Lemma 20.2.1 (the Eckmann-Hilton argument, le lemme de Godement). Let \(A\) be an anima together with a term \(e : A\) as well as two maps \[ \circ \colon A\times A\to A\ , \quad (a,b)\mapsto a\circ b\quadtext{and} \bullet\colon A\times A\to A\ , \quad (a,b)\mapsto a\bullet b\, . \] We assume that the following rules hold.

  • (i) For every term \(a : A\), there are terms of the following types: \begin{align*} u^l_a& : a= e\circ a\\ u^r_a& : a\circ e= a\\ v^l_a& : a= e\bullet a\\ v^r_a& : a\bullet e= a \, . \end{align*}

  • (ii) For every term \(a,b,c,d : X\), there is a term of type \[ \gamma_{a,b,c,d} : (a\bullet b)\circ (c\bullet d)= (a\circ c)\bullet (b\circ d)\, . \]

Then, for any terms \(a,b : A\), there are terms \[ \kappa_{a,b} : a\bullet b = a\circ b \quadtext{and} \kappa'_{a,b} : a\circ b = b\bullet a\, . \]

Proof

The term \(\kappa_{a,b}\) is obtained as follows. \begin{align*} a\bullet b &=(a\circ e)\bullet(e\circ b)\\ &=(a\bullet e)\circ(e\bullet b)\\ &=a\circ b\, , \end{align*} Similarly, the sequence \begin{align*} a\circ b &=(e\bullet a)\circ (b\bullet e)\\ &=(e\circ b)\bullet (a\circ e)\\ &=b\bullet a \end{align*} yields \(\kappa'_{a,b}\).

From Section 20.2, Additive categories.