Recall that for a cocartesian fibration \(W \to [1]\), the canonical morphism \(v\colon 0 \to 1\) in \([1]\) determines a covariant transport functor \(v_!\colon W_0 \to W_1\). We will now construct a version of covariant transport that works over an arbitrary base category.

Construction 8.2.1. Let \(S\) be a category, let \(p\colon W \to [1] \times S\) be a cocartesian fibration, and denote by \(p_i\colon W_i \to S\) for \(i = 0,1\) the base change of \(p\) along the inclusion \((i,\id)\colon S \to [1] \times S\). We will construct a cocartesian functor over \([1] \times S\) of the form Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source The functor \(l\) will be constructed as a dashed filler fitting in the following commutative diagram: Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source Observe that such a choice of lift is equivalent to finding a filler for the following commutative diagram: Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source where the right vertical functor is given by postcomposition with \(p\) and the bottom map is adjoint to \([1] \times p_0 \colon [1] \times W_0 \to [1]\times S\). Equivalently, we need to find a morphism in \(\Fun(W_0,W)\) whose source is the inclusion \(\iota_0\colon W_0 \to W\) and which lifts the morphism in \(\Fun(W_0,[1] \times S)\) adjoint to \(\id_{[1]} \times p_0\colon [1] \times W_0 \to [1] \times S\). Since \(p_*\) is a cocartesian fibration by Proposition 4.5.13, we may simply choose \(k\) to be a cocartesian lift which starts in \(\iota_0\).

Unwinding the proof of Proposition 4.5.13, we obtain an explicit description of \(l\) at the level of objects: given an object \((\epsilon,w) \in [1] \times W_0\), write \(s := p_0(w) \in S\) and let \(u \colon 0 \to \epsilon\) denote the morphism in \([1]\) obtained from the fact that \(0 \in [1]\) is an initial object, see Lemma 4.4.22. Then we have \[ l(\epsilon,w) = (u,\id_s)_!(w), \] where the functor \((u,\id_s)_!\colon W_{(0,s)} \to W_{(\epsilon,s)}\) denotes cocartesian transport along the morphism \((u,\id_s)\colon (0,s) \to (\epsilon,s)\) in \([1] \times S\).

Lemma 8.2.2. The functor \(l\colon [1] \times W_0 \to W\) constructed in Construction 8.2.1 is a cocartesian functor over \([1] \times S\).

Proof

Consider a morphism \(\psi\colon (\epsilon, s) \to (\epsilon', s')\) in \([1] \times S\) and an object \((\epsilon,w) \in \{\epsilon\} \times (W_0)_s = ([1] \times W_0)_{(\epsilon,s)}\). By Corollary 6.5.9, it will suffice to show that the canonical map \[ \overline{\psi}\colon \psi_!(l(\epsilon, w)) \to l(\psi_!(\epsilon,w)) \] is an isomorphism in \(W\). Observe that we may factor \(\psi\) as a composite \[ (\epsilon,s) \to (\epsilon',s) \to (\epsilon',s'), \] and hence since the covariant transport functors compose, Corollary 4.5.11, it will suffice to show the claim in the two cases where either \(\epsilon = \epsilon'\) or \(s = s'\):

  • โ€ข Assume that \(s = s'\) and \(\psi = (v,\id_s) \colon (\epsilon,s) \to (\epsilon',s)\) for some morphism \(v\colon \epsilon \to \epsilon'\) in \([1]\). Letting \(u_{\epsilon}\colon 0 \to \epsilon\) and \(u_{\epsilon'}\colon 0 \to \epsilon'\) denote the canonical maps in \([1]\), the map \(\overline{\psi}\) then simplifies to the map \[ (v,\id_s)_!(u_{\epsilon}, \id_s)_!(w) \to (u_{\epsilon'},\id_s)_!(w). \] But since \(u_{\epsilon'} \colon 0 \to \epsilon'\) is the composite of \(u_{\epsilon}\colon 0 \to \epsilon\) and \(v\colon \epsilon \to \epsilon'\), this map is an isomorphism by Corollary 4.5.11.

  • โ€ข Assume that \(\epsilon = \epsilon'\) and that \(\psi = (\id_{\epsilon}, v)\) for some morphism \(v\colon s \to s'\) in \(S\). The canonical comparison \((\epsilon,w) \iso (u_{\epsilon}, \id_s)_!(0,w)\), together with the previous case, reduces the claim to \(\epsilon = 0\). The map \(\overline{\psi}\) then simplifies to the map \[ (\id_{0}, v)_!(u_{0},\id_s)_!(0,w) \to (u_{0},\id_{s'})_!(\id_{0}, v)_!(0,w), \] which is an isomorphism by the unit coherence for cocartesian transport, since \(u_{0}\colon 0 \to 0\) is the identity.

This finishes the proof.

Definition 8.2.3 (Straightening). Let \(p\colon W \to [1] \times S\) be a cocartesian fibration, and denote by \(p_i\colon W_i \to S\) for \(i = 0,1\) the base change of \(p\) along the inclusion \((i,\id)\colon S \to [1] \times S\). We define the straightening of \(p\) over \([1]\) to be the cocartesian functor over \(S\) of the form Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source obtained from the cocartesian functor \(l\colon [1] \times W_0 \to W\) over \([1] \times S\) by forming the base change along \((1,\id)\colon S \to [1] \times S\). Note that \(\St(p)\) corresponds to a section \[ \sigma_{p}\colon S \to \ul{\CoCart}_S(W_0,W_1) \] of the structural functor \(\ul{\CoCart}_S(W_0,W_1) \to S\).

Remark 8.2.4. If \(S' \to S\) is any functor and if \(p\colon W \to [1] \times S\) is a cocartesian fibration, we may form the pullback Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source We obtain a pullback square Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source There are now a priori two ways of constructing a cocartesian functor \(W_0' \to W_1'\) over \(S'\): we can either apply Definition 8.2.3 directly to \(p'\), or we first apply Definition 8.2.3 to \(p\) to get a cocartesian functor \(W_0 \to W_1\) over \(S\) and then pull back along \(S' \to S\). One can show that these two functors agree. In other words, the diagram Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source is commutative.

8.2.1 Weak functoriality of straightening over \([1]\)

Given a cocartesian fibration \(W \to [2]\), we obtain functors \(W_0 \to W_1\), \(W_1 \to W_2\) and \(W_0 \to W_2\) by performing covariant transport along the three maps \(0\to 1\), \(1 \to 2\) and \(0 \to 2\) in \([2]\). We have seen in Corollary 4.5.11 that these three functors fit into a commutative triangle Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source Similarly, if the cocartesian fibration \(W \to [1]\) were pulled back along the map \([1] \to [0]\) from some functor \(W' \to [0]\), then the corresponding covariant transport functor \(W' \to W'\) is identified with the identity functor. This expresses the functoriality of covariant transport.

As we shall now see, the analogous statements still hold true over an arbitrary base \(S\).

Lemma 8.2.5. Consider a cocartesian fibration \(p'\colon W' \to S\), and let \(p\colon [1] \times W' \to [1] \times S\) be its pullback along the projection \(\pr_S\colon [1] \times S \to S\): Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source Then the straightening functor \(\St(p)\colon W' \to W'\) of \(p\) is identified with the identity of \(W'\) over \(S\).

Proof

This is clear from the fact that the dashed diagonal map in the diagram in Construction 8.2.1 may be taken to be the identity map on \([1] \times W'\).

Proposition 8.2.6. Consider a cocartesian fibration \(p\colon W \to [2] \times S\). For \(0 \leq i < j \leq 2\), define the cocartesian fibration \(p_{ij}\colon W_{ij} \to [1]_{ij} \times S\) via the following pullback square: Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source where \([1]_{ij}\) is the subcategory of \([2]\) spanned by \(i\) and \(j\). Then there is an identification \[ \St(p_{02}) = \St(p_{12}) \circ \St(p_{01}) \] of cocartesian functors \(W_0 \to W_2\) over \(S\).

Proof

The proof has two steps. We first extend the three transport constructions from the edges of \([2]\) to cocartesian functors over \([2]\times S\). We then compare the extension associated to \(0\to 2\) with the composite of the extensions associated to \(0\to 1\) and \(1\to 2\).

Via Construction 8.2.1, we obtain cocartesian functors Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source and Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source Restricting these three functors to \(\{j\} \times S \hookrightarrow [1]_{ij} \times S\) produces the three functors \(\St(p_{01})\), \(\St(p_{12})\) and \(\St(p_{02})\). We claim that these three diagrams can all be extended to cocartesian functors over \([2] \times S\) of the form Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source and Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source The map \(\overline{l}_{01}\) is obtained from \(l_{01}\) by pulling back along the map \(s_1\colon [2] \to [1]\) (given by \(0 \mapsto 0\), \(1 \mapsto 1\) and \(2 \mapsto 1\)). To obtain the map \(\overline{l}_{12}\), we write \([2]\) as a pushout of the span \([1]_{01} \leftarrow \{1\} \to [1]_{12}\), giving a pushout square Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source The map \(\overline{l}_{12}\) is then given on \(W_{01}\) by the inclusion \(W_{01} \hookrightarrow W\) and on \([1]_{12} \times W_1\) by the composite \[ [1]_{12} \times W_1 \xrightarrow{l_{12}} W_{12} \hookrightarrow W; \] this is well-defined since the restriction of both functors to \(W_1\) is the inclusion \(W_1 \hookrightarrow W\). Since both \(l_{12}\) and the inclusion preserve cocartesian morphisms, it follows that \(\overline{l}_{12}\) preserves cocartesian morphisms lying over either \([1]_{01}\) or \([1]_{12}\), from which it follows that \(\overline{l}_{12}\) is indeed a cocartesian functor over \([2] \times S\).

It remains to extend the transport associated to \(0\to 2\). The map \(\overline{l}_{02}\) is defined by finding a lift in the following commutative diagram: Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source Since the left square is a pushout square, it suffices to construct a diagonal map \([1] \to \Fun(W_0, W)\) making the top and bottom triangle commute, but such a map exists uniquely due to the fact that \(p_*\) is a cocartesian fibration. Observe that the pullback of the map \(\overline{l}_{02}\) along the inclusion \([1]_{02} \times S \hookrightarrow [2] \times S\) is indeed the map \(l_{02}\): the restriction of its curried functor \(\overline{k_{02}}\) to \([1]_{02} \hookrightarrow [2]\) is a solution of the lifting problem Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source and must hence agree with the (unique) solution \(k_{02}\).

To finish the proof, observe that the composite \(\overline{l}_{12} \circ \overline{l}_{01}\colon [2] \times W_0 \to W\) is another cocartesian functor over \([2] \times S\) that satisfies the same lifting criterion as \(\overline{l}_{02}\). By uniqueness, we thus obtain an identification \[ \overline{l}_{02} = \overline{l}_{12} \circ \overline{l}_{01}. \] Pulling back along the inclusion \(\{2\} \times S \hookrightarrow [2] \times S\) then provides the desired identification \[ \St(p_{02}) = \St(p_{12}) \circ \St(p_{01}). \]

Consequently, straightening over \([1]\) respects identities and composition. This is the coherence needed to interpret the arrows and composable arrows of a universe as functors and composable functors between the categories they classify.