beta' \circ \beta), \] and in particular we get \((\beta' \circ \beta)_!(a) = \beta'_!(\beta_!(a))\). Taking \(a\) to be the universal term of \(A_b\) then provides the desired identification.