Given associative rings \(A\) and \(B\), we may consider \((A,B)\)-bimodules: abelian groups equipped with compatible left \(A\)-module and right \(B\)-module structures. For another associative ring \(D\), the relative tensor product \(M \otimes _B N\) of an \((A,B)\)-bimodule \(M\) and a \((B,D)\)-bimodule \(N\) is canonically an \((A,D)\)-bimodule. We now construct relative tensor products in general monoidal \(\infty \)-categories using the two-sided bar construction, and explain their associativity and unit isomorphisms. For commutative algebras in a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category, this gives a symmetric monoidal structure on modules, compatible with extension of scalars.
17.2.1 Bimodules
We start by extending the notion of bimodules to the \(\infty \)-categorical setting.
Definition 17.2.1. We define a colored operad \(\oBMod \). It has three colors: \(\fa _-\), \(\fa _+\) and \(\fm \). The multimorphism sets \(\oBMod (\{X_i\}_{i \in I}; Y)\) are then given as follows:
- If \(Y = \fa _-\), then this set is empty unless \(X_i = \fa _-\) for all \(i \in I\), in which case it is the set of linear orders on \(I\);
- If \(Y = \fa _+\), then this set is empty unless \(X_i = \fa _+\) for all \(i \in I\), in which case it is the set of linear orders on \(I\);
- If \(Y = \fm \), then this set is the set of linear orders \(\{i_1 < i_2 < \dots < i_n\}\) on \(I\) with the following property: there exists precisely one index \(i_k \in I\) such that \(X_{i_k} = \fm \), \(X_{i_j} = \fa _-\) for \(j < k\) and \(X_{i_j} = \fa _+\) for \(j > k\).
Composition in \(\oBMod \) is given by composition of linear orders.
By Proposition 14.2.4, this colored operad canonically determines the \(\infty \)-operad \(\oBMod \) used below.
Observation 17.2.2. We identify \(\oLMod \) with the full suboperad of \(\oBMod \) spanned by the colors \(\fa _-\) and \(\fm \), and let \(\oRMod \subseteq \oBMod \) denote the full suboperad spanned by \(\fm \) and \(\fa _+\). Thus \(\oBMod \) contains two copies of \(\Assoc \), on \(\fa _-\) and \(\fa _+\), a copy of \(\Triv \) on \(\fm \), and the full suboperads \(\oLMod \) and \(\oRMod \). There is also an operad map \[ \oBMod \longrightarrow \Assoc \] which sends all three colors to \(\fa \) and forgets the restrictions on the linear orders. Its restrictions to \(\oLMod \) and \(\oRMod \) are the usual collapse maps to \(\Assoc \).
Notation 17.2.3. For a monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\) we write \[ \RMod (C) := \Alg _{\oRMod }(C) \qquadtext { and } \BMod (C) := \Alg _{\oBMod }(C). \] Similarly, if \(A\) and \(B\) are associative algebras in \(C\), we write \[ \RMod _B(C) \quad \qquadtext {and}\quad {}_A\BMod _B(C) \] for the fibers over \(B\) and \((A,B)\) of the two forgetful functors \(\fa _+^*\colon \RMod (C) \to \Alg (C)\) and \((\fa _-^*, \fa _+^*)\colon \BMod (C) \to \Alg (C) \times \Alg (C)\), respectively.
The results of the preceding section apply equally to right modules, with right tensorings in place of left tensorings. In particular, Proposition 17.1.16, Proposition 17.1.17, Corollary 17.1.18 have analogous statements for right modules.
Observation 17.2.4. Suppose that \(C\) is symmetric monoidal. There are equivalences of \(\infty \)-operads \[ \rev \colon \Assoc \iso \Assoc , \qquad \rev \colon \oLMod \iso \oRMod \qquadtext { and } \rev \colon \oBMod \iso \oBMod \] given on objects by \(\fa \mapsto \fa \), \(\fa _- \mapsto \fa _+\), \(\fa _+ \mapsto \fa _-\) and \(\fm \mapsto \fm \), and on multimorphisms by reversing the order on the finite set. The map \(\Assoc \to \Comm \) coequalizes \(\rev \) and the identity, so the symmetric monoidal structure on \(C\) canonically identifies the two induced monoidal structures. Consequently, restriction along \(\rev \) defines an endofunctor \(\rev ^*\colon \Alg (C) \to \Alg (C)\). It sends an associative algebra \(A\) to its opposite algebra, denoted \(A^{\rev }\), which has the same underlying object but whose multiplication is given by \[ A \otimes A \iso A \otimes A \xrightarrow {m_A} A, \] where the first map is the swap map. For associative algebras \(A\) and \(B\) we thus get equivalences \[ \LMod _A(C) \iso \RMod _{A^{\rev }}(C) \qquadtext { and } {}_A\BMod _B(C) \iso {}_{B^{\rev }}\BMod _{A^{\rev }}(C). \]
Observation 17.2.5. There is an operad map \(\oBMod \to \oMod \) which sends \(\fm \) to \(\fm \) and sends both \(\fa _-\) and \(\fa _+\) to \(\fa \). Composing it with the inclusion \(\oLMod \hookrightarrow \oBMod \) gives the canonical map \(\oLMod \to \oMod \), and similarly for \(\oRMod \). It follows that for a commutative algebra \(A\) in a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\), restriction along these operad maps defines forgetful functors
Here the left diagonal equivalence is the one from Proposition 17.1.7. The right one follows by applying Observation 17.2.4, since a commutative algebra is canonically isomorphic to its opposite algebra.
An \((A,B)\)-bimodule \(M\) has structure maps \[ A^{\otimes n} \otimes M \otimes B^{\otimes m} \to M \] for all \(n,m\geq 0\), with coherent compatibility with the multiplications and units of \(A\) and \(B\). Setting \(m=0\) or \(n=0\) gives the left and right actions. Their compatibility can be expressed by regarding \(M\) as a left \(A\)-module in \(\RMod _B(C)\), or as a right \(B\)-module in \(\LMod _A(C)\):
Theorem 17.2.6 ([Lurie (2017), Theorem 4.3.2.7]). Let \(A\) and \(B\) be associative algebras in a monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\).
- (1)
-
The \(\infty \)-category \(\RMod _B(C)\) is left tensored over \(C\), and there is an equivalence \[ {}_A\BMod _B(C) \simeq \LMod _A(\RMod _B(C)); \]
- (2)
-
The \(\infty \)-category \(\LMod _A(C)\) is right tensored over \(C\), and there is an equivalence \[ {}_A\BMod _B(C) \simeq \RMod _B(\LMod _A(C)). \]
Corollary 17.2.7. For associative algebras \(A\) and \(B\) in \(C\), there are equivalences \[ {}_A\BMod _{\unit }(C) \iso \LMod _A(C) \qquadtext { and } {}_{\unit }\BMod _B(C) \iso \RMod _B(C). \]
Proof. In light of the equivalences \(\RMod _{\unit }(C) \iso C\) and \(\LMod _{\unit }(C) \iso C\) from Corollary 17.1.15, this follows directly from the previous theorem. □
17.2.2 The relative tensor product
Let \(B\) be a discrete associative ring. A central construction in the theory of modules is the relative tensor product: Given a right \(B\)-module \(M\) and a left \(B\)-module \(N\), their relative tensor product \(M \otimes _B N\) is obtained as the quotient of \(M \otimes N\) by identifying \(mb \otimes n\) with \(m \otimes bn\) for all \(m \in M\), \(n \in N\) and \(b \in B\). In other words, \(M \otimes _B N\) is the coequalizer of the following diagram: \[ M \otimes B \otimes N \rightrightarrows M \otimes N. \] In the \(\infty \)-categorical setting, we replace this coequalizer by the geometric realization of the two-sided bar construction. We first describe its objects, face maps, and degeneracies. In Remark 17.2.10, we explain how to construct this simplicial object using \(\infty \)-operads, following [Lurie (2017), Construction 4.4.2.7].
Construction 17.2.8 (Bar construction). Let \(B\) be an associative algebra in a monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\), let \(M\) be a right \(B\)-module, and let \(N\) be a left \(B\)-module. The two-sided bar construction for \(M\) and \(N\) over \(B\), denoted \(\Bar _B(M,N)_{\bullet }\), is a simplicial object in \(C\) described as follows:
- In degree \([n] \in \simp \catop \), it is given by \(\Bar _B(M,N)_n := M \otimes B^{\otimes n} \otimes N\);
-
The face maps \(d_i \colon \Bar _B(M,N)_n \to \Bar _B(M,N)_{n-1}\) are given by:
- \(d_0 = \act _M \otimes \id _{B^{\otimes (n-1)}} \otimes \id _N \colon M \otimes B \otimes B^{\otimes (n-1)} \otimes N \to M \otimes B^{\otimes (n-1)} \otimes N\).
- For \(0 < i < n\), \(d_i\) is induced by the multiplication map \(m\colon B \otimes B \to B\) on the \(i\)-th and \((i+1)\)-th factors of \(B^{\otimes n}\).
- \(d_n = \id _M \otimes \id _{B^{\otimes (n-1)}} \otimes \act _N \colon M \otimes B^{\otimes (n-1)} \otimes B \otimes N \to M \otimes B^{\otimes (n-1)} \otimes N\).
- The degeneracy maps \(s_i \colon \Bar _B(M,N)_n \to \Bar _B(M,N)_{n+1}\) are induced by inserting the unit \(e\colon \unit \to B\) at the \((i+1)\)-th position.
Definition 17.2.9 (Relative tensor product). Let \(C\) be a monoidal \(\infty \)-category. Assume that \(C\) admits geometric realizations and that the tensor product \(- \otimes -\colon C \times C \to C\) preserves geometric realizations in both variables. For an associative algebra \(B\), a right \(B\)-module \(M\) and a left \(B\)-module \(N\), their relative tensor product is the object of \(C\) given by the geometric realization of the bar construction: \[ M \otimes _B N := \abs {\Bar _B(M,N)_{\bullet }} = \colim _{[n] \in \simp \catop } \Bar _B(M,N)_n. \] More generally, let \(A,B,D\in \Alg (C)\). If \(M\in {}_A\BMod _B(C)\) and \(N\in {}_B\BMod _D(C)\), then the bar construction lifts to a simplicial object of \({}_A\BMod _D(C)\). Geometric realizations of bimodules are created on underlying objects by [Lurie (2017), Proposition 4.3.3.9], so its realization defines an \((A,D)\)-bimodule \[ M\otimes _BN\in {}_A\BMod _D(C). \]
Remark 17.2.10. To formally construct \(\Bar _B(M,N)_{\bullet }\), Lurie defines in [Lurie (2017), Definition 4.4.1.1] an \(\infty \)-operad \(\oTens _2\) and shows in [Lurie (2017), Proposition 4.4.1.11] that it sits in a pushout square of \(\infty \)-operads as follows:
In particular, for a monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\), the \(\infty \)-operad \(\oTens _2\) encodes the data of algebras \(A,B,D\in \Alg (C)\), an \((A,B)\)-bimodule \(M\), and a \((B,D)\)-bimodule \(N\): there is a pullback square
For this reason, we denote the five colors of \(\oTens _2\) by \(\fa \), \(\fm \), \(\fb \), \(\fn \) and \(\fc \).
Lurie’s construction supplies a functor \[ \BCut \colon \simp \catop \longrightarrow \oTens _2^{\otimes } \] which sends \([n]\) to the tuple \((\fm ,\fb ,\fb ,\dots ,\fb ,\fn )\) encoding \(M\otimes B^{\otimes n}\otimes N\). It can be described as the pullback, in \(\oTens _2^{\otimes }\), of the following cospan:
Both maps are inert, and their pullback is the indicated tuple. The compatibility of these pullbacks with the simplicial operators is part of [Lurie (2017), Construction 4.4.2.7].
Now, given an \((A,B)\)-bimodule \(M\) and a \((B,D)\)-bimodule \(N\), we may think of this data as defining a \(\oTens _2\)-algebra in \(C\), which in particular defines a functor \(\oTens _2^{\otimes } \to C^{\otimes }\). Precomposing this with \(\BCut \) gives a functor \(\simp \catop \to C^{\otimes }\). One can check that this actually factors through the active morphisms. Using cocartesian transport, we can then turn this into the desired functor \(\Bar _B(M,N)_{\bullet }\colon \simp \catop \to C\).
The construction of Remark 17.2.10 also applies to a left \(C\)-tensored \(\infty \)-category \(D\): the full suboperad of \(\oTens _2\) on \(\fm ,\fb ,\fn \) maps to \(\oLMod \) by sending these colors to \(\fa ,\fa ,\fm \), respectively, and preserving the order of inputs, so we may use the cocartesian transport of the left tensoring. For \(M\in \RMod _B(C)\) and \(N\in \LMod _B(D)\), we write \(M\otimes _BN\) for the realization in \(D\) of the bar construction with terms \(M\otimes B^{\otimes n}\otimes N\), whenever it exists. Inserting the unit in the leftmost position gives extra degeneracies on the augmented bar construction \(\Bar _B(B,N)_\bullet \to N\), so \(B\otimes _BN\simeq N\) by Definition 5.2.3.
Lemma 17.2.11 (Colimits and relative tensor products). Let \(C\) be a cocomplete monoidal \(\infty \)-category, and let \(D\) be a cocomplete \(\infty \)-category left-tensored over \(C\). Suppose that the tensor product on \(C\) and the action on \(D\) preserve small colimits separately in both variables. For every \(B\in \Alg (C)\), the relative tensor product \[ -\otimes _B-\colon \RMod _B(C)\times \LMod _B(D)\longrightarrow D \] preserves small colimits separately in both variables. The same holds for relative tensor products of bimodules in \(C\).
Proof. By Proposition 17.1.16 and its right-module version, colimits of modules are computed on underlying objects. Thus each term \(M\otimes B^{\otimes n}\otimes N\) preserves small colimits separately in \(M\) and \(N\). Since colimits commute with geometric realizations, the same holds for \(M\otimes _BN\). The bimodule case follows by the same argument, since Theorem 17.2.6 identifies bimodules with iterated modules, whose colimits are again computed on underlying objects. □
Proposition 17.2.12. Let \(C\) and \(D\) be monoidal \(\infty \)-categories which admit geometric realizations and whose tensor products preserve geometric realizations separately in both variables. If \(F\colon C\to D\) is a monoidal functor which preserves geometric realizations, then for every associative algebra \(B\in \Alg (C)\), right \(B\)-module \(M\), and left \(B\)-module \(N\), there is a natural isomorphism \[ F(M)\otimes _{F(B)}F(N)\iso F(M\otimes _BN). \]
Proof. The monoidal structure on \(F\), together with the functorial construction of the coherent bar diagram from Remark 17.2.10, gives an isomorphism of simplicial objects \[ \Bar _{F(B)}(F(M),F(N))_{\bullet }\iso F(\Bar _B(M,N)_{\bullet }). \] Taking geometric realizations and using that \(F\) preserves them gives the asserted isomorphism. □
The relative tensor product is functorial in the algebras and bimodules, giving a functor \[ \BMod (C) \times _{\Alg (C)} \BMod (C) \longrightarrow \BMod (C), \] where the fiber product matches the right algebra of the first bimodule with the left algebra of the second. Relative tensor products are coherently associative and unital. In particular, for bimodules \({}_AM_B\), \({}_BN_C\) and \({}_CP_D\) there is a natural isomorphism \[ (M \otimes _B N) \otimes _C P \simeq M \otimes _B (N \otimes _C P) \qin {}_A\BMod _D(C). \] For a bimodule \({}_AM_B\), the regular bimodules \(A\) and \(B\) act as units: \[ A \otimes _A M \simeq M \qquadtext { and } M \otimes _B B \simeq M \qin {}_A\BMod _B(C). \] These statements, including their coherent compatibility, are proved in [Lurie (2017), Propositions 4.4.3.14 and 4.4.3.16]. To describe the resulting extension-of-scalars adjunction, we first introduce restriction of scalars.
Proposition 17.2.13 (Restriction of scalars, [Lurie (2017), Corollary 4.2.3.2]). Let \(D\) be left-tensored over a monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\). The restriction functor \[ \fa ^*\colon \LMod (D)\longrightarrow \Alg (C) \] is a cartesian fibration. A morphism in \(\LMod (D)\) is \(\fa ^*\)-cartesian if and only if its underlying morphism in \(D\) is an isomorphism. Consequently, a morphism \(f\colon A\to B\) of associative algebras induces a restriction-of-scalars functor \[ f_*\colon \LMod _B(D)\longrightarrow \LMod _A(D) \] which does not change the underlying object of \(D\).
Under the hypotheses used to construct relative tensor products, restriction of scalars has the following left adjoint.
Proposition 17.2.14 (Extension of scalars). Let \(C\) be a monoidal \(\infty \)-category which admits geometric realizations and whose tensor product preserves geometric realizations separately in both variables. For every morphism \(f\colon A\to B\) in \(\Alg (C)\), the restriction functor from Proposition 17.2.13 \[ f_*\colon \LMod _B(C)\longrightarrow \LMod _A(C) \] admits a left adjoint given by extension of scalars: \[ f^*:=B\otimes _A-\colon \LMod _A(C)\longrightarrow \LMod _B(C). \] Analogously, restriction from right \(B\)-modules to right \(A\)-modules admits the left adjoint \(-\otimes _A B\).
Proof. The morphism \(f\) makes every left \(B\)-module into a left \(A\)-module and makes \(B\) into a \((B,A)\)-bimodule. For a left \(A\)-module \(M\) and a left \(B\)-module \(N\), an \(A\)-linear morphism \(g\colon M\to f_*N\) induces the \(B\)-linear composite \[ B\otimes _A M\xrightarrow {\id _B\otimes _A g}B\otimes _A f_*N\longrightarrow N, \] where the final map is induced by the \(B\)-action on \(N\). Conversely, precomposition with \[ M\iso A\otimes _A M\xrightarrow {f\otimes _A\id _M}B\otimes _A M \] turns every \(B\)-linear morphism \(B\otimes _A M\to N\) into an \(A\)-linear morphism \(M\to f_*N\). These assignments arise from the displayed natural transformations, so they define maps between the corresponding mapping animae. Unitality and associativity of relative tensor products show that these maps are inverse. The argument for right modules is analogous. □
If all the algebras involved are a fixed algebra \(A\), the relative tensor product takes the form of a functor \[ - \otimes _A - \colon {}_A\BMod _A(C) \times {}_A\BMod _A(C) \to {}_A\BMod _A(C) \] which satisfies associativity and unitality. Lurie shows that this assembles into a monoidal structure on \({}_A\BMod _A(C)\):
Proposition 17.2.15 ([Lurie (2017), Proposition 4.4.3.12]). Let \(C\) be a monoidal \(\infty \)-category. Assume that \(C\) admits geometric realizations and that the tensor product \(- \otimes -\colon C \times C \to C\) preserves geometric realizations in both variables. For an associative algebra \(A\), there exists a monoidal structure on \({}_A\BMod _A(C)\) given by the relative tensor product over \(A\), with unit \(A\).
17.2.3 Modules over commutative algebras
Let \(R\) be a discrete commutative ring. Given \(R\)-modules \(M\) and \(N\), the relative tensor product \(M \otimes _R N\) is again an \(R\)-module, with the scalar multiplication given by \(r(m \otimes n) = rm \otimes n = m \otimes rn\). In fact, the construction \((M,N) \mapsto M \otimes _R N\) equips the category \(\Mod _R(\Ab )\) of \(R\)-modules with a symmetric monoidal structure. The analogous statement also holds in the \(\infty \)-categorical setting:
Theorem 17.2.16 ([Lurie (2017), Theorem 4.5.2.1]). Let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. Assume that \(C\) admits geometric realizations and that the tensor product of \(C\) preserves geometric realizations in both variables. Let \(R\) be a commutative algebra in \(C\). Then:
- (1)
-
The \(\infty \)-category \(\Mod _R(C)\) admits a symmetric monoidal structure with unit \(R\).
- (2)
-
The functor \(\Mod _R(C) \to {}_R\BMod _R(C)\) from Observation 17.2.5 refines to a monoidal functor, where the target has the monoidal structure from Proposition 17.2.15.
In particular, the tensor product on \(\Mod _R(C)\) is given as the following composite: \[ \begin {aligned} \Mod _R(C) \times \Mod _R(C) &\longrightarrow {}_R\BMod _R(C) \times {}_R\BMod _R(C) \\ &\xrightarrow {- \otimes _R -} {}_R\BMod _R(C) \longrightarrow \LMod _R(C) \iso \Mod _R(C). \end {aligned} \]
Proposition 17.2.17 ([Lurie (2017), Theorem 5.1.4.10 and Corollary 3.4.1.7]). Let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. Assume that \(C\) admits geometric realizations and that the tensor product of \(C\) preserves geometric realizations in both variables. Let \(R\) be a commutative algebra in \(C\). The forgetful functor \(\CAlg (\Mod _R(C))\to \CAlg (C)\) lifts to an equivalence of \(\infty \)-categories \[ \CAlg (\Mod _R(C))\iso \CAlg (C)_{R/}. \]
Warning 17.2.18. There is no analogous equivalence \(\Alg (\Mod _R(C))\simeq \Alg (C)_{R/}\). Already for ordinary rings, the structure map from \(R\) to an associative algebra in \(\Mod _R(C)\) is central, whereas an arbitrary morphism from \(R\) to an associative algebra need not have central image; see also [Lurie (2017), Warning 7.1.3.9].
Corollary 17.2.19 (Localization of a commutative base algebra). Let \(R\in \CAlg (C)\) be as in Theorem 17.2.16, and let \[ L\colon \Mod _R(C)\rightleftarrows D\colon i \] be a symmetric monoidal Bousfield localization as in Proposition 14.7.2. Then the local \(R\)-module \(L(R)\) canonically underlies a commutative algebra in \(C\) equipped with a morphism \(R\to L(R)\). It is initial among commutative algebras under \(R\) whose underlying \(R\)-modules are local.
Proof. As the monoidal unit of \(\Mod _R(C)\), the algebra \(R\) is initial in \(\CAlg (\Mod _R(C))\). By Corollary 14.7.4, its reflection \(L(R)\) is the initial object of \(\CAlg (D)\), and the essential image of \[ \CAlg (D)\hookrightarrow \CAlg (\Mod _R(C)) \] consists of the commutative algebras with local underlying \(R\)-module. By Proposition 17.2.17, these are precisely the commutative algebras under \(R\) whose underlying \(R\)-modules are local. □
When \(C\) is presentably symmetric monoidal, the symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(\Mod _R(C)\) is again presentably symmetric monoidal: its underlying category is presentable by Proposition 17.1.7, Proposition 17.1.17, and its relative tensor product preserves colimits separately in each variable by Lemma 17.2.11. It is therefore closed by Proposition 16.2.9; in particular, each functor \(-\otimes _RN\) admits an internal right adjoint \(\iHom _R(N,-)\).
17.2.4 Restriction and extension of scalars
For a morphism \(f\colon R\to S\) of commutative algebras, Proposition 17.2.14 gives extension of scalars \(f^*=S\otimes _R-\) left adjoint to restriction of scalars \(f_*\).1 Extension of scalars is also symmetric monoidal. The following theorem constructs this refinement functorially in the algebra.
Theorem 17.2.20 ([Lurie (2017), Theorem 4.5.3.1]). Let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. Assume that \(C\) admits geometric realizations and that the tensor product \(\otimes \colon C \times C \to C\) preserves geometric realizations in both variables separately. Then there exists a cocartesian fibration \[ p\colon \Mod (C)^{\otimes } \to \CAlg (C) \times \Span (\Fin ) \] such that for every commutative algebra \(R\) the pullback along \(\{R\} \times \Span (\Fin ) \hookrightarrow \CAlg (C) \times \Span (\Fin )\) is the cocartesian fibration \[ p_R\colon \Mod _R(C)^{\otimes } \to \Span (\Fin ) \] encoding the symmetric monoidal structure on \(\Mod _R(C)\) from Theorem 17.2.16. Cocartesian transport along \((f,\id _{\lra {1}})\) for a morphism \(f\colon R\to S\) in \(\CAlg (C)\) is the extension-of-scalars functor \(S\otimes _R-\colon \Mod _R(C)\to \Mod _S(C)\).
By straightening-unstraightening, the cocartesian fibration \(p\) corresponds to a functor \[ \Str ^{\cc }\colon \CAlg (C) \times \Span (\Fin ) \to \Cat _{\infty } \] which preserves finite products in the second variable. By currying, this may equivalently be encoded as a functor \[ \CAlg (C) \to \Fun ^{\times }(\Span (\Fin ),\Cat _\infty ) = \Cat _{\infty }^{\otimes } \] from commutative algebras in \(C\) to symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-categories. We record the resulting functoriality of module categories.
Corollary 17.2.21 (Extension of scalars). In the situation of Theorem 17.2.20, every morphism \(f\colon R\to S\) in \(\CAlg (C)\) induces a symmetric monoidal functor \[ f^*\colon \Mod _R(C) \longrightarrow \Mod _S(C), \] functorially in \(f\). Its underlying functor is \(S\otimes _R-\) from Proposition 17.2.14. For \(R=\unit \), the resulting symmetric monoidal functor \[ C \simeq \Mod _{\unit }(C) \longrightarrow \Mod _S(C) \] is the free module functor \(F_S\colon C \to \Mod _S(C)\) from Proposition 17.1.14.
For morphisms of commutative ring spectra, the symmetric monoidal extension-of-scalars functor of Corollary 17.2.21 fits into a triple of adjoints.
Proposition 17.2.22. Let \(f\colon R \to S\) be a morphism of commutative ring spectra.
- (1)
-
The functor \(f^*\colon \Mod _R \to \Mod _S\) admits a right adjoint \[ f_*\colon \Mod _S \to \Mod _R. \] For every \(S\)-module \(M\), the underlying spectrum of \(f_*(M)\) is naturally isomorphic to the underlying spectrum of \(M\).
- (2)
-
The functor \(f_*\colon \Mod _S \to \Mod _R\) admits a further right adjoint \[ \ihom _R(S,-)\colon \Mod _R \to \Mod _S \] whose underlying \(R\)-module is the internal hom: it satisfies \(f_*\ihom _R(S,-) \simeq \iHom _R(S,-)\) as functors \(\Mod _R \to \Mod _R\).
Proof. Part (1) is the extension-of-scalars adjunction of Proposition 17.2.14, transported along Proposition 17.1.7. Its right adjoint is restriction of scalars, which leaves the underlying spectrum unchanged.
For part (2), the adjoint functor theorem applies once more because \(f_*\) preserves colimits. This can be checked on underlying spectra, since restriction of scalars does not change them and the forgetful functors create colimits. The identification \(f_*\ihom _R(S,-) \simeq \iHom _R(S,-)\) may be checked after passing to left adjoints, where it is the identity \[ f_*f^*\simeq S\otimes _R-\colon \Mod _R\longrightarrow \Mod _R. \qedhere \] □
Remark 17.2.23. Restriction of scalars gives a contravariant functor \[ \CAlg (\Sp )\catop \longrightarrow \Cat _\infty , \qquad A\longmapsto \Mod _A,\quad f\longmapsto f_*. \] Indeed, the cocartesian fibration \(\Mod (\Sp )\to \CAlg (\Sp )\) of Theorem 17.2.20 is also cartesian: its transport functors admit right adjoints by Proposition 17.2.22(1), so Lemma 24.1.20 applies. Its cartesian transport is restriction of scalars.