Lemma 4.7. Let \(D\) be a category, let \(S\) be a class of morphisms of \(D\) which is closed under homotopy and composition, and let \(P\) be a class of objects of \(D\). Assume that every morphism in \(S\) is homotopic to a composite \(x \to p \to x'\) of two morphisms in \(S\) with \(p \in P\).

(1)

For every morphism \(s\colon x \to x'\) in \(S\) there is a functor \(F\colon \Q _{[0,1]} \to D\) with \(F(0) = x\), \(F(1) = x'\) and \(F(0 \leq 1) \simeq s\), such that \(F(a \leq b) \in S\) for all \(a < b\) and \(F(a) \in P\) for all \(0 < a < 1\).

(2)

For every sequence \(x_0 \to x_1 \to x_2 \to \cdots \) of morphisms in \(S\) there is a functor \(F\colon \Q _{\geq 0} \to D\) whose restriction to \(\N \subseteq \Q _{\geq 0}\) is equivalent to the given sequence, such that \(F(a \leq b) \in S\) for all \(a < b\) and \(F(a) \in P\) for all \(a \notin \N \). If \(D\) admits sequential colimits, then \(\colim _{\Q _{\geq 0}} F \simeq \colim _n x_n\).

Proof.

(1) The set \(T\) of dyadic rationals in \([0,1]\) is a countable dense totally ordered set with a smallest and a largest element, so it is order-isomorphic to \(\Q _{[0,1]}\) by Cantor’s back-and-forth argument; we may therefore replace \(\Q _{[0,1]}\) by \(T\), with \(0\) and \(1\) preserved. Let \(T_k = \{i/2^k \mid 0 \leq i \leq 2^k\}\), so that \(T = \bigcup _k T_k\) and hence \(N(T) = \bigcup _k N(T_k)\). Thus \(\Fun (T,D) \simeq \lim _k \Fun (T_k,D)\), and on cores this is a limit of a tower of animae. So it suffices to construct functors \(F_k\colon T_k \to D\), with \(F_k(a \leq b) \in S\) for \(a < b\) and \(F_k(a) \in P\) for \(0 < a < 1\), together with equivalences \(F_{k+1}|_{T_k} \simeq F_k\). Indeed, a point of the limit of a tower of animae is specified by points at each stage and paths between their successive images; no separate higher compatibility choices are required. As in Remark A.10, a functor out of a finite totally ordered set amounts to a composable sequence of morphisms, and two such functors are equivalent as soon as they agree on objects and their consecutive morphisms are homotopic. Let \(F_0\) be given by \(s\). Given \(F_k\), factor each morphism \(F_k(a \leq a')\) between consecutive elements \(a < a'\) of \(T_k\) as a composite of two morphisms in \(S\) through an object of \(P\), and let \(F_{k+1}\) be the resulting functor on \(T_{k+1}\). Then \(F_{k+1}|_{T_k}\) and \(F_k\) agree on objects, and their consecutive morphisms are homotopic, so \(F_{k+1}|_{T_k} \simeq F_k\). Since \(S\) is closed under composition, every \(F_{k+1}(a \leq b)\) with \(a < b\) is in \(S\).

(2) Apply the construction of (1) simultaneously to all morphisms \(x_n \to x_{n+1}\): on the dyadic rationals in \([0,\infty )\), which are the union of the subsets \(2^{-k}\N \), we refine the given sequence on \(\N = 2^{0}\N \) by factoring consecutive morphisms as before. The set of dyadic rationals in \([0,\infty )\) is order-isomorphic to \(\Q _{\geq 0}\) by an isomorphism fixing \(\N \) (apply the back-and-forth argument to each interval \([n,n+1]\)). Finally, \(\N \subseteq \Q _{\geq 0}\) is cofinal, so the colimits agree by Lemma A.7. □