Proposition 6.5.12. Consider a commutative diagram Commutative diagram; see the PDF for its LaTeX source of categories, and assume that the functors \(p,q,r\) are cocartesian fibrations and \(g\) and \(h\) are cocartesian functors over \(S\).

  1. (1) The induced functor \(C \times_E D \to S\) is a cocartesian fibration;

  2. (2) The projection functors \(\pr_1\) and \(\pr_2\) are cocartesian functors over \(S\);

  3. (3) For every other cocartesian fibration \(T \to S\) and cocartesian functors \(t_C\colon T \to C\) and \(t_D\colon T \to D\) over \(S\) equipped with an identification \(g t_C = h t_D\) over \(S\), the induced functor \((t_C,t_D)\colon T \to C \times_E D\) is a cocartesian functor over \(S\).

Proof

Write \(\pi\colon C\times_E D\to S\) for the induced functor. An object of the pullback consists of objects \(x\) of \(C\) and \(y\) of \(D\) together with a specified identification \(g(x) = h(y)\). Let \(w\colon s_0\to s_1\) be a morphism in \(S\), and choose \(p\)- and \(q\)-cocartesian lifts \[ u\colon x_0\to x_1 \qquadtext{and} \qquad v\colon y_0\to y_1 \] of \(w\). Since \(g\) and \(h\) are cocartesian functors, \(g(u)\) and \(h(v)\) are \(r\)-cocartesian. Their sources are identified by the pullback datum, so uniqueness of cocartesian lifts supplies a unique identification \(g(x_1) = h(y_1)\) compatible with \(g(u)\) and \(h(v)\). Hence \((u,v)\) defines a morphism in \(C\times_E D\).

We verify the local universal property of \((u,v)\). Consider a compatible pair of morphisms from \((x_0,y_0)\) to an object \((x',y')\) over \(s_1\) whose image under \(\pi\) is \(w\). The universal properties of \(u\) and \(v\) give unique vertical factorizations \(x_1\to x'\) and \(y_1\to y'\). Their images in \(E\) are compatible: after precomposition with the \(r\)-cocartesian morphisms \(g(u)\) and \(h(v)\), the required compatibility is exactly that of the original pair, and the universal property of these \(r\)-cocartesian morphisms detects the compatibility uniquely. Thus \((u,v)\) is locally \(\pi\)-cocartesian.

Now let \(a\) be any locally \(\pi\)-cocartesian lift of \(w\) with source \((x_0,y_0)\). Comparing \(a\) with the componentwise lift just constructed, uniqueness of locally \(\pi\)-cocartesian lifts gives an isomorphism between their targets in the fiber over \(s_1\). Hence the projections of \(a\) are \(p\)- and \(q\)-cocartesian. We have proved that the locally \(\pi\)-cocartesian morphisms are precisely the compatible pairs of \(p\)- and \(q\)-cocartesian morphisms. Such pairs are stable under composition, so Proposition 6.5.4 implies that \(\pi\) is a cocartesian fibration. The same characterization shows that both projections preserve cocartesian morphisms, and hence are cocartesian functors.

Finally, let \(T\to S\) and \((t_C,t_D)\) be as in (3). A cocartesian morphism of \(T\) is sent by \(t_C\) and \(t_D\) to a compatible pair of \(p\)- and \(q\)-cocartesian morphisms. By the characterization just proved, its image in \(C\times_E D\) is \(\pi\)-cocartesian. Hence \((t_C,t_D)\) is a cocartesian functor over \(S\).

From Section 6.5, Pointwise and fiberwise criteria for fibrations.