Proposition 17.2.13. Let \(\kappa\) be an elementary family of small categories such that any small category with strictly \(\kappa\)-small colimits is \(\kappa\)-filtered, then strictly \(\kappa\)-small categories. Then \(\kappa\) is localizing.

Proof

We consider a small category \(C\) with strictly \(\kappa\)-small colimits and \(W\) a family of morphisms in \(C\) that is stable under \(\kappa\)-small colimits in \(\Fun([1],C)\), with corresponding localization functor \[ \gamma\colon C\to L(C)\, . \] We already know that \(L(C)\) has finite colimits and that \(\gamma\) is right exact. Since the finite category \(\pushout\) is \(\kappa\)-small, the family of maps \(W\) is stable under pushouts. Therefore, for any object \(y\) of \(C\), the full subcategory \(W(y)\) of the slice \(C_{y/}\) whose objects are the pairs \((z,s)\) with \(s\colon y\to z\) a map in \(W\) defines a left calculus of fractions at \(y\) with respect to \(W\). We thus have an explicit formula for the mapping space of \(L(C)\), namely \[ \underset{(z,s)\colon W(y)}{\colim}\, \Hom_C(x,z)\simeq\Hom_{L(C)}(x,y) \] for any objects \(x,y\colon C^\simeq\). Moreover, it is easily seen that \(W(y)\) is stable under \(\kappa\)-small colimits in \(C_{y/}\). In particular, \(W(y)\) is \(\kappa\)-filtered. Therefore, for any \(\kappa\)-small category \(K\) and any functor \[ \varphi\colon K\to C \] with colimit \(\xi\) in \(C\) and any object \(y\) of \(C\) we have: \begin{align*} \underset{x\colon K\catop}{\lim}\, \Hom_{L(C)}(\varphi\catop(x),y) &= \underset{x\colon K\catop}{\lim}\, \Hom_{L(C)}(\varphi\catop(x),y)\\ &= \underset{x\colon K\catop}{\lim}\, \underset{(z,s)\colon W(y)}{\colim}\, \Hom_C(\varphi\catop(x),z)\\ &= \underset{(z,s)\colon W(y)}{\colim}\, \underset{x\colon K\catop}{\lim}\,\Hom_C(\varphi\catop(x),z)\\ &= \underset{(z,s)\colon W(y)}{\colim}\, \Hom_C(\xi,z)\\ &=\Hom_{L(C)}(\xi,y)\, . \end{align*} In other words, the colimit of \(\gamma\circ\varphi\) exists in \(L(C)\) and is nothing else than \(\gamma(\xi)\). We will now prove that the canonical functor \[ \gamma_*\colon L(\Fun(K,C))\to\Fun(K,L(C)) \] is an equivalence for any strictly \(\kappa\)-small category \(K\), where \(L(\Fun(K,C))\) is the localization of \(\Fun(K,C)\) by maps that are objectwise in \(W\). Since \(\Tw(K)\catop\) is strictly \(\kappa\)-small, any object of \(\Fun(K,C)\) is a strictly \(\kappa\)-small colimit of objects of the form \(x\otimes a\) with \(a\colon C\) and \(x\colon K\) (this follows from Proposition 12.9.1 applied to \(\Ind(C)\) through the full embedding of \(\Fun(K,C)\) into \(\Fun(K,\Ind(C))\)). Observe that the evaluation of \(x\otimes a\) at \(y\colon K^\simeq\) is the \(K(x,y)\)-indexed coproduct of copies of \(a\). The image of \(x\otimes a\) in \(\Fun(K,C)\) is thus \(x\otimes\gamma(a)\) since the localization functor \[ \Fun(K,C)\to L(\Fun(K,C)) \] commutes with strictly \(\kappa\)-small colimits. Therefore, in order to prove that \(\gamma_*\) is fully faithful, it suffices to prove that we have an equivalence of the form \[ \Hom(F,G)\to\Hom(\gamma_*(F),\gamma_*(G)) \] with \(F\) of the form \(F=x\otimes a\). Since the adjunction \[ x\otimes(-)\colon C\rightleftarrows\Fun(K,C)\colon\ev_x \] is compatible with maps that are objectwise in \(W\), it induces an adjunction of the form \[ x\otimes(-)\colon L(C)\rightleftarrows L(\Fun(K,C))\colon\ev_x \] by Lemma 14.1.5. Therefore, we have \[ \Hom_{L(\Fun(K,C))}(F,G)=\Hom_{L(C)}(\gamma(a),\gamma(G(x)))\, . \] Since \(\gamma_*(F)=x\otimes\gamma(a)\), we obiously have \[ \Hom_{\Fun(K,L(C))}(\gamma_*(F),\gamma_*(G))=\Hom_{L(C)}(\gamma(a),\gamma(G(x)))\, , \] which proves that \(\gamma_*\) is fully faithful. Since \(\gamma_*\) commutes with \(K\)-indexed colimits, it suffices to check that objects of the form \(x\otimes a\) with \(x\colon K\) and \(a\colon L(C)^\simeq\) are in the image of \[ (\gamma_*)^\simeq\colon L(\Fun(K,C))^\simeq\to\Fun(K,L(C))^\simeq\, . \] This follows right away from the fact that \[ K\times C^\simeq\to K\times L(C)^\simeq \] is a cover and that \(\gamma\) commutes with \(L\)-indexed colimits for \(L=K(x,y)\) for any \(y\colon K^\simeq\). This proves that \(\gamma_*\) is an equivalence of categories.

Now, the adjunction \[ \underset{K}{\colim}\, \colon \Fun(K,C)\rightleftarrows C\colon\mathrm{const}_K \] induces through Lemma 14.1.5 an adjunction of the form \[ \underset{K}{\mathrm{hocolim}}\, \colon L(\Fun(K,C))\rightleftarrows L(C)\colon\mathrm{const}_K\, . \] Identifying \(L(\Fun(K,C))\) and \(\Fun(K,L(C))\), the functor \(\mathrm{hocolim}_K\) yields the existence of the functor \[ \underset{K}{\colim}\, \colon \Fun(K,L(C))\to L(C)\, . \] This achieves the proof that strictly \(\kappa\)-small categories form a localizing family of small categories.

From Section 17.2, Small subuniverses.