Let \(\Oo \) be a colored operad and let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal 1-category. Recall that an \(\Oo \)-algebra in \(C\) is defined as an operad map \(\Oo \to \Mm _C\) into the multimorphism operad of \(C\), whose multimorphisms are given by \[ \Mm _C(\{x_i\}_{i \in I};y) \quad := \quad \Hom _C(\bigotimes _{i \in I} x_i,y); \] see Definition 12.2.10. The goal of this section is to define the analogous notion of algebras over \(\infty \)-operads in the \(\infty \)-categorical setting.
14.4.1 Symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-categories as \(\infty \)-operads
We start by constructing the multimorphism operad \(\Mm _C\) of a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\). Recall from Definition 8.1.1 that a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category is a commutative monoid in \(\Cat _{\infty }\), i.e. a finite-product-preserving functor \(C\colon \Span (\Fin ) \to \Cat _{\infty }\). These naturally form an \(\infty \)-category that we denote by \[ \Cat ^{\otimes }_{\infty } \quad := \quad \CMon (\Cat _{\infty }). \]
Since the opposite-category involution \((-)\catop \colon \Cat _{\infty }\to \Cat _{\infty }\) preserves finite products, postcomposition with it defines an involution on \(\Cat ^{\otimes }_{\infty }\). For a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \((C,\otimes )\), its image under this involution is called the opposite symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category and is denoted \((C,\otimes )\catop \).
Given symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-categories \(C\) and \(D\), write \(\Map ^{\otimes }(C,D)\) for their hom anima in \(\Cat ^{\otimes }_{\infty }\).
Example 14.4.1 (Terminal \(\infty \)-category). The terminal \(\infty \)-category \(*\) admits a unique symmetric monoidal structure, given by the constant functor \(\Span (\Fin ) \to \Cat _{\infty }, S \mapsto *\).
Example 14.4.2 (Pointwise monoidal structure). If \(C\) is a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category and \(I\) is an \(\infty \)-category, then \(\Fun (I,C)\) admits a symmetric monoidal structure, called the pointwise monoidal structure. It is given by the composite \[ \Span (\Fin ) \xrightarrow {(C,\otimes )} \Cat _{\infty } \xrightarrow {\Fun (I,-)} \Cat _{\infty }. \] This is functorial in both \(I\) and \(C\), resulting in a functor \[ \Fun (-,-)\colon \Cat _{\infty }\catop \times \Cat _{\infty }^{\otimes } \to \Cat _{\infty }^{\otimes }. \]
The symmetric monoidal functors and their monoidal natural transformations themselves form an \(\infty \)-category:
Definition 14.4.3. Let \(C\) and \(D\) be symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-categories. We define \(\Fun ^{\otimes }(C,D)\) to be the \(\infty \)-category whose associated complete Segal anima is \[ N(\Fun ^{\otimes }(C,D))_n := \Map ^{\otimes }(C,\Fun ([n],D)), \] where \(\Fun ([n],D)\) carries the pointwise symmetric monoidal structure. This is a complete Segal anima because \(\Map ^{\otimes }(C,-)\) preserves limits; see Proposition 1.8.7.
Given a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\colon \Span (\Fin ) \to \Cat _{\infty }\), we may unstraighten this to a cocartesian fibration \(p_C\colon C^{\otimes } \to \Span (\Fin )\). The next result implies that this is always an \(\infty \)-operad.
Lemma 14.4.4. Let \(p_{\Oo }\colon \Oo ^{\otimes } \to \Span (\Fin )\) be a cocartesian fibration. Then \((\Oo ^{\otimes },p_{\Oo })\) is an \(\infty \)-operad if and only if the cocartesian straightening of \(p_{\Oo }\) \[ \Str ^{\cc }(p_{\Oo })\colon \Span (\Fin ) \to \Cat _{\infty } \] preserves finite products.
Proof. We check conditions (i)–(iii) of Proposition 14.1.12. Condition (i) is part of the assumption on \(p_{\Oo }\). Since the spans \(\rho _i\colon I \hookleftarrow \{i\} \xrightarrow {=} \{i\}\) exhibit \(I\) as the product of the one-element sets in \(\Span (\Fin )\), condition (ii) is equivalent to preservation of finite products by \(\Str ^{\cc }(p_{\Oo })\).
Assume (ii), and let \(Y\to Y_j\) be cocartesian lifts of the projections \(\rho _j\) for \(Y\in \Oo ^{\otimes }_J\). For \(X\in \Oo ^{\otimes }_I\) and a span \(\alpha \colon I\to J\), we have \begin {align*} \Hom ^{\alpha }_{\Oo ^{\otimes }}(X,Y) &\simeq \Hom _{\Oo ^{\otimes }_J}(\alpha _!X,Y) \\ &\simeq \prod _{j\in J}\Hom _{\Oo ^{\otimes }_{\{j\}}}((\rho _j)_!\alpha _!X,Y_j) \\ &\simeq \prod _{j\in J}\Hom ^{\rho _j\circ \alpha }_{\Oo ^{\otimes }}(X,Y_j). \end {align*}
The first and last isomorphisms follow from the universal property of cocartesian transport, and the middle one from (ii). Compatibility of cocartesian transport with composition identifies this composite with the map induced by the \(Y\to Y_j\). Thus Lemma 14.1.13 gives (iii). □
Definition 14.4.5. Given a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category \(C\), we denote its cocartesian unstraightening by \[ C^{\otimes } \quad := \quad \Un ^{\cc }(C\colon \Span (\Fin ) \to \Cat _{\infty }). \] By the previous lemma, the resulting cocartesian fibration \(p_C\colon C^{\otimes } \to \Span (\Fin )\) defines an \(\infty \)-operad, which we will denote by \(\Mm _C := (C^{\otimes },p_C)\) and refer to as the multimorphism operad associated to \(C\). By functoriality of unstraightening, this defines a functor \[ \Mm \colon \Cat _{\infty }^{\otimes } \to \Op _{\infty }. \] Morphisms in its essential image are studied in the next section.
Lemma 14.4.6. Given \(C \in \Cat _{\infty }^{\otimes }\) and objects \(x_1, \dots , x_n, y \in C^{\simeq }\), there is a natural equivalence \[ \Mm _C((x_1, \dots , x_n);y) \simeq \Hom _C(x_1\otimes \dots \otimes x_n,y). \]
Proof. Let \(\alpha \) denote the active span \(\lra {n}\xleftarrow {=}\lra {n}\to \lra {1}\). Cocartesian transport along \(\alpha \) sends \((x_1,\dots ,x_n)\) to \(x_1\otimes \dots \otimes x_n\). The universal property of this cocartesian lift gives \[ \Hom ^{\alpha }_{C^{\otimes }}((x_1,\dots ,x_n),y) \simeq \Hom _C(x_1\otimes \dots \otimes x_n,y), \] and the left-hand side is the indicated multimorphism anima. □
Observation 14.4.7. Cocartesian transport in \(C^{\otimes }\) is compatible with finite products. More precisely, suppose that \(\alpha _j\colon I_j\to J_j\) are morphisms in \(\Span (\Fin )\) and that \(\phi _j\colon X_j\to Y_j\) are \(p_C\)-cocartesian lifts of \(\alpha _j\). Since the straightening of \(p_C\) preserves finite products, the product \[ \prod _j\phi _j\colon \prod _jX_j\longrightarrow \prod _jY_j \] is a \(p_C\)-cocartesian lift of the product \(\prod _j\alpha _j\). In particular, cocartesian transport along a forward span is computed separately over the elements of its target.
We now give a criterion for an \(\infty \)-operad to arise from a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category: its multimorphism functors must be corepresentable, and the universal multimorphisms must remain universal under substitution.
Definition 14.4.8. Let \(\Oo \) be an \(\infty \)-operad. A multimorphism \(\varphi \colon \{x_i\}_{i\in I}\to y\) corepresents multimorphisms out of \(\{x_i\}_{i\in I}\) if composition with \(\varphi \) induces an isomorphism \[ \Hom _{U(\Oo )}(y,z)\iso \Oo (\{x_i\}_{i\in I};z) \] for every color \(z\). The pair \((y,\varphi )\) is unique if it exists; we then denote its target by \(\bigotimes _{i\in I}x_i\) and refer to \(\varphi \) as the universal multimorphism for the tuple.
Suppose that every finite tuple of colors admits a universal multimorphism. For a map \(f\colon I\to J\) of finite sets, substituting the universal multimorphisms for the families \(\{x_i\}_{i\in f^{-1}(j)}\) into the universal multimorphism for their targets gives a multimorphism \[ \{x_i\}_{i\in I}\longrightarrow \bigotimes _{j\in J}\bigotimes _{i\in f^{-1}(j)}x_i. \] By the universal property of \(\bigotimes _{i\in I}x_i\), this determines a canonical map \[ \bigotimes _{i\in I}x_i\longrightarrow \bigotimes _{j\in J}\bigotimes _{i\in f^{-1}(j)}x_i. \]
Lemma 14.4.9. Let \(\Oo \) be an \(\infty \)-operad. Suppose that every finite tuple of colors admits a universal multimorphism and that the canonical map \[ \bigotimes _{i\in I}x_i\longrightarrow \bigotimes _{j\in J}\bigotimes _{i\in f^{-1}(j)}x_i \] is an isomorphism for every map \(f\colon I\to J\) of finite sets and every family \(\{x_i\}_{i\in I}\). Then \(p_{\Oo }\colon \Oo ^{\otimes }\to \Span (\Fin )\) is a cocartesian fibration, corresponding to a symmetric monoidal structure on \(U(\Oo )\).
Proof. For a forward span \(\alpha =(I\xleftarrow {=}I\xrightarrow {f}J)\) and colors \(\{x_i\}_{i\in I}\), put \(y_j:=\bigotimes _{i\in f^{-1}(j)}x_i\). The universal multimorphisms define a lift \(\varphi \colon \{x_i\}_{i\in I}\to \{y_j\}_{j\in J}\) of \(\alpha \). We show that it is cocartesian by checking that, for every span \(\beta =(J\xleftarrow {g}K\xrightarrow {h}L)\) and colors \(\{z_l\}_{l\in L}\), composition with \(\varphi \) induces an isomorphism \[ \Hom ^{\beta }_{\Oo ^{\otimes }}(\{y_j\},\{z_l\})\longrightarrow \Hom ^{\beta \circ \alpha }_{\Oo ^{\otimes }}(\{x_i\},\{z_l\}). \] By Lemma 14.1.10, this is the product over \(l\in L\) of the substitution maps \[ \Oo (\{y_{g(k)}\}_{k\in h^{-1}(l)};z_l)\longrightarrow \Oo (\{x_i\}_{(i,k)\in I\times _J h^{-1}(l)};z_l). \] Under the corepresenting isomorphisms, each is precomposition with the canonical map \[ \bigotimes _{(i,k)\in I\times _J h^{-1}(l)}x_i\longrightarrow \bigotimes _{k\in h^{-1}(l)}y_{g(k)}, \] which is an isomorphism by the hypothesis applied to the projection \(I\times _J h^{-1}(l)\to h^{-1}(l)\). Thus \(\varphi \) is cocartesian.
Backwards spans already admit cocartesian lifts. Since every span is a backwards span followed by a forward span and cocartesian morphisms compose, \(p_{\Oo }\) is a cocartesian fibration. By Lemma 14.4.4, its straightening preserves finite products and hence gives the asserted symmetric monoidal structure. □
14.4.2 Algebras over \(\infty \)-operads
Definition 14.4.10. Let \(\Oo \) be an \(\infty \)-operad and let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category. An \(\Oo \)-algebra in \(C\) is an operad morphism \(\Oo \to \Mm _C\). We write \[ \Alg _{\Oo }(C) := \Fun _{\Op _{\infty }}(\Oo , \Mm _C) \] for the \(\infty \)-category of \(\Oo \)-algebras in \(C\).
Example 14.4.11 (Commutative/associative algebras). Algebras over the \(\infty \)-operads \(\Comm \) and \(\Assoc \) are referred to as commutative algebras and associative algebras, respectively, and their \(\infty \)-categories are denoted by \[ \CAlg (C) := \Alg _{\Comm }(C) \qquadtext { and } \Alg (C) := \Alg _{\Assoc }(C). \]
Example 14.4.12 (Trivial algebras). Let \(D\) be an \(\infty \)-category. Applying Lemma 14.3.5 to the multimorphism operad \(\Mm _C\), we see that algebras over the trivial operad \(\Triv _D\) correspond to functors \(D \to C\): \[ \Alg _{\Triv _D}(C) \iso \Fun (D,C). \] In particular, taking \(D = *\) shows that a \(\Triv \)-algebra is simply an object of \(C\): \[ \Alg _{\Triv }(C) \iso C. \] Taking \(D = \emptyset \) shows that the \(\infty \)-category of \(\Triv _{\emptyset }\)-algebras is terminal.
Lemma 14.4.13 (Algebras in pointwise monoidal structure). Let \(C\) be a symmetric monoidal \(\infty \)-category, let \(I\) be an \(\infty \)-category, and let \(\Oo \) be an \(\infty \)-operad. Then an \(\Oo \)-algebra in \(\Fun (I,C)\) with the pointwise monoidal structure is the same data as a functor \(I \to \Alg _{\Oo }(C)\): there is an equivalence of \(\infty \)-categories \[ \Alg _{\Oo }(\Fun (I,C)) \iso \Fun (I,\Alg _{\Oo }(C)). \]
Proof. The pointwise symmetric monoidal structure of Example 14.4.2 is classified by the composite \[ \Span (\Fin )\xrightarrow {\Str ^{\cc }(p_C)} \Cat _{\infty }\xrightarrow {\Fun (I,-)}\Cat _{\infty }. \] By Proposition 24.2.4, its total category is \(\Span (\Fin )\times _{\Fun (I,\Span (\Fin ))} \Fun (I,C^{\otimes })\). Consequently, before imposing the finite-product condition, a functor over \(\Span (\Fin )\) from \(\Oo ^{\otimes }\) to this total category amounts to a functor \[ \Oo ^{\otimes }\longrightarrow \Fun (I,C^{\otimes }) \] whose composite with \(\Fun (I,p_C)\) is the constant \(I\)-diagram on \(p_{\Oo }\). Currying identifies these with functors \[ I\longrightarrow \Fun _{/\Span (\Fin )}(\Oo ^{\otimes },C^{\otimes }). \] Under this identification, preservation of finite products is pointwise in \(I\): the functor into the pointwise multimorphism operad is an operad map precisely when the corresponding functor \(\Oo ^{\otimes }\to C^{\otimes }\) is an operad map at every object of \(I\). Thus the equivalence restricts to the asserted equivalence of algebra categories. □